Currently my entire network is on Google Fiber. Unfortunately Google decided I wasn't paying enough for tv so they are raising the rate $15 a month. That would put my current monthly bill at $195. No way. Ain't gonna happen. January 2nd I'm reluctantly switching over to Spectrum, formally Time Warner. I'm not happy about it but I have do it. Anyway, I'm not sure how Spectrum will handle my show so I was thinking of adding a modem strictly for my show. Is this feasible and can it be done?
Sent from my SM-T710 using Tapatalk
I use a separate "show" Wi-Fi network that is not connected to my home wifi. My home wifi connects to the internet supplied by Spectrum. Spectrum has been good for me. So, YES, it is feasible and can be done.
Personally, I don't trust the gateway equipment from any of the providers. I always figure out how to make their equipment do as little as possible and provide premise equipment behind it under my full control. On comcast, I can usually even provide my own cable modem and remove their equipment from the premise altogether. With other ISPs, sometimes you're stuck with their gateway but can make it run in transparent mode to your own router.
jchuchla wrote:Personally, I don't trust the gateway equipment from any of the providers. I always figure out how to make their equipment do as little as possible and provide premise equipment behind it under my full control. On comcast, I can usually even provide my own cable modem and remove their equipment from the premise altogether. With other ISPs, sometimes you're stuck with their gateway but can make it run in transparent mode to your own router.
Spectrum did ask me if I was going to use my router and told them I didn't have one. Heck, I guess I could get my own and not pay the monthly service fee but I wouldn't have a clue what to buy and probably know less how to hook it up unless Spectrum wired it and got it going when they come to install. I dunno. I suppose I could call them and find out. Install isn't until January 2. No way was I going to screw up my lights with a new network. Btw. I don't do wifi. I'm a hardwire man.
Sent from my SM-T710 using Tapatalk
I have spectrum. I refused their router but I am using their modem. My reasoning is that the modem takes the lightning hits we get around here so it gets replaced every few years. Better to pay part of the cost of a modem (over time) than regularly replace one entirely at my cost.
My main router is an Asus 5400 tri-band that has great range and speed.
jchuchla wrote:Personally, I don't trust the gateway equipment from any of the providers. I always figure out how to make their equipment do as little as possible and provide premise equipment behind it under my full control. On comcast, I can usually even provide my own cable modem and remove their equipment from the premise altogether. With other ISPs, sometimes you're stuck with their gateway but can make it run in transparent mode to your own router.
This... I have Century(-old)link, and their modem I set to "bridge" mode (after changing the default password), and use my own firewall/router.
I have never used service providers routers and have a netgear there reliable and have some great features like storage capability on spare hdd or usb sticks.
I guess two topics in this thread. I have Spectrum (after a lot of Mergers and Acquisitions), I've found the service reliable and the speeds pretty good. As for my show, i have a separate router / wifi for the show. The FPP software makes bridging (probably not the proper network term) to my home lan easy. Good Luck next year!
Jim
pmiller wrote:Currently my entire network is on Google Fiber. ... Anyway, I'm not sure how Spectrum will handle my show so I was thinking of adding a modem strictly for my show. Is this feasible and can it be done?
A modem and a router are different things but they are often supplied as a single combo device by an Internet Service Provider (ISP).
A modem converts from fiber or coax cable to Ethernet cable (Over simplified).
A router allows you to connect multiple devices to one ISP connection (Over simplified (a typical ISP supplied home router is a firewall & router & DHCP server & wireless access point & network switch combined)).
If I understand it correctly and have my assumptions correct,
You currently have fiber coming to your house and you have a modem/router supplied by the ISP.
The modem/router gives you Gigabit capability when you are using Cat5e cable.
Your house and show are on the same physical and logical network (the first 3 numbers in your IP addresses are all the same (for example: 192.168.1.xxx) (Over simplified).
You do not use any wireless (WiFi) capabilities.
You are changing to a new ISP and want to know if everything will work, or what needs to change to make everything work.
Your new ISP will provide a different modem/router which may or may not support Gigabit Ethernet. If it does support Gigabit, you may be just fine. Unplug the old, plug in the new.
If the new modem/router does not support Gigabit, you may or may nor have problems with your house/show network. Without more info about your home/show network, it is hard to say.
You have many options about how to configure the Internet coming into you house. Most people are not technical enough or don't care enough to do anything more advanced than what the ISP provides by default. If you involved in this hobby, you are technical enough to go more advanced and you can get a lot of help here.
Some people will use the ISP's modem but use their own router as some people have described above. There are many reasons for doing that but I think they are mostly beyond the scope of this hobby.
It is a hobby best practice (not a requirement) to use a dedicated router for your show. That isolates and separates the show traffic from your home network traffic and prevents the home from flooding the show and the show from flooding the home. If everything currently is working fine, it may be because you have a very fast network (Gigabit is a very big pipe). Adding a new show dedicated subnet to your home network is easy and many people here can walk you through it. A new home router will be all you need. It doesn't even need to be that beefy. Properly configured, this arrangement allows you to access your show network from your home network (for file copies and config changes) but blocks your show traffic from flooding your home network.
As an aside, there have been discussions on this board about some show devices not liking to be on Gigabit networks, YMMV.
