E1.31 Protocol Disc...
 
Notifications
Clear all

E1.31 Protocol Discussions

63 Posts
18 Users
0 Reactions
37.3 K Views
Posts: 136
Topic starter
(@j1sys)
Estimable Member
Joined: 17 years ago

Yes the whole spectrum of ip protocols come into the 'proper' designing of a complex LAN. But for most people with $29 Ethernet switches they just need to think about simple isolation techniques to ensure that their LAN does not interfere with their UDP traffic. One reason I recommend using unicast over multicast for gateway devices is that simple (cheap) switches will isolate your LAN traffic somewhat while multicast will be treated like a broadcast and zing all over your LAN.

My recommendation for a show network computer would be to use dual Ethernet controllers if possible. One for the lighting control LAN and the other one for connection to your office/home LAN. If using a laptop/netbook then I would connect the lighting LAN to the Ethernet and use it's wireless to connect to your home/office LAN. This split horizon will keep contention at a minimum.

Even more fun will be had when we see 10,000 channel setups (I heard a rumor of one being planned) that may use multicast sensing switches or routers to help smooth the traffic flow.

As for POE we already have all smd POE devices on the drawing board and entering prototype stage.


Reply
Posts: 2630
(@dynamoben)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago

The bummer about POE is that there isn't much in the way of consumer level POE switches so you a forced to buy or make injectors when can get a bit unwieldy.


Reply
Posts: 136
Topic starter
(@j1sys)
Estimable Member
Joined: 17 years ago

$50-$70 netgear units aren't consumer grade?

Oops- trendnet $70 netgear $120

but I have seen some off brand in the $50 range.


Reply
Posts: 2630
(@dynamoben)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
j1sys wrote:$50-$70 netgear units aren't consumer grade?

Oops- trendnet $70 netgear $120

but I have seen some off brand in the $50 range.

I guess thats not too bad, still more expensive than an "standard" switch. I'm used to buying commerical POE switches.


Reply
Posts: 175
(@aususer)
Estimable Member
Joined: 17 years ago

"seek and ye shall find" thanks for the links.
Might have to see how far I go with gcc for a software-based E1.31/Reynard gateway (to allow me to "retro-fit" my current environment) before I drown 🙂

Re: your $29 hub - I take your point, but considering I can buy an 8port TPLINK with 802.3q for $AU170 its not something that should be discredit out of reach.
I conceed that I haven't seen how much data we are talking about yet.. threads I read put it at ~260Kbs for 1 DMX512 universe (??) @ 10,000channels that would be ~5.2Mbs of raw..

E1.31 does tick a LOT of boxes for me (ie. I run ESXi - and usb/serial is a no-no.. thus I have to have a dedicated show PC :()
it also gives me some project ideas too:
eg. I just threw out old laptops that could have been software-hacked into 22x22 (1universe) "pixel" display (ie. like ledtrix - just using LCDDisplayed-pixels not LEDS).
Put 9 screens in a matrix (I just threw out 9)... 9 dmx universes - wack them all into a waterproof, perspex case.. Run lightshowpro transforms or Madrix..
Not a LED in sight.
you get the idea..and all very do'able by DIYrs.. (old notebooks are e-waste to most companies).

I do have a qustion regarding the E1.31...
Can you have more than one initiator throwing signals out?
I'm looking at ways I could intigrate "kick/stamp pads" into this - and if I can inject E1.31 data from anywhere - I can make a display interactive.


Reply
Page 2 / 13
Share: