DynamoBen wrote:C5 was changed to 4700uF/16V.Thanks for the explanation, as you know I'm a hobbyist so at times I'm not "in the know" about the proper method(s) to make component selection. This is why I'm having this schematic reviewed, besides I get to learn in the process. 🙂
The 4700 should work, although it turns out that I made an error in calculation (by using the calculator on the PC without putting my glasses on first). The output of the equation should be .0044, not .00177. This doesn't leave much margin (if any) at 50 Hz, although it should be OK for 60 Hz.
It may be possible to significantly reduce the value of this part (and hence the physical size and cost), but that depends on knowing how much current is needed for the 5V parts vs the 3.3V parts.
P. Short wrote:
It may be possible to significantly reduce the value of this part (and hence the physical size and cost), but that depends on knowing how much current is needed for the 5V parts vs the 3.3V parts.
The 5V regulator has a max. current output of 1 amp, I believe that this is also true for the 3.3V regulator. I haven't calculated current consumption of the design.
It's the current draw of the design that I was asking about. Is there any significant current draw at 5V, or is that just for the LCD and it's contrast control?
The only stuff on the 5V side is the LCD (switches), 75176 (and isolation), and the dimmer control (4094s & HCT125 ).
And of course, all of the 3v stuff comes from the 5
n1ist wrote:And of course, all of the 3v stuff comes from the 5
True. Frankly I'm not sure the "correct" way to calculate my power consumption. In the past some have told me to calculate the max consumption for every IC from the datasheets but doesn't include the loss from discrete components.
The Helix controller is using larger regulators and it has about the same number of components give or take...
From Mouser:
511-LD1085V50 - Low Drop Voltage Regulators/Drivers 5.0V 3.0A Positive
621-AP1084T33L-U - Voltage Regulators - Linear LDO BI 5.0A 1.3V 12V 1.25V 3.3V FIX
Same real estate as the regular regs.
budude wrote:
511-LD1085V50 - Low Drop Voltage Regulators/Drivers 5.0V 3.0A Positive
621-AP1084T33L-U - Voltage Regulators - Linear LDO BI 5.0A 1.3V 12V 1.25V 3.3V FIX
Changed.
The components that want to be at 5V (the LCD and the SSRs) will draw just over 200 mA at max (200 mA for the SSRs, under 5 mA for the LCD and it's bias circuitry). I doubt that the rest of the parts would go as high as 100 mA, so you could change the transformer to a 3FD-316 (same package, same price). This would reduce the input cap value down to about 1000 uF, which is a bit cheaper and smaller. This does increase the power dissipation on the 5V regulator up to about 1W, so you might need a better heat sink.
Another thing to consider is to change the input to the 3.3V regulator so that it runs off the same input as the 5V regulator, and to change the DC-DC converter to run from 3.3V instead of 5V. This would move some of the thermal load from the 5V to the 3.3V regulator, equalizing things a bit.
As a side note, you are right at the limit for the current through the MC4094 ground pin, based on the ST spec (6 mA * 8 outputs).
In any case, don't change the schematic yet...the numbers need to be firmed up first.
