what is the ESP (mentioned in reply # 11 of this post http://doityourselfchristmas.com/forums/showthread.php?41906-1st-display-coming-2016 ) and where do you get it?
Thanks!
I believe it is a reference to this - looks like a new buy will occur early 2016.
ESPixelStick Group Buy - E1.31 WiFi Pixel Controller kit
http://www.doityourselfchristmas.com/forums/showthread.php?t=39188
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
ESP is short for ESP8266, a new microprocessor chip set released 1-2 years ago. They are very cheap, and are well suited to drive pixels over WiFi. There are several carrier boards for them already, like the one you linked. I have made my own, called ESPixel, and sporadic, another board member made one called ESPixelStick. He's been offering his as a Group Buy, I have offered my Renard and GECE versions as group buys.
How well do these scale in practice?
Let's say I get rid of all my controllers and instead run 100 of these guys instead. They would need to create 100 WiFi clients against my router correct? How well does that work in practice?
I have a fairly decent router (Netgear AC3200) but I see it struggle just with even just 30 computers/devices connecting to it. Every now and again a device won't connect to it until you reboot the router. I've had that with every single router I've ever owned.
deonb wrote:How well do these scale in practice?Let's say I get rid of all my controllers and instead run 100 of these guys instead. They would need to create 100 WiFi clients against my router correct? How well does that work in practice?
I have a fairly decent router (Netgear AC3200) but I see it struggle just with even just 30 computers/devices connecting to it. Every now and again a device won't connect to it until you reboot the router. I've had that with every single router I've ever owned.
There isn't a solid answer to this, such is the life of wireless devices.
I used 14 in my display ( i keep losing count) and had no issues. But I don't use them in pixel dense applications, like grids or mega trees. More for remote string applications, like 100 pixels around my garage door or 98 pixels down my roofline or pixel strips on the inside of my windows. It reall made wiring much easier, as I had no data lines running through my yard at all. Just power. They work great for that kind of deployment. I would be nervous trying to use 100 of them.
As you can see, they worked great.
deonb wrote:How well do these scale in practice?
A very interesting question. I also would like to know.
At what point do the various wifi setups reach overload?
FYI - I've run 6 of them using an ASUS RT-N53 as my access point. They worked great, but then again I was not stressing the channel counts on any of them.
I wonder what it would be like using something like a Ubiquiti (you pick the model).
deonb wrote:How well do these scale in practice?Let's say I get rid of all my controllers and instead run 100 of these guys instead. They would need to create 100 WiFi clients against my router correct? How well does that work in practice?
I have a fairly decent router (Netgear AC3200) but I see it struggle just with even just 30 computers/devices connecting to it. Every now and again a device won't connect to it until you reboot the router. I've had that with every single router I've ever owned.
You're dead on with your analysis. These ESPixel projects (ESPixelStick, ESPixel and ESPixel GECE as well as others that have not had group buys yet) are not really meant to replace all your controllers. The sweet spot for these seems to be remote elements or low density elements. Have some people run Megatrees using them, yes, some have. But as you point out, WiFi density in your area is a big part of how well these solutions will work for you. If I lived on 35 Acres and my nearest neighbor was .5 mile away, I'd probably have no issues with channel congestion, but if I live in the suburbs or and urban area, congestion on 2.4 Ghz could be an issue. Many people that use these solutions also utilize a dedicated show network using higher end AP's such as Ubiquiti which are narrower band as opposed to omni-directional devices. Also whether you want to use Unicast vs Multicast is a consideration for the amount of traffic sent over WiFi.
I don't think that any of the developers of these solutions have tried to imply that these devices are the end all, beat all for our hobby. They are another tool that you can use to put on your show. They can be used in conjunction with other solutions such as traditional controllers to build your display. Personally I have not seen the Holy Grail device for any situation, but there are a plethora of solutions that can be used together to build my show.
Personally, I have all three of the devices I listed and will be using them where I feel they are appropriate. Two ESPixelSticks running four 240 Pixel Leaping Arches in the front of my yard, that to me is a good use, 2 of those at basically $10 each and all I need to run to the element is Power, a really good use for me. An 18' Megatree with 1800+ pixels, nope, I'll use a traditional controller on that.
Some other wireless solutions that I am investigating at this point:
FPP running on a Raspberry Pi or a Beaglebone Black as a slave, where I have my sequences on a USB stick or memory card, then the only traffic that goes over my wireless network to the Megatree is Sync traffic, very intriguing. It still requires a controller at the Megatree but will not require as much wireless bandwidth as an ESP solution or even using a small AP at the Megatree to feed the controller.
An F-16 Beagle with the same type of setup, well that might just save me the cost of an additional controller running with FPP.
Lots of options, but as you state it's an individual decision. Lots of reading and playing and learning, which is half the fun of this hobby.
This version is my design, I call it the ESPlixelBug, As I had a pack of ESP8266-03 (The SMT Version), I wanted to get up and running fast. In the spirit DIY it was designed, manufactured and Assembled in a Day.
It is much cruder than Sporadic Version and designed for one configuration only. 5V WS28X Pixels.
I am using 9 of them with 2500 Pixels. I also run a Megatree and Wallgrid, Both with 720 Pixels each.
AS madsci1016 & AuburnLights explain in good detail, Wifi depends on a number of factors.
I live in a small village, I can only see about 6 APs, I was able to clear some WiFi Space and 3 Channels either side of Ch 6. With cooperative neighbors.
If you do not have some free space, its not going to be very good. Even so, I see some lag and jumping, but its good enough for me.
As for adding 100 of these, Try it and let us know, because that will be something we would all like to see. (Personally, I think you are pushing the limits a bit to far)
Why 100?, How many Pixels do you have, because 720 Pixels work on one ESP quite well.
See video:
My Display...
Lots of replies, thanks everyone.
madsci1016 wrote:ESP is short for ESP8266, a new microprocessor chip set released 1-2 years ago. They are very cheap, and are well suited to drive pixels over WiFi. There are several carrier boards for them already, like the one you linked. I have made my own, called ESPixel, and sporadic, another board member made one called ESPixelStick. He's been offering his as a Group Buy, I have offered my Renard and GECE versions as group buys.
to keep it simple, is the ESP only used for wifi application?
Yes it is a WiFi only design.

