While I may end up converting to a a RGB Pixel Megatree next year, I doubt I will convert anything else. This year I switched my arches to their own controllers. I had already planned on conerting those to wireless. In cleaninug up after the wind storm yesterday, I came to the realization that I need to go completely wireless. I am down to one Ren 64XC which I have I actually love the setup, but the SSR cables are killing me. All but one of my Minitrees was blown over. With the cold weather moving in, and the trees rolling around in the yard, many of the SSR cables were damaged. 9 of 16 SSR cables were damaged. I spent 2 hours in the below freezing temperatures remaking cables. Not a fun time. I realize it will be expensive, but my goal this year will be to remove most, if not all, cat-5 cables from my display.
So, for all you wireless folks out there, I need recommendations on configuration. For 240 channels of Renard, how many transmitters do I need or what do you recommend. I'm assuming I will switch everything to start address firmware. So each minitree and arch controller will be numbered and fixed for a position in my display. I need to start budgeting and making purchases. Also, since these items are currenlty 4 channel, I would like to get suggestion on the best way to do 8-Channel controllers. I was looking at Dirk's MiniRen8/8VOXB or MiniRen8/4XB board.
This post started out as a PM to Dirk, but I decided that I would take the burden of response off of him and let all his Wireless Cronies provide some input as well. I'm looking to understand how everyone is utilizing wireless. Even if it's just partially. What controllers and what is the configuration? Number of Transmitters, repeaters?, start address setup?
I took my first tentative wireless steps this year. I am running one xbee pro transmitter off of the output of one of my SS24's and have a xbee pro receiver which is on the input side of an SS8 which then feeds another SS8 via rs485. I had tried running 2 receivers, but couldn't get the second to run reliably. I think it was a range/line of sight issue. If I buy more radios, I would get the xbee pros with the external antenna, not that little whip thing. I have a very big yard (6 acres) and I think that external antenna would help a lot.
I did use the Renard start address set-up, and that worked very well. I just marked inside each enclosure if I had a start address programmed so I wouldn't forget next year about the start address. Also, if you are transmitting from the output of another controller, remember that the radios should be setup for 57600 8, n, 1 not 57600 8, e, 2 as they are usually set up for if they are transmitting straight off a computer.
I have noticed they occassional stray "blip" on the lights that are fed off the radio, but usually only 3 or 4 random flashes per song. To be honest, I think I'm the only one who notices. We are generally or own worst critics.
Rob
Hah! You've chosen to come over to the dark side!!!! 😥
If it's any consolation, reducing the cable clutter was exactly why I went this way... and it's been quite a nice change. It's quite a luxury, but all things considered, it's probably saved me hundreds of hours of time, and for a guy who's already 64, time is becoming more precious as each month goes by...
Kelly, what I did was look at my display in terms of individual display elements that essentially "stand alone." The windows on my house are obvious examples -- each has a PVC frame around it with strings of red, blue, green and yellow LEDs. So each frame has its own 8/4XB controller and one, single 120vac power cord dangling from it. The mini-trees are similar -- each has all strings of all four colors and currently is using an SSR but will be converted to its own 8/4XB next year (they're already built; I just have to install them on the mini-tree PVC frames). Next year I won't have to position the mini-trees in fairly close proximity with each other -- I can put them anywhere I want. I may even build some more and put them across the street in a neighbor's yard, programmed to the same channels.
Essentially, the concept I've used is small-channel count, self-standing controllers built onto/into the display piece, so we're really talking about 4 or 8-channel controllers here. That said, I do deviate a bit: my megatree has 24 channels around, 12 up the center pole and a star topper. So I have an SS24 and an SS16 at the base of the tree; each has either an Xbee Snap-In or a Ren-W. I also use an SS24 at the base of a Canada red cherry tree to animate the trunk (12 channels) and 11 strings up in the branches of the tree. The 24th channel goes to my tune-to sign which can be animated, too. I have a Ren48LSD that powers the jumbo RGB coroplast ornaments that also hang in that tree -- of course, those use cat5 runs for both power and control to each ornament.
So for areas where a higher channel count is needed to cover the display, I use a larger self-contained controller that's wireless using either the XBee snap-in or a Ren-W. But the point is that the controller is "on" or "in" the display itself and only a power cord goes to the display.
This year I have 280 total channels that are being broadcast; of that, only about 220 are actually powering lights. There are a lot of "skipped" channels because I'm not using some display pieces this year (the singing choir, for example). But rather than lose all that sequencing for future years, there just aren't any controllers set to pick up the singing choir's channels this year. I'm not using lights on my bushes this year either -- but they're still in the sequences and the controllers are out there -- but in one case, a MiniRen8/8XB (8-channels) is controlling only one wreath while another MiniRen8/8XB has only two wreaths -- so 3 channels out of 16 are in use while the others are reserved for the bushes, which don't have lights this year. Why no lites on the bushes? Because I put the mini-trees in between the bushes instead. This is how I can make the display look differently from year to year. I don't feel the need to always put out all the lights.
