RS 485 Line isolato...
 
Notifications
Clear all

RS 485 Line isolator

13 Posts
5 Users
0 Reactions
7,740 Views
Posts: 919
Topic starter
(@scorpia)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
[#4190]

Guys,

after a redesign from my other thread in the renard forum i have come up with the following board.

Its designed to to take an incoming RS232 or 485 signal and then send it down the line to a renard (or possibly any other rs485 device) .

I have used the inline power from the renard but i have also added a 3 pin header to allow you to power the board directly.

About the only other thing i can think of that i need to do is check that the output isnt inverted to the input. If it is i need to swap the A & B pins on the output.

If people think this design is usefull im happy to post the sch & brd files and pdf's etc if required.

Any other comments?

Peter

485 isolate v3 brd
485 isolate v3

12 Replies
kostyun
Posts: 2178
Guest
(@kostyun)
Member
Joined: 20 years ago

One thing I've thought about is a small board with a DB9 on one end, and a RJ45 on the other - you can plug it into a serial port, and have a renard ready RS485 adapter.


Reply
Posts: 919
Topic starter
(@scorpia)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago

easy enough to add. ill see where i can mount it in my box.

hopefully tonight i will make the adjustment.

Peter


Reply
Posts: 6728
(@p-short)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 20 years ago

The output of a 6N137 is open-collector, you need a pullup resistor.

Also, what are you planning on using to drive the circuit? It is pretty clearly way out of spec for DMX, and quite a few RS232 and RS485 implementations will have trouble meeting the input corrent specs for the 6N137. I think that a better implementation would have a second RS485 chip on the left (as a receiver) and a DC-DC converter to provide power for it. This will cost perhaps twice as much, but would be a much more robust design.


Reply
Matt_Edwards
Posts: 2664
(@matt-edwards)
Famed Member
Joined: 18 years ago

I have seen the attached used in low end DMX splitters
Matt

Iso DMX

Reply
Posts: 6728
(@p-short)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 20 years ago

Yes, I've seen similar schematics as well. It would probably work OK with Renard, which is slow and has point-to-point wiring (as opposed to an electrically party-line bus). But I don't trust that design for DMX or any situation where that circuit is in parallel with other receivers over any sort of distance. The impedance appears to vary all over the place (depending on signal amplitude and polarity), and I don't think that it will provide proper input current to the 6N137 under low-signal amplitude conditions (i.e. long lines and/or heavy loading). Someone may come up with an analysis and waveform pictures to refute my skepticism, but until then I would not use that circuit except at the end of a short cable without any other receivers on it.


Reply
Posts: 919
Topic starter
(@scorpia)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
P. Short wrote:The output of a 6N137 is open-collector, you need a pullup resistor.

Also, what are you planning on using to drive the circuit? It is pretty clearly way out of spec for DMX, and quite a few RS232 and RS485 implementations will have trouble meeting the input corrent specs for the 6N137. I think that a better implementation would have a second RS485 chip on the left (as a receiver) and a DC-DC converter to provide power for it. This will cost perhaps twice as much, but would be a much more robust design.

Phil,

thanks for the input. helpfull as allways.

Yes i had thought about adding the input chip but as you said that plus a dc-dc convertor more than doubles the cost i think so i was trying to avoid it.

as for what am i thinking to drive it. well either straight from a pc serial port or the output from a renard board or similar. As for the resistor values etc they are just random values that i will be playing with.

Matt, thanks for that, ill look into it and see what practical differences there are.

peter


Reply
Posts: 919
Topic starter
(@scorpia)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Matt_Edwards wrote:I have seen the attached used in low end DMX splitters
Matt

I have been trying to work out what advantages your picture gives compaired to the single resistor. the best i have come up with is it has a LED indicator when data is transmitted.

can anyone see any other reason for the design?


Reply
Matt_Edwards
Posts: 2664
(@matt-edwards)
Famed Member
Joined: 18 years ago

It represents a more even load to the driving cct.
In your cct no current flows when pin 4 of the RJ45 is more positive than Pin 5. This may lead to false triggering.

The visible LED is but a simple benefit.
Cheers
Matt


Reply
Posts: 919
Topic starter
(@scorpia)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago

Ah yep, see makes sense now.

ill add the extra components and see what happens.

Peter


Reply
Page 1 / 2
Share: