komby wrote:Just because I have a thing against dead horses, Im curious about the larger packet format. Any idea on the change in throughput we could expect by going to the larger format? We are still taking about using the same data rates IE 250kbps vs 1MBPS etc. Do you think we will see more throughput with larger packets? Or just less chance to drop one?Im also curious about FCC and open hardware. You are planning on releasing the hardware on the CC BY-NC-ND 3.0, if it undergoes FCC testing is that covered by the overall design of the product regardless of manufacturer? Or does it only pertain to a "built" version of the board?
For FCC every manufacturer has to be tested, even if a common design. The only way around this that I'm aware of is when a single mfgr is qualified for the board product, and resells to others.
Sparkfun listed a guy in Colorado that I'm going to call tomorrow, Thursday, and get an idea on costs.
A lot has changed since I did my last certification well over 20 years ago. From what I understand I think I can do a self confirm where you have the tests run but you don't send anything in unless the FCC comes knocking. I think you can do this even with intentional radiators. It supposed to help reduce costs for small companies. Well see.
Interesting concept. I know some will perform tests before running the final tests for FCC certification, so you are proposing pre-certification testing.
I suppose that you could perform a technical sale of the PCB, and leave it to the user for FCC certification. In practical terms no one is going to come knocking unless you sell to an entity that requires proof, and then you just can't sell to the entity. I've only had the DoD and Hospitals ask for the certification proof (FCC / ETL).
Out of curiosity I just looked at an instruction packet that came with some GECE lights (imported by Costco) and there is a certification statement present.
Most Devices need testing if they could produce any EMI radiation. Transmitters are the hardest to do and cost the most.
I had a nice talk with a testing lab in Colorado today. He can do all of my pre-testing for $200 an hour. Since I'm not in a rush he can work devices in without charging me the half day minimum. What was really funny was that he used to work at the Lab we used at a company I worked for. There is a good chance we've met.
There are totally new protocols coming that the FCC will use for device testing. For most devices you'll never have to submit anything but you do need to have all of the testing data kept on file that they can view if needed. Transmitters are a totally different story. He always recommends using an FCC certified module which relieves you doing the transmitter certification. Currently there is no certified nRF51822 module but I think we'll see one at some point. I'm even starting to think it might be worth doing one that could be used in many devices. Problem is the they even look at the protocols used as part of the testing. I need to get more information on this.
So back to the testing, the lab suggest having them do quick Pre-testing to make sure that nothing really bad is being emitted. It's highly unlikely if its clean any issues will surface. If the quantity justifies it then run the transmitters through full testing.
For this device since it's so integrated we'll have to figure the best way to handle the radio enable. For my sACN gateway with the FM transmitter I'm going to move the FM transmitter chip and antenna connectors to a plugin card just as I did with the wireless. Since that part is a very easy build I may just supply a PCB but well see.
Long term goal is still full certs but it will come with time.
Thanks, this new information is very nice to know and helpful for non-radiating systems. But the testing companies may not like their drop in business! 8<}
Testing companies still get the work except no filing with the FCC. There is a lot more to it but I didn't want to boor everyone with more details.
timon wrote:Testing companies still get the work except no filing with the FCC. There is a lot more to it but I didn't want to boor everyone with more details.
Your doing to wrong....
First you must get him addicted to blinky flashy.
Second get him involved in your project.
Third let him test it in his spare time.
Already headed down that road. He wanted me to send me links to some of our shows so I'm putting some together for him. I figured once he sees the then I can drop some hints. What I need is some good shows in the general Denver to Bolder area.
timon wrote:Already headed down that road. He wanted me to send me links to some of our shows so I'm putting some together for him. I figured once he sees the then I can drop some hints. What I need is some good shows in the general Denver to Bolder area.
Perfect:)
Not in denver but you can use mine link in sig.
Btw, I found a couple of nRF51 modules that are FCC certified and come with a U.FL connector. Only issue is that they are Bluetooth and were tested that way for the FCC certs. Although they can easily be reprogrammed I think that may void the FCC cert. I'll call them tomorrow to see what they say. The nice thing is that they only cost about $13.
