Notifications
Clear all

Dmx?

9 Posts
5 Users
0 Reactions
3,715 Views
Posts: 1420
Topic starter
(@1pet2-9)
Noble Member
Joined: 6 years ago
[#56751]

Hi, general question: is Vixen very good at DMX? I've got a show to do that's mostly DMX stage lights, with a little pixels mixed in. I like Xlights, and technically it CAN do anything DMX, but it's not so good at it. The stage light sequencers more-or-less can't do ws2811. Was wondering if Vixen's effects can seamlessly apply themselves to both ws2811 and DMX, before I spend much time learning it?


8 Replies
ChiefWarrant
Posts: 570
(@chiefwarrant)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
1pet2_9 wrote:Hi, general question: is Vixen very good at DMX? I've got a show to do that's mostly DMX stage lights, with a little pixels mixed in. I like Xlights, and technically it CAN do anything DMX, but it's not so good at it. The stage light sequencers more-or-less can't do ws2811. Was wondering if Vixen's effects can seamlessly apply themselves to both ws2811 and DMX, before I spend much time learning it?

I use Vixen to drive 60 channels of DMX, thousands of pixel channels and hundreds of Renard channels, all without issue. I also have a DMX 3-axis RGB spot beam I am toying with. All are fully supported in Vixen.

I am not an xLights user, but I had always assumed that it can do the same thing as Vixen. I mostly use DMX in my show for "dumb" RGB props and mechanical relays, but Vixen recently revamped their 3-axis DMX support, calling it intelligent fixtures, which I still tinker with in my spare time.


Reply
MartinMueller2003
Posts: 7613
(@martinmueller2003)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 14 years ago

I think you need to stop thinking about DMX and start thinking in terms of channels being controlled. Both Vixen and xLights were designed to control channels of lighting. Pixels were added later and are just three (or four) channels logically bound together (with special attributes).

Effects are applied to channels. Some effects work better with pixels and others work better with strings of lights or individual lighting fixtures. It is up to you to use effects that make your show shine. FYI: Channels can be grouped together to form elements (like my old superstrings) that can have more sophisticated effects applied to them. My superstrings had RGBYW 150 light strings. That is a 4 channel group. In vixen I added color handling filters to the channels and applied effects to the group as opposed to the channels. xLights has the same functionality (uses different words). Using this you can get color changes and simple chase / wave effects. Sophisticated effects like moving shapes, swirls etc. will require some pixels.

DMX is just one of many ways of grouping a set of channels together.


Reply
Posts: 1420
Topic starter
(@1pet2-9)
Noble Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Maybe I can be more specific: Xlights will let you set any DMX channel to any integer value at any time frame, so yes, Xlights CAN do anything in DMX. But now let's try strobe effect: pixels go on-off at some user-specified period. But for DMX, that's shutter. You keep RGBAW on, but set shutter to some value between 1-254. You have to use two effects: strobe for pixels, and a DMX effect for DMX. DMX props pretty much always have to use only the DMX effect, where you can control the channels. Whereas the rest of the effects have this abstraction layer, such as "Twinkle" or "Butterly". If I lay down a row of Renard AC's, I can apply a Single Strand effect and the Renard lights will go on/off in a cascade, like you would expect. But the DMX, I have to lay down a bunch of DMX effects by hand. And with stage lights, what I want is the Marquee effect--which is a pain to do by hand. I've created marquee chases on a light board, and that takes forever. I line a window frame with pixels, and I get instant Marquee by laying down that one effect.

Similarly, if I go over to QLC+, it has an EFX menu which lets you move your moving heads in all sorts of patterns, like figure-8's. But in Xlights, I have to figure out all those pan and tilt values by hand, and all I can do are a bunch of quantized frames. I'm much more limited in what I can realistically do.

Plus, the visualizer/preview window doesn't really portray the DMX lights that well. I can model the moving head itself, or a floodlight, or an area that's washed in light. Cones of light aren't really modelled. I guess people don't haze their outdoor displays nearly as much as they do indoor, but in the end I have to just visualize the moving beams in my head. The visualizer only shows me the heads themselves move.


Reply
MartinMueller2003
Posts: 7613
(@martinmueller2003)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 14 years ago
1pet2_9 wrote:Maybe I can be more specific: Xlights will let you set any DMX channel to any integer value at any time frame, so yes, Xlights CAN do anything in DMX. But now let's try strobe effect: pixels go on-off at some user-specified period. But for DMX, that's shutter. You keep RGBAW on, but set shutter to some value between 1-254. You have to use two effects: strobe for pixels, and a DMX effect for DMX. DMX props pretty much always have to use only the DMX effect, where you can control the channels. Whereas the rest of the effects have this abstraction layer, such as "Twinkle" or "Butterly". If I lay down a row of Renard AC's, I can apply a Single Strand effect and the Renard lights will go on/off in a cascade, like you would expect. But the DMX, I have to lay down a bunch of DMX effects by hand. And with stage lights, what I want is the Marquee effect--which is a pain to do by hand. I've created marquee chases on a light board, and that takes forever. I line a window frame with pixels, and I get instant Marquee by laying down that one effect.

Similarly, if I go over to QLC+, it has an EFX menu which lets you move your moving heads in all sorts of patterns, like figure-8's. But in Xlights, I have to figure out all those pan and tilt values by hand, and all I can do are a bunch of quantized frames. I'm much more limited in what I can realistically do.

Plus, the visualizer/preview window doesn't really portray the DMX lights that well. I can model the moving head itself, or a floodlight, or an area that's washed in light. Cones of light aren't really modelled. I guess people don't haze their outdoor displays nearly as much as they do indoor, but in the end I have to just visualize the moving beams in my head. The visualizer only shows me the heads themselves move.

This is where I begin to use the term "DMX Fixture". DMX is a protocol on a wire. A DMX fixture (Light, moving head etc.) has special needs. They use groups of DMX Channels to achieve a goal. Vixen is in the process of adding support for some DMX Fixtures. I do not know the level of support available for DMX Fixtures in xLights.


Reply
Page 1 / 2
Share: