A dimmable output using an SSR works by delaying the "Turn-On" signal to the relay by a variable delay based on the desired output intensity.
A Zero-Cross Relay only allows you to turn it on within a specific window near the zero-cross point.
A Random turn on relay allows you to turn on the relay at any point in the AC Wave cycle and then turns off at the next zero-cross event.
That makes the Random-On relay dimmable.
I use SSRez relays in my show. I have to fix one or two channels every year. Not a good rate when there are only 60 SSR Channels in my show.
I have 12 mini-trees with 7 channels each, total of 84 channels. The controllers are homemade using Arduino Due. I have had channels that either don't dim at all or instead of dimming they start to blink. The SSR's are not all of the same build. I think some of them have Renard logos on the PCB. There are inconsistencies in the dimming level between the controllers / SSR builds. I might be able to compensate for this using a dimming curve in Vixen. I figured out this past season that some of my issues correlated to increased air temperatures. I was leaving the Arduino's powered up during the day and some of the channels stopped dimming. I switched to unplugging the Arduinio's after the show and turning them on just before show time and they started dimming again. This makes me think my issue is not with the SSR's but that the Arduino is slowing down due to heat. I was eyeing these phidget SSR's just to potentially get something more reliable with consistent dimming.
As you said, it does sound like the issue is the controller and not the current ssr's you have. Keep in mind, if you went the route of the phidget, you'd still need a controller to control it.
If it were me, I'd try and narrow down exactly where the issue is the control (I'm cheap and the phidget isn't).
I think I'd start by looking at the dimming inconsistencies that you are talking about. I'd locate 2 ssrs that are inconsistent from one another and note how they are inconsistent. Then swap the controllers and see if the inconsistency stays the same or changes. This should point you to ssr or controller.
On 2nd thought, since you said leaving them on can lead to issues that get resolved by rebooting, I'd suspect a possible code issue that during off times its somehow getting into an unknown state. For example, if some interference gets on the line and creates ghost data.
If you're interested in going this route, post more data on how the controller is set up and I'm sure you'll find you'll get more help troubleshooting it then you'll know what to do with.
If they're inconsistent, you might check the leakage current when it's supposed to be "off." Most TRIACS leak something, and if memory serves me right, the higher the trigger voltage, the more leakage you can expect.
Are you using PWM output? The use of just a pulse output leads to latching issues that get worse as you approach 70% on and under 30% on.
