E68x vs j1sys contr...
 
Notifications
Clear all

E68x vs j1sys controllers

18 Posts
13 Users
0 Reactions
6,034 Views
Posts: 425
Topic starter
(@mkess)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
[#23439]

Trying to decide which way to go. What are the pros/cons of the different controllers and do I need extra hardware with either to make them work?


17 Replies
Posts: 283
(@gigogig)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago

ive used both but i like j1sys better (cost per univers of a p12r is better than the cost per univers of a 682 (and i like the web interface better)) (and now there getting more selection of options not just the p12r/8), that said the e68x has support for more pixels types (like gece (both i believe support the 2811 witch is the pixel type i recommend)), both typically need cases and power supply, other than that they are very evenly mached


Reply
Posts: 4092
(@skunberg)
Famed Member
Joined: 18 years ago

Like Greg said j1sys cost less per pixel. But if it doesn't support your pixels or if you have a issue that needs a firmware update j1sys is slow if ever. They seem to crank out hardware a little more aimed towards commercial. E68x supports more pixels and much more support for us diy people.

IMHO, no offence Ed

Brian

Sent from my SCH-I500 using Tapatalk 2


Reply
rokkett
Posts: 441
(@rokkett)
Reputable Member
Joined: 17 years ago

I picked the SanDevices controllers (I have three 681s that have the upgraded Ethernet) because there seemed to be more users on DIYC and the firmware was open-sourced. Now I haven't had a need/chance to go in and play with the firmware yet, so it has turned out that wasn't an obvious requirement. But I have other pixel hardware that has issues, and no firmware access, so I didn't want to paint myself into that corner again...

I don't have any practical experience with the J1sys options to make a recommendation on them...


Reply
pmcpa
Posts: 1390
(@pmcpa)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago

Both are good boards, Both are good companies. I like the E68x series, and it's my only choice because I use GECE and J1sys doesn't support them.


Reply
jaywalk101
Posts: 761
(@jaywalk101)
Prominent Member
Joined: 15 years ago

I only have experience with the E68X line, and I used three of them this year with my display without a hiccup.... Jim from sandevices.com is awesome when it comes to support and upgrades as well!


Reply
Posts: 214
(@gary-martin)
Estimable Member
Joined: 18 years ago

I looked at both closely and last year, it was pretty hard to get anything from J1Sys. That situation has changed from what I've heard. They both work, but they're best at different things. IMHO, the E68x is better used in a tight cluster of pixels, a Megatree or panel display. It's ideal for 16 strands of 42 pixels per strand to fill up four universes. That way you don't have to inject power all over the place, just at the controller. The J1Sys can support more universes, but then you'd be running power injection drops all over your strings to keep your whites white. 😉 The J1Sys has a GUI setup page for those that can't deal with text but then the SanDevices E68x handles more protocols. Someone I know here in town was trying to setup 1804 based pixels with a J1Sys and was having issues with how fast they could get changes to take effect in their sequencing. The SanDevices unit supports two different 1804 types for fast or slow based controllers and is actually easier to setup for that product. The SanDevices can also use one of it's clusters to drive a DMX512 chain directly. It's a handy thing for eliminating extra wiring, just to be able to drop another DMX chain where the pixel controller is.

It's personal preference, there is no perfect choice.


Reply
Posts: 1744
(@tjetzer)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Gary Martin wrote:I looked at both closely and last year, it was pretty hard to get anything from J1Sys. That situation has changed from what I've heard. They both work, but they're best at different things. IMHO, the E68x is better used in a tight cluster of pixels, a Megatree or panel display. It's ideal for 16 strands of 42 pixels per strand to fill up four universes. That way you don't have to inject power all over the place, just at the controller. The J1Sys can support more universes, but then you'd be running power injection drops all over your strings to keep your whites white. 😉 The J1Sys has a GUI setup page for those that can't deal with text but then the SanDevices E68x handles more protocols. Someone I know here in town was trying to setup 1804 based pixels with a J1Sys and was having issues with how fast they could get changes to take effect in their sequencing. The SanDevices unit supports two different 1804 types for fast or slow based controllers and is actually easier to setup for that product. The SanDevices can also use one of it's clusters to drive a DMX512 chain directly. It's a handy thing for eliminating extra wiring, just to be able to drop another DMX chain where the pixel controller is.

It's personal preference, there is no perfect choice.

The E682 supports up to 1020 total pixels. The numbers you are refrencing are for the E680 and E681. Also, there is an adapter PCB available that will allow thet E680 and E681 to drive 1020 pixels.

For both pixel and user support it's SanDevices hands down. It seems J1sys has pretty much given up on DIYC.


Reply
Posts: 425
Topic starter
(@mkess)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago

On the e682 kits, do I need to be able to flash pics or anything like that? Or do I just solder and go


Reply
pmcpa
Posts: 1390
(@pmcpa)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago

Only if you buy the PIC's from mouser. If you get a kit from Jim or from a group buy they are normally pre-flashed


Reply
Page 1 / 2
Share: