PropController Ethe...
 
Notifications
Clear all

PropController Ethernet - Construction question

31 Posts
8 Users
0 Reactions
17.6 K Views
RPM
Posts: 1080
 RPM
(@rpm)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
DynamoBen wrote:It's installed correctly but two pins are swapped (2 & 3) on the PCB. Long story short, the board will function correctly even with this mistake.

That transistor is used to toggle the reset on the prop when programming it. I've used this design with this mistake for 2 years and have never had an issue.

Sound kind of like my issue with my Propeller based board, but mine had the V+ and V- to the Propeller IC backwards... this was due to an issue with the library file I was using.
I had done a pre-check of voltages before inserting the IC's, but still missed the swapped pins.
Testament to the durability of the Propeller, even after running the board with the voltages reversed to the IC, it still works! I can say I was amazed at this!

Ben, if you are going to change the layout of the PC board, might I suggest you feed the input of the 3.3 regulator from the output of the 5v regulator?
Right now the 3.3V regulator is fed from the same source as the 5V regulator, and on my board the 3.3v reg seems to run a little hot.


Reply
Posts: 2630
(@dynamoben)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
RPM wrote:
Ben, if you are going to change the layout of the PC board, might I suggest you feed the input of the 3.3 regulator from the output of the 5v regulator?
Right now the 3.3V regulator is fed from the same source as the 5V regulator, and on my board the 3.3v reg seems to run a little hot.

I did try that on one of my boards and they both run hotish. Beyond that I'm indifferent about changing it.


Reply
budude
Posts: 10400
(@budude)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

I would be hesitant to pull the 3.3v off the 5v regulator as I prefer to supply 5v to the daughterboards and we have to ensure we keep enough reserve to power all of them. It may be more than enough but we should probably keep power management in mind. I'm guessing also that powering the 3.3v bus in addition to external boards may just shift the heat from the 3.3v regulator to the 5v regulator.

I'm wondering if there are any drop-in switching style regulator modules that could be used? I know I used one for my Ren48LSD v3b board that worked very well (at 5v) - perhaps they have one for 3.3v as well.


Reply
Posts: 352
(@pmscientist)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
budude wrote:I'm guessing also that powering the 3.3v bus in addition to external boards may just shift the heat from the 3.3v regulator to the 5v regulator.

Yah, this seems the crux of the issue. I've been seriously considering this question for another project. From a pure thermal perspective, it would be more efficient to shed the heat from the large voltage drop once as opposed to twice. On the other hand, it probably doesn't take all that much 3.3V current, to reach the point where the additional heat sink capacity capacity needed may outweigh any potential efficiency gains.

Just as an example, using a 12V source and assuming input current draw of 1A@5V and 0.5A@3.3V, you only shed approx. 0.95W less in a cascaded regulator configuration than in a parallel configuration. However, this savings comes at the cost of adding about 2.8W of heat to lose at the 5V regulator. In this case, I don't see a strong case for a redesign by rearranging linear regulators.

budude wrote:I'm wondering if there are any drop-in switching style regulator modules that could be used? I know I used one for my Ren48LSD v3b board that worked very well (at 5v) - perhaps they have one for 3.3v as well.

You hit the nail on the head there. Moving to a switching regulator would be the way to go, should a redesign of the power supply be considered. There are definitely 3.3V switching regulators, and regulators with 2+ outputs that can do both in the same package. The pitfall with switching controllers seems to be choosing one that may add more complexity to the supply than is really necessary for the application. That looks easy to do with the multiple output regulators. There is alot to be said for the simplicity of linear dropout ICs.


Reply
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Wow, all this development stuff is going so quickly that by the time I get a chance to ding around with the PropController boards, the originals I bought will be so far out of date that they probably won't work. They sure are super-looking boards, though! 🙂


Reply
Page 3 / 7
Share: