Newbie question on ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Newbie question on controllers

5 Posts
4 Users
0 Reactions
732 Views
Posts: 13
Topic starter
(@jharding)
Active Member
Joined: 1 year ago
[#58864]

This may be common knowledge, but I'm looking for some details on the popular pixel controllers to help make my selection most effective for my setup. I have googled and found some comparisons between Falcon, Kulp, alphapix, etc, but nothing that highlights advantages/disadvantages in functionality.

I am just starting my first pixel light setup with a permanent house outlines of 4 strings of 12v node lights mounted 2 inches apart in j-channel. I plan on adding some temporary house props/window outlines, etc, but maybe in the future.

I mentioned this in a different thread where I was troubleshooting a bad first pixel in a string, but I have 4 different spots where I could mount a controller (yellow box)
1. Attic (needs drilling)
2. Under roof overhang (weatherproof box)
3.On wall by front door (closest to power)
4. In garage (drilling to hide wires)

House Front Wiring

I'm mainly looking at Falcon and Kulp controllers. From my research, the Falcon would require a show player (computer hooked via LAN), Raspberry PI with wireless or LAN). The Kulps have the Beaglebone that runs FPP and either wireless or LAN adapters.

I am looking to connect the 4 pixel strings to the pixel outputs of the controller. If I did run some props or window outlines, they would connect to the pixel outputs as well, so a Kulp K16 or Falcon F5 would be my best bet. Would like to do wireless if it makes sense until my show gets bigger.

If I did keep the controller in the garage, then a differential in location 2 to the 4 pixel strings would be just one LAN coming out of the garage and easier to hide, but power would be difficult

How much manual configuration is needed with the controllers once they are hooked up? Sending sequences/updating FPP? The only "frequently accessible" locations are the garage and wall by the front door.

Thank you for the help. If there is another post that already covers all this info, please point me in that direction


4 Replies
Posts: 1420
(@1pet2-9)
Noble Member
Joined: 6 years ago

I am partial to the Kulp.controllers,.and think they are noob-friendly because of the way they are self-contained. I hear bad things about Holidaycoro and thus Hinxpros.

Someone new at this will probably constantly go back-and-forth, adjusting the controller. You're figuring it out. I'm in my 5th year or so and I'm not changing that much now (especially after figuring out the point of having pigtails). However, I did just have a scare at 5pm when my entire 32-port controller wouldn't finish the boot sequence. Turns out it was the power supply (thank God ..), but still, I had to mess with the controller, with some screwdrivers, to debug and swap the PSU.


Reply
Posts: 13
Topic starter
(@jharding)
Active Member
Joined: 1 year ago
1pet2_9 wrote:
I am partial to the Kulp.controllers,.and think they are noob-friendly because of the way they are self-contained. I hear bad things about Holidaycoro and thus Hinxpros.

Someone new at this will probably constantly go back-and-forth, adjusting the controller. You're figuring it out. I'm in my 5th year or so and I'm not changing that much now (especially after figuring out the point of having pigtails). However, I did just have a scare at 5pm when my entire 32-port controller wouldn't finish the boot sequence. Turns out it was the power supply (thank God ..), but still, I had to mess with the controller, with some screwdrivers, to debug and swap the PSU.

So the Kulp controller with the beaglebone runs the show standalone as long as you have network connectivity to load it? Is the SD card just to install FPP on the beaglebone?


Reply
Posts: 3
(@lalan45)
Active Member
Joined: 11 months ago
jharding wrote:
This may be common knowledge, but I'm looking for some details on the popular pixel controllers to help make my selection most effective for my setup. I have googled and found some comparisons between Falcon, Kulp, alphapix, etc, but nothing that highlights advantages/disadvantages in functionality.

I am just starting my first pixel light setup with a permanent house outlines of 4 strings of 12v node lights mounted 2 inches apart in j-channel. I plan on adding some temporary house props/window outlines, etc, but maybe in the future.

I mentioned this in a different thread where I was troubleshooting a bad first pixel in a string, but I have 4 different spots where I could mount a controller (yellow box)
1. Attic (needs drilling)
2. Under roof overhang (weatherproof box)
3.On wall by front door (closest to power)
4. In garage (drilling to hide wires)

House Front Wiring

I'm mainly looking at Falcon and Kulp controllers. From my research, the Falcon would require a show player (computer hooked via LAN), Raspberry PI with wireless or LAN). The Kulps have the Beaglebone that runs FPP and either wireless or LAN adapters.

I am looking to connect the 4 pixel strings to the pixel outputs of the controller. If I did run some props or window outlines, they would connect to the pixel outputs as well, so a Kulp K16 or Falcon F5 would be my best bet. Would like to do wireless if it makes sense until my show gets bigger.

If I did keep the controller in the garage, then a differential in location 2 to the 4 pixel strings would be just one LAN coming out of the garage and easier to hide, but power would be difficult

How much manual configuration is needed with the controllers once they are hooked up? Sending sequences/updating FPP? The only "frequently accessible" locations are the garage and wall by the front door.

Thank you for the help. If there is another post that already covers all this info, please point me in that direction

Both Falcon and Kulp are solid. Kulp is simpler since it has FPP built in; Falcon usually needs a Pi but is very flexible. Garage mounting is easiest for access and protection, and after the initial setup, you rarely need to touch the controller again.


Reply
Posts: 2507
(@mrgrumpy)
Famed Member
Joined: 12 years ago

I went through several controllers before I got a Kulp. I figured since Dan Kulp was the lead developer for the BeagleBone side of FPP, he knew what a controller needs and how to work it into the FPP or work the FPP into his controller. So, I bought a Kulp controller in a group buy many years ago. That one controller is now 6 Kulp controllers running my show, If I expand it will also be a Kulp.


Reply
Share: