Defamation—also called calumny, vilification, traducement, slander (for transitory statements), and libel (for written, broadcast, or otherwise published words)—is the communication of a statement that makes a claim, expressly stated or implied to be factual, that may give an individual, business, product, group, government, or nation a negative image.
In this instance there may be a case for Libel against MPH but not DIYC itself. The poster owns the rights to the post, DIYC takes no ownership.
I am not sure what course of action, if any, I am going to take. I have to run some things through my head first.
I think it is important to not censor peoples posts. MPH is entitled to his opinion, just like anyone else. If he got banned from ACL then there is nothing wrong with him saying so. I see no reason why he should not be able to tell the world why he was banned. The only issue I can see here is the statement about ACL pocketing money that was supposed to be used for prizes. On the other hand he may just be telling of his experience with that site. I am not so sure there is anything wrong with that. Just like someone complaining about a raw deal they got from any other place.
thoughts?
Macrosill wrote:I think it is important to not censor peoples posts. MPH is entitled to his opinion, just like anyone else. If he got banned from ACL then there is nothing wrong with him saying so. I see no reason why he should not be able to tell the world why he was banned. The only issue I can see here is the statement about ACL pocketing money that was supposed to be used for prizes. On the other hand he may just be telling of his experience with that site. I am not so sure there is anything wrong with that. Just like someone complaining about a raw deal they got from any other place.thoughts?
With the way it is written, that is how I took it. I don't see an "accusation", but the story of the accusation he already did on their site and got banned for it.
I have sent a PM to MPH requesting he remove the following from his post "and he had just pocketed" as it is very accusatory. Once that is complete I feel the post is perfectly acceptable.
Well, edit mine as well, with the quote in it.
Aussiephil's original PM
BrianI would like to raise this with you
This is from the third report i have made, all parties were active on the forum for the first two reports.
the thread in question is
http://doityourselfchristmas.com/for...for-the-noviceThe report is about MPH's slanderous comments on Page2
There is absolutely no reason for DIYC and ACL to be at loggerheads and i am seriously disappointed that the moderators have left that content in place.
I fully agree with them telling people to stop it btw, I personally cautioned FastEddy about reacting to the posts.I trust this can be dealt with quickly and effectively with the offending content removed or a reason provided that it will not be removed
Regards
Phil-------------------------
THIRD REPORT and NO Action, NO Response.If this is continued to be ignored I will be seeking legal advice with regards to this post and the duplication of the information by WayneJ and what action may be taken against DIYC for allowing this to remain on public view.
I will also be seeking that DIYC remove this from any SEARCH Engine results.There have been many Mods available but they seem to wish to ignore this report, this is not acceptable.
Phil Short: I have also PM'ed you independently and POLITELY and you appear to have ignored that.
Please either deal with this post or provide a reason that you and your Moderators are allowing slanderous information to remain on your forum.Aussiephil
------------------------------
My reply
aussiephil wrote:I am on vacation and have very limited internet access. I will look at this next week when I get home.
Brian,
Appreciate the advice your away and I respect your need for a holiday, however, the reported posts is considered by me (and others) to be damaging to my reputation and the lack of action by your Global Moderators forces me to bring this to your attention for immediate action.
If this is not dealt with in a timely fashion as per your forum rules then I will have little recourse but to seek legal advice.
I really am sorry for pushing this as hard as I am when your away.
I would also thank WJohn for taking the time today to ring me and discuss, unfortunately he cannot take any action.
Regards and best wishes
Phil
Phil,
I have reviewed the reported post and thread.
I have sent a PM to Andrew requesting he edit his post to removed the following portion, "and he had just pocketed". Once that is done the post will be nothing more then him informing others about his experience with ACL, just the same as someone informing others of their experience with a Vendor, good or bad. Nothing Slanderous about it.
If you feel you need to "seek legal advice" then do so.
Should I receive a Court Order, from a court of competent jurisdiction in the US, ordering me to delete the post in question I will do so.
I am actually offended by your tone insisting I take action and threaten me with legal action. If you had been reasonable and explained the situation and ask me to help resolve it then I may have been a little more accommodating. But once you start telling me what to do and threaten me and my staff with "legal action" if I do not comply I will do no more than I am legally required to.
MPH has edited his post and I edited Wayne's
I spoke to Phil last week.
My guidance to Phil was Andrew can state the facts (he was booted from ACL), Andrew can even say he is aggrieved by what happen. However, as for the pixel strings Andrew donated as a prize for a Mini, they were given to the Prize Winner. Phil did take his time (over 6 months to ship them), and Andrew may not be aware that they were delivered as he would only have the facts up to a earlier point in time.
I expect Andrew was bounced off ACL before the delivery took effect, so in his mind, he believes that they were never delivered, when the fact are they were delivered, just later then expected.
As with most things, I support Andrew to express his position, facts and feelings, I dont support assertions not backed by facts when they involve a second party.
Like sands through an Hour Glass, they are the Days of Our Lives.......
(i used to walk home from school in the early 70s, and D.O.O.L would be on our B&W TV, followed by Green Acres (the place the be).....
