I'm quite certain this has probably been covered before, but, I couldn't find it so I thought I would ask again.
Thinking about next year and what I will be adding to my display, I realized that I need to add another controller or 2. Currently I run 2 e682's in a centralized station with 4 power supplies and fpp to run everything. Other than wires running everywhere it works fairly good. I say fairly good because for the first time this year, I go to play with power injection and null pixels. All was fine and everything went off without a hitch. As the show is going to grow in 2018 I have to consider the option of wireless.
My question is I hope simple. Is there an actual advantage to wireless? I still have to run power wires to them, either 12volt, or run a 120 volt lead to a power supply mounted close to them. The only real advantage I'm seeing is not having to use null pixels so far. Hopefully I'm missing something and someone can open my eyes to the true advantage of wireless.
Understanding that is a very opinionated subject, I'm hoping to get some real world advantages from members. Why did you choose wireless over wired or vice versa? Thank you all in advance!!
There's pros and cons to both. There is no wireless solution (yet) that's as reliable and troublefree as wired.
Major advantage is less wiring, and less kinds of wire. You're right that you still need to run power, but that's it. No Ethernet, or serial lines, or pixel lines with kludgey extenders or repeaters. because there's much less wire, and just the common power wire, this gives you a lot of freedom of placement and changing from year to year. I distribute only 120V AC power in my yard and put appropriately sized power supplies in each prop.
The other side of the coin is reliability. Nothing is as reliable as a wired signal. Wireless is subject to interference and reception issues. Most of that is out of your control. So if you're not equipped to diagnose and respond to problems, you're going to be doing a lot of cursing.
Keep in mind that with wireless, small test setups usually work perfectly, but as you scale up, the problems start to show up. So don't get a false sense of confidence after doing a successful bench test of one wireless controller in your workshop. Don't get me wrong. You'll have gotten past all the steps to make it work in an ideal scenario, but you won't have experienced any of the problems that come up in real world use.
I guess you could say my show is wireless as i have no data cables in my yard. I have 10 FPP remotes (9 Pi3s and 1 BBB) and all the sequences are on the remotes. The only data that goes over wireless is sync packets from my FPP master which is inside my house. For me it works great. I started with wireless last year just to get into my side yard and did not want to run any cables across the driveway. I have power on that side of the house. 2016 worked great so I expanded in 2017. I get good wifi signal even across the street from my house so maybe I am just lucky with no interference although it would appear that every house around me has a wifi network of its own.
Is there a way to test for interference without setting up the entire display? What about delay? Is there any lag issues using wireless, especially as you get further away from your router?
jnealand wrote:I have 10 FPP remotes (9 Pi3s and 1 BBB) and all the sequences are on the remotes. The only data that goes over wireless is sync packets from my FPP master which is inside my house. For me it works great. I started with wireless last year just to get into my side yard and did not want to run any cables across the driveway.
I think this is a distinction that not everyone seems to understand (or fully elaborate on) when they start talking about "running a show on WiFi." There are two (or more) *entirely* different methods employed here: sending data for the ENTIRE show over wireless, versus just using wireless to send the "sync packets."
When someone new is looking at "going wireless," I think they may not understand this (important) nuance.
