I know there is a steep learning curve. It's frustrating, I know. I was ready to through my computer across the room when I tried 1.8. But I really emplore everyone to spend some time with it. Force yourself to watch all the tutorials, for this version and the previous. Make sure your audio is encoded with 128 kbs and 44100 hz. Audacity is a good free program to do this. Then struggle through creating at least one sequence. I'm sure you will all quickly find that it's not as bad as first impression may lead you to believe. I've completed my second sequence and I'm getting better and faster. I'm not saying it's perfect, but I am learning work arounds for it. You shouldn't have to do this, yes, but I believe the features outweigh the problems.
I'm not here to continue the sequencer wars, but did want to make one point. One of the more mentioned complaints is around importing Vixen sequences. While that's understandable that many folks here want to move their Vixen sequences to LSP without issues, understand that translation from one program to another is not an easy task. There's no guarantee that the Vixen sequence is in a known "good" state, and with the varied versions (2.1, 2.5, etc.), it's quite possible that some of the issue could be due to the actual sequence.
And perhaps, this translation/import issue has been less tested than some of the major features, such as layers and RGB. I know that the import of AL sequences was never as great as I would like, since I had a fair number of those sequences in my collection. I chose to "redo" those sequences and channel layouts from scratch, or at least keeping the timing with the music. I can still use my AL controllers with LSP and have for the last 3 years.
One other note - the 16 universe limit of the advanced version is not based totally on Universe count, but is a 8192 channel limit, I believe. You can have lots more than 16 universes with 8192 channels if you are not using the full 512 channels of a universe. I've segmented my display and sometime use much less than 512 on a given segment. Of course, that is changing this year with lots more RGB.
mschell wrote:I'm not here to continue the sequencer wars, but did want to make one point. One of the more mentioned complaints is around importing Vixen sequences. While that's understandable that many folks here want to move their Vixen sequences to LSP without issues, understand that translation from one program to another is not an easy task. There's no guarantee that the Vixen sequence is in a known "good" state, and with the varied versions (2.1, 2.5, etc.), it's quite possible that some of the issue could be due to the actual sequence.And perhaps, this translation/import issue has been less tested than some of the major features, such as layers and RGB. I know that the import of AL sequences was never as great as I would like, since I had a fair number of those sequences in my collection. I chose to "redo" those sequences and channel layouts from scratch, or at least keeping the timing with the music. I can still use my AL controllers with LSP and have for the last 3 years.
One other note - the 16 universe limit of the advanced version is not based totally on Universe count, but is a 8192 channel limit, I believe. You can have lots more than 16 universes with 8192 channels if you are not using the full 512 channels of a universe. I've segmented my display and sometime use much less than 512 on a given segment. Of course, that is changing this year with lots more RGB.
These are all good points Mark. If you (or anyone reading this) have David's ear, I would be more than willing to be a crash test dummy for importing Vixen sequences. I can do 2.1 or 2.5, doesn't matter, I know my sequences are in a known good state, etc. I have e-mailed him once through the LSP web site to help test and was not taken up on my offer - which is okay, it is his choice and I hold no ill will towards him or his product. There are things I really like about LSP, but having spent well over 200 hrs on sequences, I am not about to start over with my sequencing. But, I bet the Vixen importers could be potentially won over, at least until Vixen 3.0 ships. Got to love competition, it makes better products. -- John
N7XG wrote:I think this other thing that annoys me is that I offered to help test and he declined. In fact several of my email were just ignored. I am concerned that this pattern will not change.I also suspect that many of the problems I was having with LSP ver 1.8 are still there.
I think if there were understandings of what is occuring "behind the scenes" it would make more sense as to why you did not receive a response.
It really disappoints me when someone makes a statement about the reliability without having fully tested it. I ran my 2010 show in LSP 1.8 with 2,800 channels and I won't kid you that it was hard to work around some of the issues. I personally commited to LSP 2.0 about 40% of the bug reports and while I know it is not a 100% perfect product, it has made MAJOR strides over 1.8 in terms of quality.
Could I get you to simply go to screencast-o-matic.com and do a sreen recording of your issues(s) so that we can document them in the bug tracker so they can be resolved? The complaints just don't get the bugs solved - documenting and reporting them does.
David
dirknerkle wrote:Just as a test last night, I imported a working Vixen sequence, configured the controller, verified with the controller test that it was correct, turned on the outputs and ran the sequence. Nothing worked except the audio. This was exactly the same experience I had with version 1.8, so as far as the end result is concerned, it doesn't appear that much has changed.
Are you willing to either document (screencast-o-matic.com) the issue or let one of us remote in and work with you to resolve the issue?
