JEC wrote:Not to hijack the thread...
There may be an argument for building a set of DMXArtNet/ACN nodes. Then off-the-shelf wired and wireless networking gear can be used to distribute the data.
I believe about 40 universes of DMX can fit in an Ethernet cable on a private network.
The hold up at the moment is a lack of a Vixen driver and the lack of supporting hardware. I'm having enough trouble finishing my multi-universe DMX dongle. :rolleyes:
JEC wrote:Not to hijack the thread...
There may be an argument for building a set of DMXArtNet/ACN nodes. Then off-the-shelf wired and wireless networking gear can be used to distribute the data.
I believe about 40 universes of DMX can fit in an Ethernet cable on a private network.
Isn't this essentially what ETC is doing with ETCNet2? They use regular network equipment for all connections as well. You have a good point in that it would be much easier to use existing wireless networking equipment. How does one configure TCP/IP over ACN?
JEC wrote:That's a neat little board. Price?
Not sure, you could call/email for a quote. I may do that if we roll with that idea, but see my above post first!
MaxS wrote:Isn't this essentially what ETC is doing with ETCNet2? They use regular network equipment for all connections as well. You have a good point in that it would be much easier to use existing wireless networking equipment. Would you have to mess with TCP/IP at all?
I'll defer to Ben on this one.
From what I understand, there are a few different ethernet-based DMX transmission standards out there. They're not compatible with each other.
However, both ArtNet and ACN are are free, open and have full documentation available. Particularly interesting to me is that lots of commercial lighting software does image-->pixel mapping and outputs ArtNet.
Normally the lighting guys will set up a private wired or wireless network between the control position and the various fixtures / dimmers.
If you're actually building a DMXEthernet bridge, I expect you'd need to be fairly comfortable massaging ethernet packets on a low level.
A Lantronix X-Port may be just the ticket to making everything run smoothly, as it handles all the TCP/IP housekeeping on its own.
Somewhere on the artistic license site are a couple free programs which generate and analyze ArtNet packets.
MaxS wrote:Isn't this essentially what ETC is doing with ETCNet2? They use regular network equipment for all connections as well. You have a good point in that it would be much easier to use existing wireless networking equipment. How does one configure TCP/IP over ACN?
Right, I actually designed and tested the system ETC is using while I worked there. BTW ETC is moving to ACN just like most large manufacturers which can traverse standard networking equipment w/o a problem.
Heh, so there are definitely a few ways to go about this. For scalability and backward-compatibility I would think that DMX over ACN over Ethernet/802.3 would be the way to go, right? (Would that use the 802.11 or 802.3 standard?) But for simplicity, DMX over RS485 over ISM 2.4GHz would work as well. For the time being, because to lack of Vixen support for ACN, would it even be worth it to start developing an ACN-compliant system/DMX-ACN dongle? Phew, I got into a little more than I bargained for when asking about this. 😉
Normally the lighting guys will set up a private wired or wireless network between the control position and the various fixtures / dimmers.
That's exactly what ETC is doing in their systems. They use their proprietary ETCNet2 protocol and use the Ethernet/802.11 standard for everything. Consoles, servers, dimmer racks, and dimmer controllers are all connected to a central switch.
MaxS wrote:Heh, so there are definitely a few ways to go about this. For scalability and backward-compatibility I would think that DMX over ACN over Ethernet/802.3 would be the way to go, right? (Would that use the 802.11 or 802.3 standard?) But for simplicity, DMX over RS485 over ISM 2.4GHz would work as well. For the time being, because to lack of Vixen support for ACN, would it even be worth it to start developing an ACN-compliant system/DMX-ACN dongle? Phew, I got into a little more than I bargained for when asking about this. 😉
Yes, yes and yes.
🙂
All right, well I'll have to start looking into streaming ACN then. Post any more thoughts/ideas in this thread!
MaxS wrote:For the time being, because to lack of Vixen support for ACN, would it even be worth it to start developing an ACN-compliant system/DMX-ACN dongle? Phew, I got into a little more than I bargained for when asking about this. 😉
You can but you will basically be creating a DMX to ACN gateway which is not going to be a trivial task. It would be best, in this case, to have someone crank out an ACN plug-in. It doesn't have to be the full ACN spec it could just be DMX-over-ACN (see my sticky). The request has been made in the Vixen plug-ins forum but not a lot of attention has been paid to it.
BTW you will need/want to buy a copy of the ACN spec from ESTA ($40).
MaxS wrote:Post any more thoughts/ideas in this thread!
Start here:
http://doityourselfchristmas.com/forums/showthread.php?t=184
