Technicolor quality...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Technicolor quality?

256 Posts
45 Users
0 Reactions
83.4 K Views
jklingert
Posts: 1767
(@jklingert)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago

To be honest, it sounds like it was not really just a bad batch of ICs. There were several different ICs listed in this thread that failed, and there were no waves of other WS2811 IC failures reported in other pixels, just the Technicolor pixels. A lot of the other failures that happened this year in other pixels were people who used silicone molded pixels, and they are known to be problematic with water intrusion.

It is more likely that there were a number of failure modes for the Technicolor pixels and the fact that they were a new design with a new molding might also point to mechanical failure and not just failure of the electronics. Folks should look at what is different about these pixels to find for reasons they failed. Zach posted on Facebook that there were issues with the molding ripping the pads and wires off the pcbs and that there were manufacturing changes midstream. The different heavy molding compound, the compressive stresses from the lens and locking ring are unique to these pixels and may help lead to some of the failures.

Until someone really does reverse engineering on a handful of the bad pixels, it will be hard to tell what really took them out. Lot's of speculation and comments from a vendor who is likely facing tens of thousands of dollars (or more!) in bad product shipped. The Technicolor group buy was almost 500 strings alone! I'm not looking to place blame, just help people learn what to lookout for in the future. Pixels are a massive expense and no one wants to spend thousands on pixels to have them fail.

Counterfeit, bad clone or recycled ICs are an issue that all electronic industries are facing with parts out of China now. http://spectrum.ieee.org/computing/hardware/counterfeit-chips-on-the-rise or http://spectrum.ieee.org/semiconductors/processors/the-hidden-dangers-of-chopshop-electronics Even the US Military has been burned. Take a look at how many clone pixel ICs have popped up on the market, it is possible that Ray's suppliers may also have received or used bad parts. No one has shared a circuit diagram of the pcb, it sounds like there were missing resistors that the datasheet for the WS2811 called for, hopefully there were no other electrical design issues. Still not sure why they are moving the wires around on the new design, was there a manufacturing issue with the wiring shorting out the 12v and the data line?

The quality of pixels have shot up over the last three years and most folks had very good success this year with other pixel designs. The first wave of silicone pixels 3 years ago were a complete disaster. They have gotten better, but they still tend to be more problematic.

Hopefully Timon and others can help sort out the underlying issues so that the quality of the pixels can all go up next year. This is a learning exercise for the community, just like most folks learned about the importance of waterproofing 3 years ago.

In the meanwhile, caveat emptor on any non epoxy pixel design...


Reply
dsmjuggalo
Posts: 663
(@dsmjuggalo)
Prominent Member
Joined: 15 years ago

Here's a couple pics in my phone.


Reply
Posts: 23
(@hauvega)
Eminent Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Here are some pictures of my tc failures.

1210 13
1210 10
1217 8

I have some more shots on my photobucket account. The link is http://s577.photobucket.com/user/Hauvega/slideshow/Pixel%20problems


Reply
MindTrik
Posts: 1542
Topic starter
(@mindtrik)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago

did you figure out exactly what the failure causes were?...are yours the only ones to melt/catch fire?


Reply
Posts: 23
(@hauvega)
Eminent Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Mine did not melt. I figure mine had moisture inside. I had some with injection molding issues where the pcb was forced out of position. I did clean most of them up and coated them. I replaced about 10 ics on others that quit receiving and transmitting data. The 12v leaked over to the data line and killed some of the chips(low resistance on data to gnd measurements).


Reply
MindTrik
Posts: 1542
Topic starter
(@mindtrik)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago

so timons rework of how the wire is run would fix the V leak


Reply
Posts: 23
(@hauvega)
Eminent Member
Joined: 18 years ago

That would fix that problem. I have some of the v leak on my 12v square resin filled pixels. I still think if moisture still is present, the problems are not going away. It will take longer to fail. I would like to know the type of conformal coating used, the temperature of the injected material. I would like to see if some of the new test pixels taken apart to see if the coating is applied. I would like to see some outdoor tests on the strings in various environments for an extended duration.


Reply
Posts: 214
(@gary-martin)
Estimable Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Question: Assuming the material used on the wire insulator is different from the injection molded plastic of the outer case, has anyone check to see if the wire and case have different contraction rates when they get frigid cold?

I'm wondering if the wire insulator contracts faster than the case, leaving an opening for water intrusion?


Reply
Posts: 154
 zman
(@zman)
Estimable Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Guys, this thread has been very informative.

Thanks for the diligence of info. What I was not able to get out of Ray in my communication with him, is what type of testing and QA went into these pixels. He told me he personally tested the batch I got, which was 60 strings worth (2520 pixels). I argued that he if he had tested them as he said he did, he could not have not seen issues. My strings were in the elements since late October, and even my first few test runs, I saw failures.

What if any is known about how the extreme temps affect these overall. Hopefully the kinks can be worked out, as I really like this form factor. Those that I know who got the 5V version, have seen very few failures.


Reply
timon
Posts: 2149
(@timon)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago

The new PCB is a little larger and it's thicker now that is uses a 0.031 board instead of a 0.015 so that will help. The pads are now much larger so the wires should not pull away. I'll talk to Ray about the speed of injection. It's AC careful balance of temperature and pressure/injection pressure. If you run hotter it takes less pressure but you risk parts and wire with the hotter temperature.

The one with water damage, we're the wires spliced? We've seen water get into the pixels through the wires.


Reply
Page 15 / 26
Share: