ErnieHorning wrote:
This sounds like my experience with ChatGPG. I felt that I was just dictating what I could have just done myself. It seemed like I could have gotten a similar experience if I told somebody, with no experience, what to do as I stood behind them.Okay, so AI physically manipulated the sequence but it still can't write it.
All the coding I do at work is agentic now and I've always compared it to working with a really fast but really naive junior programmer. You have to be very specific, and it takes everything you say literally.
If you say "here's 3 examples of how to do it" it will take those 3 examples and use them, and only them. It doesn't understand the nuance that these are examples and not the ridgid spec.
Okay, not pulling punches and being honest. Perhaps overly bluntly, so forgive me, Tim!
It's interesting. And a bit of a sensory overload insofar as every prop is used almost all the time. There's no black space. There's no time that the viewer gets a break, even though the beginning of the song is quieter. Some of the effects are softer at the beginning and of course, as the guitars and wildness enter the scene, the effects become more agitated.... rightfully so. But because the viewer has essentially seen all the props already, there's nothing new other than the craziness of a rock band adaptation. At the end, I felt tired. What are you trying to convey to the viewer? What do you want the viewer to feel at the end of it?
dirknerkle wrote:
It's interesting. And a bit of a sensory overload insofar as every prop is used almost all the time. There's no black space.
I really liked it the first time but I watched it a second time after reading this and I see what you mean. But I still like it. :unsure:
I've always run our display as "a regular Christmas display that just happens to blink some of the props to music". I've never been a huge fan of having a mostly dark display that reveals props one by one throughout the show. I mean I enjoy other displays that do that, but that's not the way I've ever run ours.
Indeed we have a good amount of static display elements that are always on and mixed into this that isn't shown on the preview at all.
I think it all stems back to when I was a little kid, and you'd be riding in the car and turn the corner then THERE IT IS, a magnificent house with a bazillion lights. All static back then of course. I think that's why I've always tended to sequence "mostly on"... I sometimes go to animated displays and think "this is cool, but I wish they gave us more lights on" lol.
As for not pulling punches... let me have it. I want to hear what people think. Over the years I've been told that "hybrid displays suck" and You can't mix pixels and regular LEDs (much less incans), etc. Sometimes it makes me change my mind as to what I do, sometimes I decide I like my display the way it is lol.
This song is a little strange, and it took me awhile to warm up to it. Cathy didn't like it at first and she's warmed up to it now too. When I first did animation back in 2003, we had mostly rock songs. Over the years, I've kind of watered things down, with some great slow songs. This song grew on me because it starts out as a standard slow Christmas song but then surprises you when it kicks into gear.
I guess at the end of this one, I'd like people to think "Wow, what did I just see? That was cool!"
Anyway, thanks for the feedback. Keep it coming. I'm considering it all.
Since you asked. I have both fixed LEDs and lots of pixels. To be honest, I felt the AI sequence was lacking life. It felt very mechanical and formulaic.
