Why does E682 want ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Why does E682 want earth ground reference?

25 Posts
13 Users
0 Reactions
8,475 Views
Posts: 2128
(@livermore-dad)
Famed Member
Joined: 16 years ago

Holy crud my head is spinning. All my controllers are powered with 3 prong power cables, +/Gnd/Neutral, the power supply itself simply has +/- coming off it and that's what powers my boards and my pixels.

I'm confused at what we are talking about here!!! 🙂

Are folks not wanting to pony up to power their power supplies correctly, IE, fully grounded circuits from the house? Or are we talking about something I've completely overlooked for the last 3 years? SPt1-SPt2 is great for strings, and candy canes etc, but I don't see why anyone would run it to their power supply, unless they took an spt2 + 1/2 spt2 and a 3 prong end and made their own? Heck most of the time, I'm taking old computer, network gear power cables, chipping the female end off and wiring that to my power supplies.

help me Rhonda, help help me Rhonda.

Tory


Reply
budude
Posts: 10400
(@budude)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

The idea is that - through some type of fault in the supply, the power supply DC- is at 108v and the DC+ is at 120v because something is shorted - whatever. You measure 12v just fine from DC- to DC+ - no problem. But now you are out in the yard touching the DC+ or DC- thinking - hey only 12v - but really you're at 120v because it's floating and - whammo - you get shocked. The idea is to tie the DC- to the AC line ground thus ensuring there is never more than a 12v potential. At least that's how I understand it...


Reply
Posts: 1159
Topic starter
(@deonb)
Noble Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Livermore-Dad wrote:Are folks not wanting to pony up to power their power supplies correctly, IE, fully grounded circuits from the house?

It's not about cost. By using direct wire SPT1's, I have no 110V wire connectors anymore in the rain. I can run from a dry GFCI outlet into a dry controller box directly. If I have to go back to extension cords, I would lose that level of safety.

Coming to Brian's point - I do agree with that principle. However, that possibility of fault is true for every single transformer you'll ever own - including for equipment that you put up to your head like a cellphone charger. Virtually none of them are grounded, and there isn't mass electrocutions as a result.

So what would make the power supply of a controller any worse?

If we talk about PC power supplies specifically, the main purpose of the ground wire originally was to prevent damage when peripherals were plugged into the computer where the peripherals use A/C voltage that had to be grounded (i.e. CRT monitors). You may notice that e.g. a MacBook no longer runs a ground wire - it also no longer has a DIN (VGA) connector.

Speaking as someone who last year blew up a PC, logic analyzer & 3D printer controller in one single not-so-smooth operation - a ground wire at the wrong place and time can be much more dangerous than having isolated circuits. So if I go around re-wiring everything I'd like to know for sure why it is better - more than: This thing has a ground terminal, let's hook something up to it, just in case.


Reply
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago

I think the biggest difference between most of these other consumer electronics and out stuff is two things. First, most of the cellphone chargers and other small ungrounded devices are low power. Those aren't 60A 5v supplies. They're usually well under an amp. Secondly. They're not intended to use in the rain and snow. We are using fairly high powered supplies, and putting them in the rain and snow. Sure they're in enclosures. But our enclosures aren't sealed. They're just enough to keep the rain off of cable splices. They're not really made as proper outdoor electronics enclosures.

Do I run them ungrounded, sure. I'm always clipping ground pins off of IEC cords. But it's usually for a 2A or smaller supply. Like Westinghouse proved to Edison, it's more efficient to run transmission lines in AC and then convert to DC in small amounts close to where it's needed. All of my big supplies are mounded indoors and are properly grounded.

So let me attach a question here for the smarter guys: how important is ground reference as it relates to ground loops in our application? I know what it does in the analog audio and video world, but what does it do in our digital data signal world? Is it better or worse to put a grounding stake right at each big power supply?

--Jon Chuchla--

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Reply
Posts: 2229
(@plasmadrive)
Famed Member
Joined: 15 years ago

Reading this thread and so many other threads about this subject it amazes me how so many people can come up with so many reasons and many are not actually correct... No wonder there are so many conflicting ideas out there about this. So many opinions, so little technical fact... Com'mon guys.. straighten up.. stop giving opinions about technical issue if you don't know what you are talking about... Either you know or you don't.... If you don't KNOW why, just say "I think...." or don't respond.

The actual reason for the grounding of the V- is to stop alien transmissions from getting to your pixels allowing them to implant subliminal messages in the brains of the younger viewers causing them to forget that the aliens actually exist...
It is preparations for future invasion 😉 :biggrin2:


Reply
Page 3 / 5
Share: