Your Recommendation...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Your Recommendations for Mega Tree - Pixel Strings or Pixel Strips?

22 Posts
13 Users
0 Reactions
9,715 Views
rstehle
Posts: 4348
Topic starter
(@rstehle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 19 years ago
[#23906]

I am really wanting to add a Pixel Mega Tree for this year, in addition to my current display (more or less). A lot of you had beautiful Pixel Trees this year and I'm sure have learned a lot about them, and I would like to pick your brains.
I'm thinking of an 180 degree tree, in the neighborhood of 16-18' tall. I am starting to get a grasp of the equipment needed, and have already ordered a couple of e682 kits and an e1.31 Bridge. I still need to order Pixels and am looking for your recommendations. I have seen where some folks use Pixel Strings, some use Pixel Modules, and some use Strips. I have also seen recommends for using higher (12) bit Pixels. I plan on implementing some scrolling text (if I can ever learn the software) so I'm thinking that more is better............ So, couple of questions: (keeping price somewhat reasonable)

What is your recommendation for the best Pixel style to use? Strip, String or Module.

What is your recommendation for the best actual Pixel to use? (i.e. 2801, 2811, 3001, etc.)

Would it be wise to pull the trigger now, or wait to see what happens with new products and pricing?

Thanks for your help!
Randy


21 Replies
LightUpMA
Posts: 208
(@lightupma)
Estimable Member
Joined: 15 years ago

Randy,

2012 was my first year, and ended up jumping in on a pixel tree ... I just love new technology and couldn't wait. I had some difficulties getting the strings to face forward and line up properly. In the end, I bought 2811's from Ray ... 42 pixels x 16 strips to maximize my e681 controller. I used a 180 degree tree, and in the end, I ended up mounting strings to pvc 1/2" grey poles 15' long using strong 3m clear tape. They held great, even in my harsh New England weather. And, no one around here has seen anything like it....so it was a huge success. However, because of the conical shape, I couldn't line up to use words or pics.

I say if you're going to buy, do it by the summer. I don't think prices are going to fluctuate that much. Truthfully, you want to save money on shipping, so choosing a slow shipper necessitates that you don't wait until after July. I think the prices I paid last June are darn close to what they are now. I think the secret is not as much in the pixel type, but in the mounting, and application. How well you construct your design will be the winning feature I think.

Good Luck...I can't wait to see the videos!

-Wayne


Reply
Posts: 4092
(@skunberg)
Famed Member
Joined: 18 years ago

If your interested in text, try out nutcracker and you'll see that pixels close to a square grid work best for text. So think wider top, skinny bottom, side spacing close to pixel spacing. I think your on the right track and will be very happy with the results.

Brian


Reply
LightUpMA
Posts: 208
(@lightupma)
Estimable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Skunberg wrote:If your interested in text, try out nutcracker and you'll see that pixels close to a square grid work best for text. So think wider top, skinny bottom, side spacing close to pixel spacing. I think your on the right track and will be very happy with the results.

Brian

Funny you mention a square grid. I was giving serious thought to a more traditional tree next year and then a square matrix for my pixels. I want to be able to do more with text and pictures this year.

*** how far apart should pixels be in a matrix? I was thinking about coroplast mounting so the pixels are secure, protecte and even.


Reply
Posts: 210
(@danhouston)
Reputable Member
Joined: 15 years ago

I had a similar question about scrolling text with pixels rather than strips and on a mega tree. Here's that thread over at DLA:
http://diylightanimation.com/index.php?topic=11056.0

He references back to the ColorMotion tree by Walter Monkhouse (lots of good information on how he got things to line up and point outward.


Reply
Posts: 8517
(@angus40)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 15 years ago

It is my experience and opinion that when selecting your pixels to purchase that your choice in type> Ic and construction >string or strip is crucial to the type of effects you can achieve .

Going with cheap elements definitely does not mean more bang for the buck . cheap = less bang .

Just my opinion.

