I think I caused the derail...
Robert
Phew.. sorry for the lengthy delay here. Family commitments etc etc. I finally got back to trying to lay out this board. The intent is to create a DMX2NRF bridge, that will fit nicely in an enclosure, similar to what I did making my USB2DMX adapter. In fact, I think I'm going to be using the same blue plastic boxes for the effort. I've already proven that I can get the PIC (16F1823) receive DMX (32 channels worth is all I'm tracking at the moment), and to talk to the NRF24L01. I had taken my PCB's that were supposed to drive some RFM12B modules, and just barnacled a ribbon cable to the pads, in order to connect to the NRF module. So this is really just a packaging exercise, with a small bit of development outstanding (mostly using the DIYC "start" code to encode a "program start address" command).
In addition I opted to download a copy of the POVRAY tracer for use with eagle. *WOW* that is pretty cool. With some minor changes to the default config, I can generate the following image to show what the board should look like when I'm done.
At the moment it is dual footprint to accommodate DMX and/or renard, but I'm considering dropping the REN support. The RJ45's are pre-wired for DMX config, and I'm not sure that I will have room to put the jumper blocks in place to permit the user to change from DMX to REN. Lastly, this is intended (ultimately) to be a transceiver board, in that I plan to tweak the FW so that it will auto-detect the DMX and opt to run as DMX2NRF, or a NRF2DMX.
You can see where the NRF module will attach, and I've opted to use SMD component for the 3.3v regulator section, so that when complete, that there will be room for the external antenna to attach to the box/case in that upper right corner of the enclosure (hope that made sense.. it's 2:00am and I'm starting to see squirrelly).
Andrew:
That rendering sure is pretty.
Looks like you're again targeting a Hammond project enclosure?
Don't know that I'm a potential customer, but I continue to rail against SMD (and there are a lot more there than just the regulator) ... I'd think that the footprint of a TO-92 (like the MCP1700) would be smaller than an SOT-23 ... but I'm too lazy to look it up.
Anyway, looks cool. Best of luck on the project.
\dmc
I have one question why? This already exists with the rf1s from komby. Don't let me stop you though.
It is a good idea to have a pic version of the nrf stuff though that for sure.
dmcole wrote:
Don't know that I'm a potential customer, but I continue to rail against SMD (and there are a lot more there than just the regulator) ... I'd think that the footprint of a TO-92 (like the MCP1700) would be smaller than an SOT-23 ... but I'm too lazy to look it up.Anyway, looks cool. Best of luck on the project.
\dmc
It is just not that hard its all about having good solder and flux mainly. I for one would much rather solder a 32pin qfn that a 32 pin dip It is so much faster and thats with a normal iron; I don't use hot air or an oven.
But i am with you when it comes to any 2 pin package resistor/cap/etc there a pain. just use a standard disk or or vertical resistor takes up the same space but on 2 sides.
I think the SOT-23 and TO-92 footprints could co-exist if plate-thrus were used instead of the land pads. Same trick can be used for the smd resistors(?) where a 1/8th watt on end fits in the space of a SMD resistor.
However, I do not mind SMD (0805 or bigger) as I actually have taken the time to "learn a word processor program rather than sticking to a typewriter"... 😉 I've invested my $10 in a mag hood, good tweezers, solder paste and tiny tip on my good iron. It is amazing what you can learn to do if you HAVE to do so!! I think the biggest fear with SMD is that you HAVE to individually solder each connection (you don't) rather than "en-mass" like you end up doing. I've found that grabbing a SMD resistor or cap, tacking one side with paste, then tacking the other side is quicker than thru-hole with forming leads, placing on board, tacking, adjusting, soldering, and clipping. SMD is cleaner as well.
Keep in mind that a SMD only takes up space on ONE side of the board and a thru-hole takes up space on both sides so that could be where the space issue comes in.