Of course, every controller uses Phil's wonderful creation, start_address firmware. What it translates into are 24 wireless controllers this year. I could be more efficient and re-use channels and have fewer controllers, but that would likely also mean more cabling and I'd probably have to re-sequence things, too. Being that sequencing takes a whole lot more time than simply changing the start address of a controller, I opt for the latter. It all breaks down as follows:
9: Windows
3: Wreaths, garage swag, front entry trees
2: Garage doors
1: Strobes
1: Manger
2: Cherry tree, Jumbo RGB ornaments, tune-to sign
2: Megatree
1: Street lamp candy-cane post
1: 8 firesticks (each firestick has a 675 controller too)
2: minitrees (next year will be 8)
Don't know how much this helps... but I've been very, very pleased with the concept of using many low channel-count controllers. It's more expensive to build eight 8-channel wireless controllers than using a Ren64 and SSRs, but in terms of convenience, it can't be beat. An additional benefit: should one controller go down, it affects a very small part of the display, unlike a Ren64 going down... And in a daisy-chain setup, one controller can take down the whole display.
EDIT: I added a photo of this year's display that supports all the above...
I am moving in the same direction as Dirk has laid out. This year for Halloween I had four faces, eight channels each run with two RenSS16's which meant that I had 32 fifteen foot extensions cords running between the boards and the controllers. I picked up 4 MiniRen8/8XB's from Dirk a few weeks ago so next year there will be only one power cord daisy chained to all controllers (The faces are all LED) and I intend to set it up so that I can move the controller from Halloween faces to Christmas faces that I hope to develope in the coming year.
I have 4 RenSS24's in my Christmas display. I now realize that I could save greatly on extension cords if I used smaller controllers. Also when trouble shooting, it is much easier to swap out small controllers to take indoors to test or repair.
I am totally wireless this year running two XBEE networks from explorer boards off a laptop. I am attaching my XBEE layout spreadsheet as I think it shows how one can organize a wireless setup. I have 176 channels on the first network and 128 on the second. 160 was originally planned but I ran out of time to do the two smaller mega trees that I had planned to do. Hope this helps.
While I have had a couple minor issue with my E1.31 network, the XBee networks have worked flawlessly
As already has been said, the number of radios will depend on the number of controllers you'll eventually need. Start address firmware is the only way to go IMO. I went with the Helix and SS controllers early on, so that's what I've stayed with. I have a Ren-W in my second SS24 by my megatree which is set to transmit only, and snap-in Ren-W's set to receive only in the 2 SS16's that control my 6 minitrees, and the 2 SS16's that control my 4 arches. I wrote the address ID's on the outside of the controller so I don't even have to open up the controller, just plug it in and go. (silver metallic Sharpies work great for this!!). So, total of 5 radios for the minitrees and arches, and 2 radios for the Helix. I'm also controlling my LEDtriks wirelessly using a Ren-W, so 2 more radios for that.
I'm attaching a diagram of my display that I used early in the year when I was discussing my going wireless with Greg and the Dirkmeister, if that helps.
Good luck!
Welcome Kelly, couple considerations from a guy with a mixed wired and wireless display. General broadcast is easier unless you are in a situation that forces daisy-chaining transmitters and receivers, like needing to boost range. If you go GB, the # of transmitters will be tied to your needed # of com channels / display channel count / sequence time resolution. Also choose your transmitter location carefully in terms of maintaining line of sight to the receivers. Was forced this year to shoot one signal through a pinion tree. Fine regularly but com goes a little bonkers in wind as the branches move. Lastly read the wiki very carefully, especially on serial settings and starting addresses.
My 2 centavos. One Xbee standard radio for each controller and with 240 channels, maybe 2 Xbee pro radios as transmitters (if you run 50ms sequences, you should be okay with one. YMMV) I love, love, love the MiniRen8 for my mini trees. Two trees for each controller, with the controller mounted under one of the two trees. Makes setup quick and two weeks in I decided to move the mini trees. Just unplug the main, move and replug. I am thinking of putting one on each of my arches too, but I don't know if it makes sense for me yet. I have 3 arches this year and an SS24 seems to work nice, but who knows next year, right? I always keep a few Xbee standards in reserved, just in case. I've loaned out my extra board, otherwise I would post a picture of how I mount them (in the lid of the GC cases) so I can move them if I need too. Once you go wireless, you'll wonder why you didn't do it sooner. Also, look on eBay occasionally for radios, I have got them for as cheap as $8 each for standard and $11 for pros. Welcome to the dark side, you'll like it here! 🙂
I too am using the wireless meathod that Dirk has outlined. For me its a matter of convienace then the overall cost per channel. Having each "feature" on a seperate "stand-alone" allows me to scalee up or down each year as needed without having to re-sequence or configure any one piece or section
I need to revamp my setup as I did not have the best of lick with the wireless stuff, lots of missing effects, loss of signal etc. I'm sure mounting the renw boards outside the CG1500's would help, maybe looking at doing external antennas , but my 5-6 ren-w's didn't play that well.
I would love to see things go E1.31 and wireless, vs the XBEE's
It is back to the drawing board and rethinking the set up. Dirk has shed new light on how I want to set up next year with some examples that make more sense to me than going with the high channel count controllers I had planned. John also has planted new ideas in my head. I currently have a mix of ss16 ss24 sr32 and a ren64xc in the show. But I think the lower channels count controllers will serve me better next year in some areas and then a few of the middle of the road counts for other things. I had planned using the ren64 fr the mega tree but yes if it fails and since it is the first element in the show the entire show is kaput and would have to take that element out of the show to keep running. I will have a few back up controllers on hand in case. I will be selling some of my equipment to finance new stuff and maybe some more xbee. I have 2 pro and ten standard radios at this time so once I plan the show I will start looking to buy more if needed. I am open to all suggestions since I am as some know pretty green in this area.

