I'm a long time member of the forum but sadly, our house burned down to the ground this year (long story). And so I have to start all over with my lights. The good news is, we are custom building which means I can plan for some special wiring to help me. But, I need to make some decisions pretty quickly with the builder. And needless to say, I was an old school renard guy, but if I have to start all over... I may as well go to pixels, right?
So, in lieu of taking months learning an entirely new (and super complicated) topic like I once did for the renard stuff... I only have a couple weeks to plan for any wiring I need. Which brings me to the HELP I need. 🙂 Most pressing is the roof line lights, so here are some q's in the immediate term. The rest I can come back and learn later.
1. I really prefer the "old school" look of the separated pixels versus the "blending together" of light that strips provide. But, I have noticed there are some strips that have 30 leds/meter but only 10 pixels per meter. Will that give me the more spread out look I am looking for? Or, does it only help with limiting the channels i need to program (and the "blending" still happens)?
2. With regards to both strip OR individual nodes (square or bullet) how many feet can I go without re-injecting power? I assume the strip types above also allow for longer runs?
3. I know #2 is relative, but am I right to assume that if I want to maximize run length... 12V power as well as 18AWG pixel strings are the best way to go?
4. If you guys could rip your house down to the studs and plan for wiring to potentially permanently install RGB strips on the roofline... what route would you go? Looking for a bunch of options here, i suppose? Has anyone ever found a cool and clean way to (semi)permanently install the 4 inch spaced square or bullet pixels in their roofline? Strip would be so much easier, but again, i really like that old school look.
Thanks so much for any direction you guys can give me. Enjoying looking at everyone's progress this year. Haven't been back here in years. But, glad to see it's still going strong!!!!
I would put 2" pipes from the basement into the attic and any other space that can be used to feed data and power to the display. Every 10' under the eves I would put a utility box (think over sized CG1500) that could hold two power supplies and some electronics (recessed into the wall with a door would be pretty cool). Make sure you run lots of independent circuits up to those boxes. I would add J channel set up to hold and hide the wire. I would never use 18AWG for the power feeds (14 or 16 is what I would use). Make sure you have CAT6 to each of those boxes from a central location. I would do the same at ground level. If you plan to have decorations you put up and take down, add some pulleys that can be used to make the job simpler. Build in hooks and mount hard points that can support some extra weight.
As for strips versus bullet nodes, I am in the process of removing all strips from my show. They are proving to be unreliable and a real PITA to maintain.
I feed 12V around and then use buck converters to drop power to 5V for my string. If you have those boxes every 10' then you can just supply power without converters. Since I use cheap converters, I inject every 25 pixels. If you have supplies nearby, then you can inject 5v every 50 (or even 75) pixels. If you use 12V, I have heard people say they inject at 100 pixels and it is working well for them.
I suppose the short story is: Mount points and lots of places to make power injection simple. Make sure you can provide a lot of network connectivity so you can distribute your controllers. High quality cable so you can send various signals (other than Ethernet).
My first year here and I went with strip LEDs on the house. If I was doing it over, I'd just use the individual node strings. Much easier to work with in my opinion. Each node is really waterproof and it's easy to cut and splice strings if a node dies. The strips are a general pain to splice and rely on a waterproof sheath that's likely not going to survive the long haul, especially with sun exposure. Once a crack develops or you fail to seal the ends, I can visualize water wicking it's way along causing nothing but misery. As you eluded, the density of strips is overkill IMO.
This year, I'm using PVC pipe painted to blend into the trim and strapping the LED strips to the outside with zip ties. Next year, I will likely drill 1/2" holes through the pipe and use node strings. I found some cool clear plastic clips that I can leave up all year (supposedly) that let the PVC snap into place making it easy to place or remove the lights.
Sent from my Moto G (4) using Tapatalk
Here is feedback/opinion
afremont wrote:1. I really prefer the "old school" look of the separated pixels versus the "blending together" of light that strips provide. But, I have noticed there are some strips that have 30 leds/meter but only 10 pixels per meter. Will that give me the more spread out look I am looking for? Or, does it only help with limiting the channels i need to program (and the "blending" still happens)?
I like both. Back before LED's when I had a large house I used C9 clear bulbs to line the roof. All pointed in the same direction nice clean look. Still like how that looks. Now I'm using strips because I look that look as well and what you can do with it. Really comes down to what you like. 30 LED per meter 10 pixels per meter means for every meter of strip you will have 10 controllable pixels and within that meter you will have 30 RGB led's so in the meter every 3 LED's is controlled together where as if you had something like a 60/60 which is 60 pixels per meter and 60 LED's per meter you could control every LED and there is no grouping. Again it comes down to what you want it to look like. If you are going with strips 30/10 is the most common but it's not going to give you that classic separation look. For that you will want either LED Nodes or pixabulbs. There are products that will help mount and space them.
afremont wrote:2. With regards to both strip OR individual nodes (square or bullet) how many feet can I go without re-injecting power? I assume the strip types above also allow for longer runs?
It's not just distance, it also depends on wire gauge and type of LED (power consumed). In theory strips actually would need more injection vs nodes mostly because strips while they might indicate 18AWG wire the traces in the strips are small and therefor there is more voltage drop. No mater what you do plan for power injection.
afremont wrote:3. I know #2 is relative, but am I right to assume that if I want to maximize run length... 12V power as well as 18AWG pixel strings are the best way to go?
Yes 12v does allow for more voltage drop however you should understand that the LED is still 5v and on 12v nodes or strips there is a converter changing the 12v to 5v. Data line is also always 5v as well. 12v is good for having less injection points but will not eliminate it. 5v is more power efficient since there is less converting but you will have more injection points.
afremont wrote:4. If you guys could rip your house down to the studs and plan for wiring to potentially permanently install RGB strips on the roofline... what route would you go? Looking for a bunch of options here, i suppose? Has anyone ever found a cool and clean way to (semi)permanently install the 4 inch spaced square or bullet pixels in their roofline? Strip would be so much easier, but again, i really like that old school look.
I think the biggest thing if I was building a house would be a few things and it doesn't matter if you were using strips, nodes or even incan's is that think about AC power plugs along the roof line. Probably at the corners as well as place in the middle of long runs. Thinking about future additions of things on the roof that need power. It would be much easier to run a short AC cord to a DC power supply for power injection if the plug is already near where you need it. You could then use multiple smaller supplies and not have to run long AC or DC power lines to your injection points. The other thing to think about is conduit where you might run power/data lines so that they are hidden away possible making it convenient to leave things up all year. Might also consider how the roof line is designed and how you would want to possibly have lights up year round but hidden away for convience.
All of this costs money so you have to think about is it worth it, will you ever sell the house with this to someone that doesn't need it so provides no value to them. Also consider power around your house on the outside and conduit there as well not just at the roof line.
My wish list would be for well placed power outlets on the outside of the house that may or may not be used, but are conveniently located for future shows. I am another vote to stay away from strips. Fixing strips, and they will fail at some point, is a real PITA. Nodes are relatively easy to replace. I would not be mounting anything permanently on my house, but would be looking to make sure I had the ability to fasten things to the structure in the future. Your siding option will affect how things get fastened to the structure so think thru that - window frames, column lighting, edge lighting. etc.
Good luck with everything and remember that if may a cost a little more today to do some things, but the cost and effort to retrofit later can be even more. I'm thinking of insulation, HVAC efficiency, outlets inside the house, etc. I even had my drive made 2 ft wider on each side to make it easier to get around cars parked in the driveway without having to walk in grass (or snow). LOL
