I've used Vixen since day one and I haven't really played with any new sequences due to Work,etc. I'm going to do some more sequences for next year so I was wondering if getting the songs to sync to lights is still trial and error using beat marks,etc?
I ask because I have seen some Vixen sequences that when the Song hit a mark,the lights were spot on. I think mine are really good,but some are down right awesome.
I think there will always be some trial and error but the beat/bar detection in Vixen seems to do a much better job now detecting the beat for you instead of having to go through and mash down a key to make a mark like before. Leaves me more time to play with the effect parameters and curves to find some new things like the liquid effect!
Mine are done by slowing down the music to 25%, put it on loop for a 1sec period and then move the mark until it looks like it is in the right place for the instrument/voice I am working on. The beat mark tools are pretty good with the music major beat but when you are working with multiple voices or a violin that is not the major instrument then you have to do a bit of listening and hunting.
I wouldn't so much call it trial and error. It's more about learning the tools and how and when to use them. Once you're comfortable with the tools, the timing becomes easy. I almost never use the mark tapper feature. I find it to be the least effective way to get good beats. I only use the tapper feature to mark major reference points in the song such as verses and refrains. I don't use these for timing effects, but rather as a reference for when I'm scrolling thru a song.
Martin's observations are spot on. The beat detection works very well to get the main beats of the song. But it doesn't find the notes. Beat detection also works much better on music with a heavy beat. Like electronic music and a lot of pop. It doesn't do so well on instrumental or a cappela music. It also doesn't do well for songs with mixed time signatures.
If you want note marks, you're best served by generating those marks in audacity with some of the advanced detection plugins such as the queen mary plugins. There's a note detection function that works fairly well for certain songs. Audacity calls them label tracks or something like that. You can import those tracks from audacity into a Vixen mark collection. Some of my a cappela songs are done with this method.
There's always the slow it down and repeat method too. That's really tedious, but it works well. If you want a real challenge, try sequencing minitrees to the notes of a banjo riff!
It's not too late to add sequences for THIS season. I haven't added any new ones to mine yet, but I'm working on a few that I expect to get into the show before Christmas
Thanks guys.
