Notifications
Clear all

Falcon or Kulp

31 Posts
7 Users
0 Reactions
8,708 Views
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago
1pet2_9 wrote:After looking at the Kulp16 manual instead of the Kulp8, I found an audio jack on my Kulp32, but it was not in the same place. I will see if I get audio to work off of that. It would be nice, if I need the USB port for wlan0.

FYI, most people use an external USB audio device on these microcomputer based devices because the onboard sound is generally poor quality. That's why you see the soundblaster play come up so frequently.


Reply
Posts: 1420
(@1pet2-9)
Noble Member
Joined: 6 years ago
jchuchla wrote:FYI, most people use an external USB audio device on these microcomputer based devices because the onboard sound is generally poor quality. That's why you see the soundblaster play come up so frequently.

Yeah, and it works for me. In fact, that is the only audio tested and proven to work for me, besides playing from the laptop. Do all these controllers have a good option to connect USB or the RJ45 directly to a laptop (no router) and re-upload fseq files in-place? Because the Kulp goes outside behind the bushes, my router is upstairs, and bringing the controller back inside involves reconnecting 32 ports. I never got http://fpp or fpp.local to work, by the way. I always have to hand-enter the IP address that appears on the OLED screen. I've just lived with it, but it suggests I'm doing something wrong.


Reply
Posts: 2507
(@mrgrumpy)
Famed Member
Joined: 12 years ago
1pet2_9 wrote:Yeah, and it works for me. In fact, that is the only audio tested and proven to work for me, besides playing from the laptop. Do all these controllers have a good option to connect USB or the RJ45 directly to a laptop (no router) and re-upload fseq files in-place? Because the Kulp goes outside behind the bushes, my router is upstairs, and bringing the controller back inside involves reconnecting 32 ports. I never got http://fpp or fpp.local to work, by the way. I always have to hand-enter the IP address that appears on the OLED screen. I've just lived with it, but it suggests I'm doing something wrong.

For me, FPP/ & FPP.local both works on the wlan0 (WiFi) network, but not the show (eth0) network. That network also makes me use the IP.


Reply
Posts: 1420
(@1pet2-9)
Noble Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Oh, are you using a Wifi dongle, like, from a Raspberry Pi 2 to get wlan0?

Anyway, the audio jack works, and the sound is fine. Buying the soundblaster doesn't seem to have been necessary, but I'll keep it in my pocket. And the wlan0 works using a very old Wifi dongle. Probably 802.11b. That'll reach to the bushes, no problem. LOL.


Reply
Posts: 2507
(@mrgrumpy)
Famed Member
Joined: 12 years ago
1pet2_9 wrote:Oh, are you using a Wifi dongle, like, from a Raspberry Pi 2 to get wlan0?

Yes


Reply
Posts: 10
(@kmc-pyro)
Eminent Member
Joined: 9 years ago

I love my Falcon F48 setup, but...., its the only thing I've ever used. I haven't had any desire to swap over to anything else, so take that for what it's worth.


Reply
Posts: 629
(@dkulp)
Honorable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
jchuchla wrote:FYI, most people use an external USB audio device on these microcomputer based devices because the onboard sound is generally poor quality. That's why you see the soundblaster play come up so frequently.

The DAC on the K16/K32 is a PCM5101 or PCM5102 (Latest batches of boards had to go with the 5101 as the 5102 was out of stock everywhere) which is the same DAC that is found on the HiFIBerry (higher end audio hat for Pi) and also used in several of the big-name mid-range receivers. It's a very capable and decent DAC. It's actually more capable than the SB Play in that it can support the 384Khz audio and such. That said, we all use crappy over compressed mp3's so that's likely not a big deal. FPP can use better audio sources, but I'm not aware of anyone that does.

That said, being right on the same board as a bunch of digital 800khz signals (all the pixel strings) and such there is definitely a higher chance of interference. The SB Play can be moved away from any interference with a cheap USB extension cable.


Reply
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago
dkulp wrote:
That said, being right on the same board as a bunch of digital 800khz signals (all the pixel strings) and such there is definitely a higher chance of interference. The SB Play can be moved away from any interference with a cheap USB extension cable.

This right here is probably the most important part. I've got no experience with the Kulp board's audio, but at least on the pi, a lot of the poor audio on the internal audio port is HF interference noise. I'd imagine it's a similar situation on Dan's boards. Simply putting some distance between the audio circuit and the main board solves most of the issues. There's many good USB audio adapters out there. But the SB Play is a known good one that's easy to recommend and easily get on a reliable basis.


Reply
Posts: 629
(@dkulp)
Honorable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
jchuchla wrote: but at least on the pi, a lot of the poor audio on the internal audio port is HF interference noise.

Actually, no. The audio on the Pi is poor mostly because it doesn't even have a real DAC that's designed to produce audio waveforms. It mimics a DAC by using the PWM subsystem to generate a wave form. That's also why you cannot use sound while using any sort of pixel hat as the pixels use the PWM subsystem for timing.


Reply
jchuchla
Posts: 8698
(@jchuchla)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago
dkulp wrote:Actually, no. The audio on the Pi is poor mostly because it doesn't even have a real DAC that's designed to produce audio waveforms. It mimics a DAC by using the PWM subsystem to generate a wave form. That's also why you cannot use sound while using any sort of pixel hat as the pixels use the PWM subsystem for timing.

That’s true. But it doesn’t mean that noise isn’t a contributing factor. I can literally hear when there’s traffic on the usb bus. Some devices worse than others. But even a keyboard or mouse will do it.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Reply
Page 3 / 4
Share: