ebrady - reverse-phase dimming or converting to DC are still not particularly clean as far as the power line goes, since the load is still not very resistive. The SCRs/transistors end up relatively isolated from the effects of garbage on the lines, but those solutions still result in disturbances on the power liness.
djulien - slowing the rise/fall times increases the power dissipated by the power switching elements, so they present their own problems (as well as still being a non-linear load).
Also, I'm not sure that the lower currents of the LEDs helps much. I think that triacs (or their kissing cousins, SCRs) are still cheaper than higher-voltage transistors.
BAM - I've quickly coded up a version of the Renard firmware that implements the BAM algorithm, stripping out all AC functionality in the process. However, I'm not at home, and haven't had a chance to debug/test it, so uploading it out will be an exercise for another day. It will be unsupported code, however, as I really don't want to have to support a second version of the Renard firmware.
P. Short wrote:ebrady - reverse-phase dimming or converting to DC are still not particularly clean as far as the power line goes, since the load is still not very resistive. The SCRs/transistors end up relatively isolated from the effects of garbage on the lines, but those solutions still result in disturbances on the power liness.
Yes, reverse phase is still "dirty" with regards the power lines, however I understand that it is easier on bulbs, (no filament oscillations). Sine wave dimming is the cleanest. There will be some 50Khz switching noise (+ harmonics), but at an emission level which is likely to be negligible when compared to forward/reverse phase designs. Unfortunately, this is the most expensive and complex .
P. Short wrote:slowing the rise/fall times increases the power dissipated by the power switching elements, so they present their own problems (as well as still being a non-linear load).
Whoops, forgot about the power dissipation.
Is it possible to "switch" back and forth between 2 somewhat even loads? For example, if the existing triac circuit can be thought of as a SPST switch which simply turns the power off part way through the AC half-cycle, then is there the equivalent of a SPDT switch that could be used to switch back and forth between the lights and a similar size load that is not lights? Maybe this would hide the dimming action from the power source (reducing the noise?), and make it look like a normal steady-on load.
Also, if complementary pairs of loads is feasible, then maybe some of the "wasted" power from the non-lighted part of the cycle could be reclaimed by using reverse dimming with that (as long as the forward- and reverse- dimmed angles do not overlap).
don
dirknerkle wrote:Another approach might be to create power supplies that provided clean 120vdc and power lights with that using existing PWM concepts with MOSFETS (or other power components?) instead of triacs.
The main problem with this is that AC LED strands are designed to maintain a given power level when provided with 120v RMS - but there are multiple ways to achieve this.
You can have a strand with fairly low Vf that is lit for a fairly large portion of the AC phase, and has a fairly low peak current compared to the average current.
You could have a different strand with a higher Vf that conducts for a fairly small portion of the AC cycle, and will have MUCH higher peak current to maintain the same average current.
Connect them both to a constant-voltage DC source, and you'll see very different brightness/current levels.
It's disappointing that it seems like the Aussies/New Zealanders haven't standardized their low voltage lighting - they have a wide variety of strand voltages, and most are fed by AC transformers.
A commercial standard for, say, 48VDC strands that were weatherproofed would be GREAT. Such strands could be dimmed using any one of a variety of DC dimming methods.
Obviously there's the power supply issue in this case - but it is fairly easy to get good 48VDC switching power supplies that have good power factor and efficiency.
