Notifications
Clear all

FGII

30 Posts
12 Users
0 Reactions
15 K Views
mrpackethead
Posts: 2289
(@mrpackethead)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago

MOVING THIS OFF TOPIC DISCUSSION TO /DEVELOPEMNET/SINEWAVE DIMMER

I was pretty sure that reverse phase control reduced harmonics, primarly due to the fact that there is a signifcant reduction in in rush current on turn on... Page 3 on teh attached PDF shows graphs of the harmonics for three different methods of dimming.. Reverse phase shows quite lower harmonics than the reverse.

( yes this is a manufactures advertising, but is pretty much the same as what i've seen elsewhere )

After thinking about this for some time, i am pondering if the reduction in harmonics is not because of reverse phase control, but but because the turn off/turn times of the igbt can be controlled, and the slew rate will be somewhat lower than using a triac/scr

Unforutnatly i'm not talking from a point of much practical experience 🙁

I'm kind of thinking i'd like to try to design and build a sinewave dimmer.. Just because i figure if i can acheive that, i'll have learned somethign new and possibly useful.. I figure that a you'd need to run a pwm signal in the order of 1000x the mains frequency ( 50/60khz ).. And a small passive filter network on the output.. Perhaps even the cable feeding the lamp might be enough.. I' thinking that correct igbt selection will be critical though.. and smoking it might be quite a possiblity during protoyping..

What have i missed in my simplistic thinking?


Reply
Posts: 6728
(@p-short)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 20 years ago

How much of the reduced harmonics and noise of the reversed phase dimming is due to thermal effects? I'm not sure how much a lamp filament temperature and resistance varies on the time scale of an AC power cycle. These could both be significantly different at the switching times between regular and reverse phase dimming, resulting in a smaller di/dt and DT/dt at the time of switching with reverse phase dimming.

--

Phil


Reply
Posts: 2630
(@dynamoben)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago

You guys are discussing two different topics one is feed harmonics and the other is filament hum/sing. I don't want to completely hijack this thread so let’s continue here:

http://doityourselfchristmas.com/forums/showthread.php?p=21513#post21513


Reply
WildWillie
Posts: 122
(@wildwillie)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago

FG,

How's the newest version coming along?? Anything new to let us in on??


Reply
FireGod
Posts: 655
Topic starter
(@firegod)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
WildWillie wrote:FG,

How's the newest version coming along?? Anything new to let us in on??

You saw I got revision 1 put together on 2/16/08 and I found a couple of problems. I left town on a business trip 2/17/08 and I have not been back home since.

I have the PCB design revised and I expect to get home next week and give it a second try.

Thanks for the intrest and I'll let you know how revision 2 goes.


Reply
Page 4 / 6
Share: