After talking with jchuchla recently I realized it would be better if I had a clearer idea of what I wanted to achieve and more importantly, how I was going to do it. I've poked around here and the net looking for posts/tutorials but I'm not really seeing anything that really covers it. The closest I've come is this thread: http://doityourselfchristmas.com/forums/showthread.php?41581-Suggested-Window-Frame-grouping&highlight=setup+organize
It's somewhat close to what I am looking for but not really in-depth enough.
Essentially, I'm not looking for "How do I..." but rather "Why do I...". I want to have a better grasp on things I will need to consider when I setup my display. I can create controllers and elements all day but it won't matter if I don't understand how to group and manage them. If I start scaling up how will I maintain my sanity?
I guess I'm asking if there is any information out there where the focus is not so much on how to setup your display and sequences but more on why you would want to setup or configure a specific way. I'm assuming there are multiple ways to use Vixen and if I want to get the best results for me I should have a good understanding of the logic behind what is going on and how it all interacts with itself.
I hope that makes sense!
I love this question. You can reflect back to me if it's on point or not (no ego in it).
First, any of us can provide conceptual and philosophical information to you, but it's only really going to sink in from trying it no matter how savvy you are or how much you study (I went through this 2016). I recommend setting up a small test bench with a few strings, maybe a small matrix (punch some pixels through cardboard), and experiment with different groupings and how effects behave on them. I say that because there can be personal aspects to the technique of grouping, such as preferred mental model and style.
What organization in grouping best matches the mental model you will best think in while sequencing? You have to discover that yourself. For me I like to think of my house as a nested model that starts from an "everything" group down to individual groups, then strings, named and organized by location on my house. Style comes in because with some more complex elements (circles, trees) grouping can change how effects behave. Point being you have to do R&D. With that said, here's my philosophy.
Principally I use grouping to facilitate high organization so I can exclude element details when I don't need to thing about them (if I want the whole house to turn white I don't want to think about each element), and then also for sequencing convenience/speed. Groups are sort of like using functions in programming.
Here's my house:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FflNAOiUfG4
Here's my groupings:
I'm just going to throw out examples of why I made the groups seen here. Without my groupings much of what I've sequenced would not be feasible:
-Several groups on there are basic and just combine like elements (e.g. Floods, Wreaths).
-I have 3 circle props. I chose to model each circle as a group of individual rings to give me more flexibility to apply individual effects to different parts of each circle. (e.g. in the opening of the video the beats are applied to individual rings)
-I made "All Circles" so I can apply a single effect to trigger all circles.
-I made "2BigCircles" because I often use the middle circle as a centerpiece doing something different (like reacting to snare hits, flute runs, whatever), while the 2 big circles are synchronized (like @42sec in video where big circles are the bass drum)
-I broke up each wreath into a "front" and "back" group. Which allows me to make more subtle glowing effects by only using the rear lights at times (e.g. @28sec).
-Roofline is a master grouping of my roof broken into halves, then quadrants, then individual segments (which is also how they are wired and installed). The segment groups allow me to do things like have the rooflines individually follow the bells (e.g. @38sec). It was my choice to create the individual segments (T1, T2, T3, etc).
-Everything is all elements (@1:06 sec whole house turning white)
-"Mouths" is a super custom group for my middle circle I only use for one song. It groups the middle pixels in my circle so they look like a closed lip. That way I just put one solid color effect and I get that closed mouth.
-The subsequent circle groups are multiple variations of organizing the pixels in the circle by degrees (e.g. "pie slices") rather than concentric rings. This radically changes how a chase and some other effects look on the rings (see @1:41 with the green
fan/windmill looking effect). It was 6 months into my project before I recognized this as a possibility. Makes me wonder what else I haven't thought of.
If I had window and other house structure outlines, I'd probably have things like this to make it convenient to do a lot of different stuff:
-All Windows
-Individual Windows
-All Window Verticals
-All Window Horizontals
-Upper Windows
-Lower Windows
Getting a bit crazy:
-All Left Verticals
-All Right Verticals
-All Top Horizontals
-All Even Top Verticals
-All Odd Top Verticals
I'd only do that though if in my sequence I want to trigger the lights in those manners frequently, like I wanted the beat to alternate on all top horizontal window lines for the snare, and botom horizontals for bass drum. Why "write a function" you will never call, right? Some people will also say, why in god's name have a bass drum in a Xmas song, haha.
Note I can do all of that easily in Vixen. None of the groupings exclude another from existing. For someone who doesn't want to go to that detail this many groups will be obnoxious to navigate. Some Vixen effects allow us to choose at what grouping level they render also. I can put the Vertical Meter music effect on my "Rooflines" group and the effect gives me 5 options to render at the parent group, the halve group, the quadrant group, or the individual strings group. It changes the look. Same for twinkle with color gradients. Some of my grouping is also just to help with "writer's block" at times, that's how I thought of the degree groupings.
BTW here was my "test bench", this exercise was vital for me. I figured out the "rings" grouping concept, figured out I didn't want to use ribbon, chose the type of C9 I wanted
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ify3Q2gpfUA
Your post was definitely on point!
First off, your post was much more than I anticipated getting. The videos with reference points for your explanation really helped to see it in action. I've literally read and re-read your post and watched the video sections a dozen times. I'm a big fan of the way the glowing effect with the wreath looks! Thank you for taking the time to do that!
The grouping concept was really intimidating at first. The first time I ran V3 and realized it wasn't just an upgraded V2 but a whole new beast I panicked, LOL.
This I think was the crux of my concern: I can create a group with select elements and nested sub-elements to my hearts desire, but will the way I have my groups setup prevent me from doing specific effects? My initial thought was to have a main group: "Everything" and all sub-groups would be nested inside it. That seemed logical at first but I realized that if I wanted to do a global effect just applying the effect to the "Everything" group wouldn't result in what I wanted. A "Cylon" effect applied to "Everything" would follow the order of the elements in the timeline, not the way they are setup physically.
The screencap of your timeline made me realize I could create additional "top-level" groups and organize them for specific effects, like having them in the order I want to do a chase effect. It makes sense but I have to admit I have my doubts about this line of thinking as I can see myself winding up with lots of identical element groups in different orders just to have a single different effect apply. I suspect that this idea might not be related to grouping at all but perhaps to another aspect of the software I haven't gotten to yet.
I'm not intimidated at all to go into detail with my groups. I honestly would prefer to have the "crazy" ones you listed and then even more detail like window corner and pane groups. I'm sure I will wind up doing this to the nth degree.
I wanted to avoid a situation where I would have to restart or heavily modify a project because I hadn't taken something into account from the get-go. My brain was stuck on the thinking my group heirarchy was limited to a single tree but that's clearly not the case. I feel now any limitation I encounter won't be software, grouping or hardware related - it will simply be my imagination. I agree, R&D is important for me right now. I do have a work area that I'm using now to see how different effects work.
I basically wanted to know if others ran into unanticipated issues in the past because of the way they had set up their groups or displays. I'll grudgingly admit that there may have been a time or two I've kicked myself for rushing into a project and missing something that was important down the road that I think I should have realized beforehand.
Keep your sanity......thats funny. Won't Happen by the way, no one in their right mind would ever take on what we do.
I have been putting up lights since 1976. I lost my sanity somewhere around 1977.

