This was the video I was referencing. They like to twist the information they are giving in their video a bit lol.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uiUYCw7aO-o
Litebrite wrote:This was the video I was referencing. They like to twist the information they are giving in their video a bit lol.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uiUYCw7aO-o
Controllers have their pros and cons. As the user you need to determine which works best for you. There is nothing wrong with the HC controllers. They just haven’t had the features of the Falcons. I have a HC controller in my garage as my test controller. It works fine. But for my show I use Falcons. Because I use virtual strings and I don’t believe HC controllers can do virtual strings.there may be a way around it with HC but I don’t know. Also David gives great support and this forum is an awesome resource for Falcons. Of course HC is going to slant their video in favor of their controllers. But as an end user it is up to us to look at what best fits our needs. Be it Falcons, Kulp’s, HC, Hinks, Sans or the others. All good choices but what works best for the individuals needs.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I am not a fan of HC especially their marketing practices so I won’t be considering them.
Litebrite wrote:Why does no one mention the Holiday Coro controllers? I watched some videos, made by Holiday Corp so very biased, but they compare the Falcon to their flex system. They make some pretty good points about their system. Any thoughts?
I usually don't post, but seeing some of the replies to this question has urged me to speak out.
My 2 cents as to why HolidayCoro controllers are not mentioned on this web site is because over the years this website has become mainly a Falcon based community.
Since I retired, I have focused on designing products for this hobby. I have elected not to do my own Sales/Marketing. I sell my controllers and accessories through HolidayCoro - so I wish to comment on some of the replies to the question asked.
#1 "reverse engineered knockoff of the falcon controller".
These words imply a direct copy of a design that is then sold at a lower price. This is not the case.
A better statement of fact would be -- "Improved upon weakness found in a competitor's product or implemented new ideas introduced in a competitor's product".
There is nothing wrong with this - this occurs in almost every business in the USA.
As an example (you can go back into the 2016 posts and follow this if you like) - David Pitts had released his specifications on the Falcon 2 and was taking orders. No Falcon 2 productions had shipped yet. I released my HinksPix16 controller for sale and published it's specifications in a post on this website. My HinksPix16 had two (2) features the Falcon 2 did not have: WIFI and a Ethernet Switch. Within days of my post, David announced the specification his new Falcon 3 (remember Falcon 2 had yet to ship production units). The Falcon 3 now included the features of WIFI and an Ethernet Switch.
The best compliment someone can give you is to recognize something you have done and either copy it or improve upon it.
Another example - David Pitts released a "Smart Differential Receiver". Great idea. In 2019, I released my own version of a Smart Receiver which addresses several weakness I perceived in David's design. Did I reverse engineer it - NO. Did I improve upon it - I think so.
#2 HolidayCoro's Flex System:
Falcon had the capability to offer expansion - no other controller offered that. The weakness was in the execution of expansion - namely - how do you package all of the boards and power associated with expansion.
HolidayCoro's Flex system is a system design approach to address that weakness thereby providing a more compact end-item package at a lower cost to the user. The videos and written comparisons are attempting to convey where those improvements were made.
#3 "Can drive 1000 pixels per port":
As far as I know, Falcon and my HinksPix16 and EasyLights16 are the only controllers that can do this. I've now come to look at this specification as a "specmanship statement". Can the controllers do this - YES - but how important is it when looking at the total display/show implementation. When designing a product or designing a display based on controllers, you have to look at the trade-offs that must be taken into account. If you elect to drive 1000 pixels from a single controller's port you must also accept the fact that your shows "frame rate" drops to a minimum of 50 milliseconds and you have a TON of power injection that must also be designed in. My latest controller - HinksPix PRO - provides 48 ports with a maximum of 680 pixels at any one port. I don't believe there are a lot of users who want to drive 1000 pixels from a ports and have elected to use the controller's resources elsewhere.
Newcomers to this hobby should look at what controller's features/specification are important to their implementation.
#4 "virtual strings"
My HinksPix16 and EasyLights16 offered the same capability but I called it by a different name. The controllers offered in 2016 needed that capability because software tools like "xlights" had not yet been released/developed and the controller was the only place to provide that feature/capability.
Today, my HinksPix PRO does NOT include that capability because technology has changed from 2016 to today making it much better for the user to implement that feature in software like "xlights" than in the controller. As technology changes, products should also change to take advantage of advancements in "other" products that are associated with their own.
Conclusion:
I have attempted to state some points/facts using my controllers for comparisons. HolidayCoro sells their brand of controllers "AlphaPix" but they also sell my "Hinkle Line of Controllers".
When a newcomer is looking to choose a controller, there are multiple controllers to select from. They all have their own set of PROs and CONs and their associated price points. The best controller for an application two years ago my no longer be the best choice today based on technology changes.
I would hope people on this forum would help people select what is best for the newcomer's wants/needs and not be biased based on their own past experience/selections.
Again - just my 2 cents.
Thanks
I too would say that the entire run of this hobby has been folks releasing a 'product' and someone else following on with a derivative product.
This goes all the back to the entire series and run of the RENARD controllers.
Even the SSR's went through this process.
We also have this TODAY as a very active set of "Pixel Stick" controllers available from multiple vendors.
So, why the animosity towards Joe's controllers?
It really isn't fair.
But! I will say this. And to be very clear...this is my opinion alone.
I think Joe's controllers would see a better adoption rate if they weren't sold through Holiday Coro.
There... I said what I know others are thinking.
I think you hitched your wagon to the wrong horse.
I am not going to bring up the past hurts that folks have with HolidayCoro. Not the point here.
I for one, want to see as many alternatives for controllers as possible.
I believe this drives innovation and lower prices.
Again, I would point to the pixel sticks as an example.
I'm not trying to start a flame war here. I would however like to encourage as many options as possible!
JHinkle wrote:I usually don't post, but seeing some of the replies to this question has urged me to speak out.My 2 cents as to why HolidayCoro controllers are not mentioned on this web site is because over the years this website has become mainly a Falcon based community.
Since I retired, I have focused on designing products for this hobby. I have elected not to do my own Sales/Marketing. I sell my controllers and accessories through HolidayCoro - so I wish to comment on some of the replies to the question asked.
#
