First some background on what I am doing and have done. I am adding a "firework" item using pixels and E131 to my display this year. The main firework is 32 "arms" x 50pixels each. The pole for the firework is 6x50 I researched and purchased pixels and controllers back in Jan/Feb. I also spent time researching what software I was going to use. That is when I discovered Nutcracker and "fell in love" with what it was capable of doing so easily. This was back when only version 2 was available. At that time I created a bunch of test routines and exported them to .vix files for playback in Vixen 2.1. I used these for burn in.
Come late August I picked up and finished the actual firework. I discovered and updated to using Xlights/Nutcracker and spent time recreating most of my test routines. I have noticed a subtle difference in what I would call "smoothness" of playback in Xlights versus Vixen. While I think I may notice differences in other effects I can only say for certain that I see what I would call an occasional jump or hesitation with meteors. I doubt I would even notice it if I hadn't started with Nutcracker 2/Vixen. I am sure I am also using the meteor effect more heavily than most since my element is a firework. I have done a bit of testing such that I think I can list a few things that are NOT causing the difference. First I have used multiple computers of varying capability with the same basic results so I don't think it is a lag due to processing. Secondly, I am pretty sure I can see the same hesitation in preview with no output to lights. Not sure if it is relevant but I also switched my controllers and setup at some point from multicast to unicast so I could leave the wireless adapter in the show computer enabled and not overwhelm my wireless router with e131 traffic. I am not sure what version of Xlights I started with but I have pretty much kept up with the latest version from Sept. through now. I had some initial problems with unexpected behavior with meteors but this was fixed pretty early in my testing I believe with one of the updates.
I am not really looking for any fix for this but just wanted to post my personal observations.
I also want to say a huge thank-you for making Nutcracker. It was incredibly easy and fun to create awesome routines for my firework display. Everybody who has seen it while I have been developing and testing has described it as spectacular!
Post a video, I would love to see what you have been working on. It sounds great and I would love to do same next year.
:thup2:
if you could post a video and describe at what timing mark you see the delay.
also post you
xlights_networks.xml
xlights_rgbeffects.xml
and your sequence.xml file to a dropbox.
I can then duplicate what you are seeing.
thanks for the input
My display is "static" in that my lights are not synchronized to music. While I could have created a sequence or sequences that contain multiple Nutcracker effects I created sequences that contain just one effect per display element each. Since what I am seeing is much more pronounced with the meteor effect I created identical playlists in Xlights and Vixen that include only the meteor sequences. What I describe as a "hesitation" is not really so much something that happens at a given timing mark as it is an overall impression. The meteors look "smoother" to me played in Vixen. Below are links to videos of playback of the identical playlists of my meteor sequences in Xlights and Vixen. Also below are links to a video of my full playlist and a dropbox link to a zip file of the xml files for all my meteor effects in the playlist plus the other xml files you requested. FYI, the "Explosion" portion of the display is currently defined as a single "Explosion" display element and also broken down into display elements "wing1" - "wing8". This allows me to have a meteor effect with meteors going different directions. All this to say that I saw the same results when I had only the "Pole" and "Explosion" display elements defined.
xLights playback of meteors effects
Vixen playback of meteor effects
Full playlist
Zip file of xml files
Dropbox File (Private or Invalid)

