n8huntsman wrote:Since there are more threads regarding nutcracker than there are for the Arduino, and arduino has it's own forum, maybe Nutcracker should also have its own forum too? I pose this because most of the threads are in the Vixen forum when very few are actually related to Vixen.
Maybe, I'm sure Nutcracker will dominate the rest of the year but next year it'll may be almost nothing. But I hate going from one dead forum to another dead forum looking for a recent post. We already have too many dead areas. I'd much rather weed thru live ones.
Just my .02 cents (before taxes) worth.
Brian
Skunberg wrote:Maybe, I'm sure Nutcracker will dominate the rest of the year but next year it'll may be almost nothing. But I hate going from one dead forum to another dead forum looking for a recent post. We already have too many dead areas. I'd much rather weed thru live ones.
Just my .02 cents (before taxes) worth.Brian
I asked macrosill where is the best place to post Nutcracker threads
His answer would tell me he doesn't know what it does:
"Is the Nutcracker a plug in for Vixen? If not then I guess the best place would be in the General Software forum.
Thanks,
Brian, your friendly site Admin."
The nutcracker is generic as it covers all three sequencers. we create lots of threads. I feel guilt that i am filling up the vixen forum.
Should I start posting Nutcracker over in the General Software forum? When i first posted here 3 months ago, i was working on Vixen and not on the other two sequencers. Now all 3 groups have loaded animations. Whereever we go , we will create lots of threads there.
I think the nutcracker will still be going pretty strong next year. I am working on layers, i have prototyped a way to get the beats from audacity into a label file and plan on having nutcracker animations (think like when meteors fall) to be synced to your music, put all objects in front yard into one 3d space and animate across all of them. I want to detect motion in the front yard using a video camera and change the animations, still have movies to project, other target models (arches, icicles) .
I dont think i will finish all of this by the end of this year, but who knows, maybe.
Because nutcracker covers all of the sequencers, i cross post oe many places.
These two have a separate forum for nutcracker
Software => Nutcracker: RGB Effects Builder
http://diylightanimation.com/index.php?board=48.0
General => Nutcracker Software
http://auschristmaslighting.com/forums/index.php/board,61.0.html
The following do not have a separate forum, so i looked to try and find the best place.
Vixen 2 => How do I?
http://doityourselfchristmas.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?27-How-do-I
The Coffee Shop
http://forums.lightorama.com/forum81/
Lights => RGB Based Lights
http://forums.planetchristmas.com/index.php?/forum/208-rgb-based-lights/
LED => RGB
http://holidayuniversity.com/forums/index.php?board=113.0
Effect Plugin Development
http://www.lightshowpro.com/effect-plugin-development/2532-nutcracker-plugin.html
(I have been asked to not post nutcracker stuff on LSP since the tool is generic. He believes a generic tool is best in a DIY forum. This is why you dont see hardly any posts there over the last few months).
smeighan wrote:Should I start posting Nutcracker over in the General Software forum? When i first posted here 3 months ago, i was working on Vixen and not on the other two sequencers. Now all 3 groups have loaded animations. Whereever we go , we will create lots of threads there.
I asked Brian if it would be possible for a subsection of the General Software forum could be created just for this subject. While I understand the thought that these sections can become stale quickly... they also help to focus on subjects that specialize in a specific area giving anyone with interest an easy location to go and research. This tool has the possibility to become very popular over the next year and I see the threads falling away on several forums. Having it all compiled in a single section would show all the work he's done with it... and give the new person looking at it some perspective to all it can do. I was searching his threads via his profile and found several things I had missed. It's really amazing how much work he's put into it, and it sort of blows that it's not easily reviewable.
I say make a sub-section for the Nutcracker in the General Software section and place all of Sean's threads in it... However, that could result in marital problems as looking over his work again just might negatively affect my bank account...
Jeff
I say make a sub-section for the Nutcracker in the General Software section and place all of Sean's threads in it
+1 on this.
Moving forward Nutcracker is shaping up to be a must have program. Pixels = mega channels , Nutcracker = ease of sequencing . I couldnt dream of how easy Sean has made complex sequencing.
smeighan wrote: I feel guilt that i am filling up the vixen forum.
As I see it, Nutcracker is a very complex backend to something that more and more will use. You should feel no guilt for the amazing time and effort you've put into this, shared, and continue to improve. Who cares that it's filling up a particular forum.
As to the question of whether it's to have it's own forum or not, I suggest yes. It may become stale in the near future only because you might stop enhancing it or someone comes up with something better (I don't think that will happen any time soon). But in my mind, as someone who hasn't tried pixels yet, a forum of it's own would allow me to reference all the posts pertaining to this once I do delve into pixels. This thing seems so above-and-beyond normal sequencing endeavors that I feel it should have it's own place here. It stands in stature, in my mind, with things like "Ledtriks", "MegaTrees", or other specific forums.

