Over my head with the technical side of this. Most of my props are 50 to 210 pixel count in size and many of them could benefit from single channel controllers given each prop location. Cat5 direct to my display network (e682/6804 and PX1 controllers) is my go-to.
WRT the original conversation: It may be good to note that not all of the ESP32 devices have PSRAM attaches to them. I know that the Quinled controllers do NOT have PSRAM. Adding it adds cost to the product.
As for more small controllers driving smaller port counts / props: I TOTALLY agree. While I have mostly F16's and a few ESPixelSticks in my show, my F16s rarely have more than 8 channels in use. (mega tree also only uses 8 ports) This is to that any given F16 can absorb a neighboring controllers load if that controller goes out (call it a hot spare if you like). I have multiple ESP32s with only a single channel output driving things like my tune to sign and remote props using WiFi (no data, just fpp sync messages). Works great and has come in handy when the controllers die (and they have). My original F16 Blue version died a few years ago and the reds picked up the load within 30 minutes of replugging.
dirknerkle wrote:
We almost always acquire the mindset that "more is better" -- for some reason we equate the concept of bigger size to better quality. It's not always the case. One can do a LOT with only 150-250 pixels and create a wonderfully effective display piece. Another benefit of designing a show using smaller counts of lights is that if the section goes out, it doesn't usually kill the whole display, only a part of it. DIY'ers who have encountered a major show failure when their main controller goes out are quite familiar with the issue of relying on a single piece of gear for their whole show. When you put all your eggs in one basket, you better keep a backup basket in the closet!
Though the bigger boat does have the right of way ! lol
Couldn't resist !
angus40 wrote:
Though the bigger boat does have the right of way ! lol
Couldn't resist !
But bridges have the right of way over ships and boats.
Speaking of Bridges.... This puppy should be able to run 6 Px1's or Renards if it could be brought back into production.
www.doityourselfchristmas.com/wiki/index.php?title=E1.31_Bridge

