Hello!
I have a working custom board design that I've put on a perfboard and now want to put it on a PCB. I have no problem etching the PCB, but I can't get the holes drilled and plated right (it's a 2-sided board, so if the hole is drilled off by a hair then it pushes out the copper on the other side of the board, which invokes much cussing which results in me getting yelled at by my wife).
Do you have any recommendations for using PCB manufacturers and related design software? I've never used a PCB manufacturer, so I don't know who to use or what to expect... I've heard of ExpressPCB, but I don't know if they're the best or most economical one to use. I like how ExpressPCB has board design software integrated into their service (I'm currently using PaintShop Pro paint program, which most PCB manufacturers probably can't use). Do you guys and gals have any recommendations, or do you etch your own boards?
Thanks in advance for the info!
I will etch at home when its 1 sided and I only need one board, beyond that I send it out to a board house. Everyone has their favorites and it depends on how long you are willing to wait, what you are willing to spend on software, and the quantity of boards you want produced.
Personally I use PCBFabExpress, they are based in CA (boards are made in CA also) the big price break comes at around 5 boards. They have an online tools for pricing.
To use a conventional board house you need to be able to send them a gerber file (some take Eagle files), I use Diptrace. Diptrace is free up to 200pins but won't produce a gerber unless you buy the software. I believe they have a not-for-profit version that includes 1000pins for around $100-150. A free alternative is freepcb ( http://www.freepcb.com/ ) you loss schematic capture but is does create gerbers and is easy to use. Finally many here use EagleCAD which also is pin limited for the free version but I believe does create gerbers. Personally I found it unconventional and thus difficult to learn but others would disagree, its worth a look.
Beyond those options ExpressPCB works, I personally haven't used them. The software is free and I've heard the quality of the boards are good. The only issue I have with them is you have to use them, their files aren't easily converted to other formats and other board houses won't accept them.
Another alternative is Advanced Circuits. They also provide free software, PCB Artist, but it's for their service only. The software is nice, because you can print easily for home-etching, but doesn't give you gerbers - you need to use their service. I don't know how the pricing is, but if I recall, ukewarrior used it on his SSRNeons, and the boards are excellent. Also, if you have a business license and get approved, you can get the first $500 order for free, but it's their "premium service", and a lot of the $500 is eaten up in set up, but you can still end up with a lot of product. I have Eagle, and ExpressPCB, but use PCB Artist almost exclusively, because it's really easy.
Roger
Eagle has a board size limitation also - but - for free I guess you can't complain much. I'll second PCB Artist - the library is OK (they claim to have the largest) and it's easier to use than Eagle IMO. I haven't tried getting boards made yet but might down the road.
One thing I like about PCB Artist, is you can cut and paste components between boards. Not sure if you can in the others. The library didn't have a good RJ45 jack, but someone made one, and I got it on a board. I've c'n'p'd it on all my boards, no hassle.
R
I guess it boils down to how often you plan on making boards and how often you want to capture a schematic. I'm work on several project a year so Diptrace was worth the money because of the short learning curve and capabilities.
If this is an infrequent occur the free options like PCB artist or PCBexpress may be the way to go.
I use Kicad, which is also free and generates Gerber files (the industry standard PCB file format). For fab, I have used Gold Phoenix (www.goldphoenixpcb.biz) and Advanced Circuits (www.4pcb.com). I have also used ExpressPCB; their miniboard service is a nice option, but you are locked into their service if you use their software unless you buy Gerbers for $65 from them. For home etch, I use Kicad for design and toner transfer for the boards - the local Radio Shack (sorry, "The Shack" now...) still has etchant though there are cheaper etchant options out there.
/mike
Thanks for the suggestions! I'll probably just go with ExpressPCB, since I'm only going to make about eight boards. They're 16-channel boards, so that would be a TON of drilling if I tried to make them myself!
By the way, I know how to make ferric chloride etchant. It's a bit cheaper than buying it, and it's not that hard to make. Anyone interested in knowing?
Pine Fire,
Yes, I'd like to know if it's not too difficult; elsewise, I'll stick to my peroxide/muriatic acid stuff.
Throw the details at me.
Alright Blackbeard, I'll post how to make ferric chloride. I'll go ahead and write a new post, since this post doesn't really have anything to do with making etchant and a lot of people may pass up this info as a result. So stay tuned, post coming soon!