Richard


Reply
Xenia
Posts: 1358
(@xenia)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago

Randy,

I am going through the same decision matrix as you are. I thought I had made some decisions. I was looking to do a 32 string half Mega Tree about 18" tall which would go in the center of my tri-level under the Bethlehem star utilizing two E682's. Well the last couple of days I have finally spent some time learning the basics of Nutcracker. First I decided that I liked the look of 24 strings instead of 32 in a half tree. The real problem started when I realized that you cannot do a real spiral or double helix utilizing the half mega tree.

The next issue is design. One thought I had was to use 1" coroplast strips in 8' lenghts with the pixels punched through. I would use 1/16 vinyl aircraft cable in an up/down run about 3/4" apart to secure the coroplast. This way the string could at least be folded in 8 foot lengths for storage. I will probably decide on pixels around May in order to let a couple of the new products to become available for evaluation.

I would love to see more people share how they do their pixel tree and other element setups. Since this is a new area I am sure there will be some innovation on various setups. Even when ideas don't work. I think we can all learn from them.

Good Luck!


Reply
rstehle
Posts: 4348
Topic starter
(@rstehle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Xenia wrote:Randy,

I am going through the same decision matrix as you are. I thought I had made some decisions. I was looking to do a 32 string half Mega Tree about 18" tall which would go in the center of my tri-level under the Bethlehem star utilizing two E682's. Well the last couple of days I have finally spent some time learning the basics of Nutcracker. First I decided that I liked the look of 24 strings instead of 32 in a half tree. The real problem started when I realized that you cannot do a real spiral or double helix utilizing the half mega tree.

The next issue is design. One thought I had was to use 1" coroplast strips in 8' lenghts with the pixels punched through. I would use 1/16 vinyl aircraft cable in an up/down run about 3/4" apart to secure the coroplast. This way the string could at least be folded in 8 foot lengths for storage. I will probably decide on pixels around May in order to let a couple of the new products to become available for evaluation.

I would love to see more people share how they do their pixel tree and other element setups. Since this is a new area I am sure there will be some innovation on various setups. Even when ideas don't work. I think we can all learn from them.

Good Luck!

Randy, thanks for your input! This tree will be an addition for me, so I am not real concerned about being able to do the traditional spiral effects. I would like to do some animations and text (assuming I can learn Nutcracker........:wacko:) and some of the other very cool things I have seen folks do.
But like you said, I hope that lots of folks will volunteer their input on what they recommend based on their experiences - either bad or good.
Thanks,
Randy


Reply
Lionking_Tx
Posts: 780
(@lionking-tx)
Prominent Member
Joined: 15 years ago

I think there is no "one size fits all" answer.
I decided on regular Pixels for my tree, but spend hours figuring out how to mount them so they point out and don't twist the string.
Since I used a regular mason line to zip tie the pixels to I also had a problem with the spacing.
A string unfortunately stretches, so I spent more hours to adjust the spacing again.
After all I was pretty satisfied with the results, however I think next year I will try cables (a bit more expensive).

Text/pictures were a catch 22 for me - personally I prefer the "string type" trees where the LED's move freely with the wind however, text did not work like planned - I will try increasing the pixel density next year to improve text and pictures.

The 180 degree compared to 360 degree is also personal/finacial preference. I like to do full circle effects, so I always had a 360 tree - however, for most of the new RGB effects a 180 is more than sufficient.


Reply
Mudsculpter
Posts: 1218
Admin
(@mudsculpter)
Member
Joined: 19 years ago

concerning the use of wire rope

I have been using the same 1/16" galvanized aircraft cable for about 4 years now. Dont waste money on the vinyl coated stuff unless you just dont like to get stabbed in the finger when handling the cable near the cable end. Get the 1/16" galv 7x7 or the 1/16" stainless steel 7x7 if you really want weatherproof properties. The galvanized variety has lasted a pretty good while though. I also use the thimbles to make sure I dont pinch the cable and weaken it. A 500 ft spool will run about $10 shipped on ebay and search for 1/16" thimbles and crimp sleeves while you're there. A crimping tool is also needed.


Reply
Page 1 / 3
Share: