Notifications
Clear all

Ftdi

39 Posts
10 Users
0 Reactions
10.2 K Views
Posts: 130
(@charleskerr)
Estimable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
We agree that the counterfeiters are the bad guys, right? Can we also agree, at least in principle, that the end consumer should NOT bear the entire burden of fallout of the bad guys' actions?

Apparently not, as that goes back to the business decision aspect, which every company has the ability to make. I understand that you disagree with the decision, and as a result, may choose to not use FTDI products. Clearly FTDI is hoping or believes that will be the minority, and that others may support the decision of them protecting their brand. Others may simply not care.

If the question is, why doesn't everyone agree with your analsysis that FTDI made a poor choice, I think people have voiced their reasons. Expecting a universal concurrence on any decision of a third party is probably unrealistic, and academic at best.

In my business, we consider all legal options to protect our products and brand. We understand that not all of those will be popular with all consumers. If the results are too negative, we reconsider our decision, recognizing that making a different decision will have its own impacts.

I think the upshot of this, FTDI has choosen to use their software to protect their brand. They are updating via the acceptable windows policy of updates for their products. This may have undiserable impacts for non FTDI products using their driver.

If one believes FTDI should not have done this, they will make behavioral changes in regards to FTDI. Clearly some on this forum think they did, and others think they did not. So the market will determine the impact if any to FTDI and if they make future decisions.


Reply
Posts: 485
(@jerry-rigs)
Honorable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
jimboha wrote:This kind of action taken by a hacker would be considered a malicious attack.Jimboha

Not an exact match, but the flavor is there.

If a private company with the OK from the US Government hacks the hackers that are targeting US interests, it is called "active defense". Some of the targeted computers were bots with clueless owners. This was publicized a few years ago but I don't remember the details but I'm too lazy to dig right now.


Reply
Posts: 582
(@jimboha)
Honorable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
charleskerr wrote:Apparently not, as that goes back to the business decision aspect, which every company has the ability to make. I understand that you disagree with the decision, and as a result, may choose to not use FTDI products. Clearly FTDI is hoping or believes that will be the minority, and that others may support the decision of them protecting their brand. Others may simply not care.

If the question is, why doesn't everyone agree with your analsysis that FTDI made a poor choice, I think people have voiced their reasons. Expecting a universal concurrence on any decision of a third party is probably unrealistic, and academic at best.

In my business, we consider all legal options to protect our products and brand. We understand that not all of those will be popular with all consumers. If the results are too negative, we reconsider our decision, recognizing that making a different decision will have its own impacts.

I think the upshot of this, FTDI has choosen to use their software to protect their brand. They are updating via the acceptable windows policy of updates for their products. This may have undiserable impacts for non FTDI products using their driver.

If one believes FTDI should not have done this, they will make behavioral changes in regards to FTDI. Clearly some on this forum think they did, and others think they did not. So the market will determine the impact if any to FTDI and if they make future decisions.

I agree with all you say. I really do. But I add and stress the qualifier: "from the developer's point of view". "From the consumers' point of view," ... well, you know what I was going to say.

Thanks for the lively discussion!

Jimboha


Reply
Posts: 911
(@madsci1016)
Noble Member
Joined: 12 years ago
jimboha wrote:But now FTDI is using an unaccepted mechanism to prevent other chips from working (with their driver).

More power to them! No one should have been using their driver anyway.

But let's differentiate between clones and counterfeits. Counterfeits: I can agree with your support of FTDI - I still worry about the little guy who's devices stop working out of the blue, but he is using counterfeit parts. Clones: different story.

Not a different story. Either it's counterfeit and pretending to be something it's not, or it's a clone that shouldn't be using their driver. The makers of the clone should write their own driver for their own products.

Yes - they are the bad guys. But the USB VID[emoji14]ID pair mechanism assumes the manufacturer to be honest and was not designed to prevent this issue. Due to that faulty assumption and short-coming

It's not a faulty assumption nor short-coming; it was a planed design decision. To force security you have to generate encrypted communication and rights management. If USB was designed that way, it would have been way worse than the HDMI content protection system. Not to mention it would have been incompatible with open source operating systems like linux. No, USB is fine the way it is, and again stop defelcting attention away from the guys that actually did something wrong.

and a series of other similar bad assumptions in the entire supply chain, the end consumer suddenly is the one that has to pay the bill.
Jimboha

This right here is why I don't buy into the "think of the users!" excuse to bully FTDI into accepting their fate of supporting counterfeiting just because they built the most popular and lucrative to counterfeit chip.

The world is and always has been 'Buyer Beware'. It's not fair, but the world isn't fair. Consumers who make decisions to save money over the need for customer service or warranties, or who are ignorant to pay attention to the market are the ones that end up getting burned. It's a fact of life.

  • Those getting fakes did so because they risked this by buying from an un-trusted source that isn't willing to guarantee working nor authentic parts.
  • Those getting products designed with fake chips inside them bought end products from companies and vendors that aren't willing to guarantee working products.
  • Those doing either that bought from reputable vendors with customer service departments and guarantees for working products are having their now defective devices replaced free of charge.

The 'end user' is not blameless.

For example, Sparkfun (who still uses FTDI chips in all their new products) came out in day 1 and said any clones they might sell bricked by the updates would be replaced free of charge. And, because they are a company that actually vets supply chains, they have never sold a counterfeit.

I buy from Sparkfun. I, as a consumer that understands I'm risking my own money with my purchase decision, am paying more to be protected from the results of counterfeiting. I have at least 2 dozen FTDI device in my lab and they are all authentic, and unaffected by these updates.


Reply
Page 8 / 8
Share: