My implementation of Custom Effect was introduced back in Jan of this year.
HLS has grown well beyond the vision at that time.
Custom Effect are a combination of effects with the intent of treating them like ONE effect.
As HLS has grown - this idea of a complex effect staying as ONE has caused concerns when trying to enlarge them, delete them, move them ....
Before I make the change, I would like your feedback .....
I would like to REMOVE the grouping aspect of a "Custom Effect".
You can still build them and place them.
Once PLACED - they become a combination of simple effects which you can then manipulate as you wish.
Please provide your thoughts.
Thanks.
Joe
I use them quite frequently and end up re-selecting them to remove the grouping more than half the time anyways, so having them placed ungrouped would be cool with me. My only concern would be the ability to do chases etc with them as a group. As long as this was maintained all would be good. Maybe you could throw in a right click "group effects". That would be easy enough to use if needed.
Along the same line, would it be possible to widen the percentages for random placement? I would love to see the range go from about 2% to maybe as high as 50%
As always, Thanks Joe
Would that eliminate the need to 'un-group' the effect? If so, I like your idea.
BrianJ wrote:
Along the same line, would it be possible to widen the percentages for random placement? I would love to see the range go from about 2% to maybe as high as 50%As always, Thanks Joe
If the effect weas a single cell effect then 50% could be obtained.
As soon as the effect is more than 1 cell in duration - 50% is NEVER obtainable.
Let me think about letting you set 50% - but NOT reporting an error is the requested percentage can not be obtained.
Try it for you self on a piece of paper. Draw a long string of boxes and then say you are going to randomly lay down a 3 or a 5 cell effect. Close your eyes and start pointing to the boxes - when you hit an empty cell that has the number of empty cells following it to take the effect - then draw X's in all of the cells.
You will find as the size of your effect goes up --- the percentage of random placement goes way down - very fast.
Joe
I see exactly what you are talking about with the effect frequency. I was really more interested in the lower percentages anyways, allowing a "twinkle" type placement of custom effects.
Twinkle of custom is already there - it called Random.
Select a box - select Custom Effect - one of the many placement options is Random.
Joe
Yes, what I was looking for was the lowering of the minimum percantage on that effect. 🙂
Thanks again
Version 8M drops lower limit from 10% to 2%
Joe
Once again Joe, You are awesome 🙂
Version 8P removes Grouping from Custom Effects.
No more "Un-Grouping" required and Custom effects turn into a combination of Simple effects upon placement.
That means --- all the normal editing/deleting processes work with Custom Effects now.
Joe
