Controller Safety
 
Notifications
Clear all

Controller Safety

17 Posts
6 Users
0 Reactions
3,102 Views
(@oyarsa)
Posts: 68
Estimable Member
Topic starter
 
[#54877]

It seems to me that a lot of pieces of equipment in this hobby are fairly cheap. The most expensive piece is the controller. I figure that if I fry a string of lights or a power supply, it's not the end of the world, but if I fry the controller, my wife might end me. Have you fried a controller? If so, how? What are the ways in which you can damage a controller?


 
Posted : 13/11/2021 11:59 am
(@1pet2-9)
Posts: 1420
Noble Member
 

The best piece of advice I have seen on this forum is, rely 100% on power injection. If you ever get a short, your power supplies have short detection, but we cannot guarantee that the PCB trace on your controller will not blow out if you drive it hard with power and then get a short.


 
Posted : 13/11/2021 12:51 pm
rstehle
(@rstehle)
Posts: 4348
Illustrious Member
 

If you are using one of the more popular brands of controller (i.e. Falcon) the outputs are fused, so a short on a pixel run will not harm your controller. Check yours for output fuses, if they are there, you are good to go. If there are none, then you will def want to fuse each output.


 
Posted : 13/11/2021 1:34 pm
 kev
(@kev)
Posts: 1387
Noble Member
 

Like anything (car, stove, lawn mower) safety devices/limits are built in. But we always seem to find ways to exceed the limitations of the devices in ways the manufacturer did not think of. Like using a car to pull a fifth wheel or a lawn mower to trim your hedge or a toaster to dry your socks.

So the best advice is - Do Not Overload the Controller or Power Supply. You often read of people who say " I will only run at 30% so I can run more pixels and then can't figure out what might have damaged their board.


Kevin

 
Posted : 13/11/2021 2:24 pm
(@oyarsa)
Posts: 68
Estimable Member
Topic starter
 

kev - I do need to do some calculating. I think I'm well within limits, but better safe than sorry!


 
Posted : 16/11/2021 11:16 am
MartinMueller2003
(@martinmueller2003)
Posts: 7615
Illustrious Member
 
rstehle wrote:If you are using one of the more popular brands of controller (i.e. Falcon) the outputs are fused, so a short on a pixel run will not harm your controller. Check yours for output fuses, if they are there, you are good to go. If there are none, then you will def want to fuse each output.

If you short the data line to V+ you can damage the output driver. Not much you can do about it but replace the output buffers. If you melt a power trace you move to power injection. In both cases your accountant will not harm you. Put 24v on any pin and you have cooked the controller and need to ask forgiveness.


[/SIGPIC]
2026 - Four more 3d printed singing faces, vertical strips for the arches, 2 new 24px24p matrix signs for the sides of the yard.
2025 - Added two 3d Printed singing light bulbs, Added Stars on top of mid and mini trees
2024 - Prop rebuilds
https://www.youtube.com/user/MartinMueller2003

 
Posted : 16/11/2021 12:01 pm
(@1pet2-9)
Posts: 1420
Noble Member
 

What about the mistake far easier to make: reversing the Power/Ground polarity leads?

Although I guess if you have loose strands in your VDD line going into the screw terminal, that could touch the data pin. That would be a problem. I'm glad these new boards have those removable 3-pin screw terminals now.


 
Posted : 16/11/2021 12:11 pm
(@oyarsa)
Posts: 68
Estimable Member
Topic starter
 

Well...I learned today that it's a good thing my controller has fuses. Blew two of them. I was making a failed attempt at attaching led strips to the peak of my roof. In the process, I had to cut the strip and solder input wires to the cut end. My soldering skills leave something to be desired. I'm not at all sure what I did wrong, but when I plugged it into the controller, the lights didn't work. I tried a different port and noticed the fuse pop for that port and realized the same had happened for the first port. I stopped with that LED strip and soldered a different strip. That one worked fine. Guess I need to get two fuses and hope that's all it did. I suppose I can manage with 14 ports, if necessary. At least I didn't fry the board...


