Hi everyone,
I am experiencing some lag in my show and was hoping I could get some advice on curing it. Here is my situation:
I am running Falcon Player on a Raspberry Pi. The Pi is connected to 5 daisy chained Renard AC controllers (via USB to RS485 dongle) and 5 ESPixelSticks (via a Netgear wireless router). The Renard AC channels are syncing perfectly with the music, but the pixel sticks are between 1 and 1.5 seconds behind.
I had the same setup last year, but only with 2 pixel sticks and it worked. I sometimes would get some flickering on my upper roofline which I could only fix by rebooting the router. I attributed that to the distance the pixel stick was away from the Pi as well as the house walls and roof that were in between. The lower roofline pixel stick worked without issue. It was close to the garage door, so that surely helped its signal.
This year all 5 pixel sticks are experiencing delay.
I have checked the Network status page on the pixel stick web interface and noticed that they are all reporting an RSSI of around -70dBm / 60%. This of course fluctuates up and down a bit, but never very far. Could this be an indicator of the problem? Am I simply not getting a good enough signal from my old Netgear router?
Ken
Following... I'm having similar issues. I have 20+ ESPixelSticks/Pops in unicast (multicast has even worse performance) with static IPs over a Ubiquiti PicoStation M2. Some run pretty smoothly and others are irregular. There may be a correlation between performance and distance from the AP, but it's no more than 50' in any direction with clear line of sight. Already thinking about next year and getting rid of all wireless.
I also occasionally have issues with my home WiFI and my show WiFi possibly interfering with each other even though there's no channel overlap between them and they are on different SSIDs. On occasion, my Pi is not able to pull an IP address from the home network for it's internal WiFi.
I am using an Ubiquiti Nanostation M5 access point but you may be having the same problem I was having. Please read over this thread. It may provide some help. My problem turned out to be my AP location in relation to the ESPs.
http://doityourselfchristmas.com/forums/showthread.php?54018-Latency-problems&p=517719#post517719
I was having similar issues and my gear is similar. FPP on Pi3B+, Ubiquiti Nanostation LocoM2, 24 ESPixelSticks (22 controlling 2800 pixels, 2 controlling 2 Renard SS24s). I have no hardwired controllers, all via WiFi. My lag was up to 3-4 seconds. Fixed it by:
1) Used a WiFi scanner on an android phone to find the best (least used) WiFi channel. The WiFi near my house is very crowded with about 10 - 15 APs seen. The LocoM2 auto selected channel 11 and it would absolutely not work on that chan. Found chan 7 was least used and locked the LocoM2 to that chan and it worked a bit better.
2) Only use Multicast and make sure nothing else but your ESPixelsticks are on the show WiFi network, especially no cell phones.
3) Made sure all ESPs have a direct line of sight to the LocoM2. I have one ESP that shows about 70% signal, all others are 80% and better.
4) SSH into the LocoM2 and set the MCAST rate to 24000 (credit to Jon Chuchla, not sure if you can do this on any other AP).
To display the current Mcast rate:
iwpriv ath0 get_mcast_rate
To set:
iwpriv ath0 mcast_rate 24000
Note this is not persistent, if you power down the LocoM2 you have to reset this.
4) This probably had the biggest effect for me, I packed my universes and channels as tightly as possible, no unused channels, chan gaps, etc.
Doing the above pretty much fixed it for me. I occasionally have a stutter from an odd lost frame but not much.
Here is a video of one of my songs using all WiFi ESPs (hope you're not a Texas Longhorn fan!).
Good luck.
All I can say from experience....
Ditch the router....
an AP is the way to go without all the junk to slow things down. I got the lags and went to a AP and it is fine. An AP point can be a USB WiFi device capable of a soft-AP. do the settings they suggest. i tried to turn everything off on the router and still lagged