 
Posted : 17/11/2021 7:51 pm
 kev
(@kev)
Posts: 1387
Noble Member
 

don't get 2 fuses. get 10


Kevin

 
Posted : 17/11/2021 9:28 pm
jchuchla
(@jchuchla)
Posts: 8698
Illustrious Member
 

When it comes to controller design, all those terminal blocks and fuses and the space they take on the board is one of the biggest things that drives up the cost of the controller. Take a look at the falcon expander board for example. It's $50 That expansion board is pretty much a carbon copy of the bottom of the main f16 board. So if you're going to do all your power distributon and fusing off the main controller, what's the point of paying for all those features on the controller itself. some of the first pixel controllers (e.g. sandevices e680) out there did just this, skipped the fuses and terminal blocks. They were simple and cheap, but the users wanted fusing and terminal blocks, so the next generation of controllers got them. It's been that way ever since. I don't see any benefit separating power distributing and fusing from the controller itself.

I can see how these days newcomers think that controllers seem to be expensive. They have gone up in price from the early days. I seem to recall an e680 was around $60. But you don't have to assemble them yourself anymore. And features and horsepower have certainly increased as well. But really even at $200 they are still a bargain. Commercial equivalents cost considerably more. Here's one example from Enttec at $735 that only has 8 ports and will only handle 2730 pixels. SO when the wife complains, just show her that link and convince her how frugal you really are.

I'm a big advocate of using a lot of controllers, each controller controlling a relatively small percentage of your show. I've got a rather modest show compared to many of the pixel addicts out there. Only 17,000 channels. But there's 35 controllers driving it. And I've got a backup for almost every controller model I have in use.

The biggest piece of advice is to design your layout so that your board can handle 100% of the load at 100% signal levels. that way, when some config mishap happens, you don't end up with problems.


[/SIGPIC]

My Display: www.facebook.com/ChuchlaFamilyLights
My Videos: www.youtube.com/jchuchla
My Pics: http://photos.chuchla.com/?aid=606

 
Posted : 17/11/2021 9:42 pm
(@oyarsa)
Posts: 68
Estimable Member
Topic starter
 

Sounds like good advice.

I don't begrudge the price of the controller. I believe it is quite reasonable for what I got. Just want to make sure my stupidity doesn't destroy it! I already wasted about $150 today (see post about where to install LED strip). Guess maybe I should have been more concerned about the LED strip install than the controller.


 
Posted : 17/11/2021 10:20 pm
jchuchla
(@jchuchla)
Posts: 8698
Illustrious Member
 
kev wrote:don't get 2 fuses. get 10

I didn't realize you could get them in packs less than 50.


[/SIGPIC]

My Display: www.facebook.com/ChuchlaFamilyLights
My Videos: www.youtube.com/jchuchla
My Pics: http://photos.chuchla.com/?aid=606

 
Posted : 17/11/2021 10:29 pm
(@1pet2-9)
Posts: 1420
Noble Member
 
oyarsa wrote:Sounds like good advice.

I don't begrudge the price of the controller. I believe it is quite reasonable for what I got. Just want to make sure my stupidity doesn't destroy it! I already wasted about $150 today (see post about where to install LED strip). Guess maybe I should have been more concerned about the LED strip install than the controller.

Join the club, I just fried a controller today! Fortunately, only an arduino. Power/ground short, power routed right through it. Melted the solder, the surface mounts just came right offfffff the board!


 
Posted : 17/11/2021 11:36 pm
(@oyarsa)
Posts: 68
Estimable Member
Topic starter
 

Sorry to hear that! What were you doing that led to the short?


 
Posted : 17/11/2021 11:38 pm
(@1pet2-9)
Posts: 1420
Noble Member
 

Testing LED strips. Everything worked fine in the lab, and then I fished an IP65 strip through a PEX tube that I had left out in the rain, and it built up water and mud inside. For reasons I don't yet understand, that shorted power and.ground in an IP65 strip. Letting the arch drain and hoping that fixes it.


 
Posted : 18/11/2021 12:41 am
Page 1 / 2
Share: