pmscientist - No, my first stab at the setup was to have the elements completely powered by the external power supply (+ & -), and just run a data line. After that didn't work, I used the negative off the controller along with the data line, and tied that into the negative of the power supply, but that didn't work either. I knew the distance was too far to not have anything in between, and the null pixel was the easiest to implement, and it did the trick. I didn't need the external power at all. I've been pretty lucky so far. I've got some long runs for the GECEs and I haven't had to do anything with them. One of the runs is about 50' without anything but the cat5 between the controller and string.
pythan wrote:Actually using RS485 solves several issues for the most part. First off converters are cheap. $15 for a receiver and e6804 and e682 (I assume the J1S stuff also) will output differential already. I don't know about you but my time to mess with null pixels or adding resistor cleanly, is not worth the trouble. I tried it the first time around and never again.. what a pain!Secondly not only distance is an issue. There are also noise implications for bundles of cables. (been there done that). Now granted not everyone has the same issues I did with the Plasma Icicles, but those conditions do exist... So I guess it could be a case by case thing... but I bought a bunch of Pixel Extenders and plan to use them whenever I have any distance or data cable bundles to deal with in regards to pixel stuff.
Ahh, I understand where you're coming from now. Unfortunately, the sandevices controllers output a single ended signal. Some pixel types use two lines for signaling, but those are clock and data lines, not a differential pair. Any differential signal means more hardware on both ends. If the controller was generating a differential signal already, I'd totally agree that it's not worth the hassle to do anything else.
The 681, 682, and PS1 already have series terminating resistors, and include sockets to use with them, which makes this pretty trivial on those board. I can't tell if the 6804 does, though it needs a level shifter anyways. The original 680, which is what I've got, definitely doesn't. Not sure about the J1S stuff, though the renard pixel controller appears to have onboard terminating resistors. In this case, a 681 is in use, so no board or circuit modifications are necessary to get to a resistor of the requisite value. It's just pretty hard to beat the cost and simplicity of swapping a resistor in this case. If you have to add a resistor when the main board doesn't have the provisions for doing so, a single ended board is cheaper and typically deals more channels in the same space than a differential board.
Sure, noise can still be an issue, and that's a place where differential signaling has some distinct advantages. However, even basic twisted pair deals with noise from typical AC lines and noisy low voltage DC well enough that, if you eliminate transmission line effects, you can carry the signal much further before taking the next step. Like I said, this is probably a solution for 10s of feet, not 100m+.
slug wrote:pmscientist - No, my first stab at the setup was to have the elements completely powered by the external power supply (+ & -), and just run a data line. After that didn't work, I used the negative off the controller along with the data line, and tied that into the negative of the power supply, but that didn't work either. I knew the distance was too far to not have anything in between, and the null pixel was the easiest to implement, and it did the trick. I didn't need the external power at all. I've been pretty lucky so far. I've got some long runs for the GECEs and I haven't had to do anything with them. One of the runs is about 50' without anything but the cat5 between the controller and string.
Ok, that's good, thought I might have missed something in there. Glad it's going well.
pmscientist wrote:Ahh, I understand where you're coming from now. Unfortunately, the sandevices controllers output a single ended signal. Some pixel types use two lines for signaling, but those are clock and data lines, not a differential pair. Any differential signal means more hardware on both ends. If the controller was generating a differential signal already, I'd totally agree that it's not worth the hassle to do anything else.The 681, 682, and PS1 already have series terminating resistors, and include sockets to use with them, which makes this pretty trivial on those board. I can't tell if the 6804 does, though it needs a level shifter anyways. The original 680, which is what I've got, definitely doesn't. Not sure about the J1S stuff, though the renard pixel controller appears to have onboard terminating resistors. In this case, a 681 is in use, so no board or circuit modifications are necessary to get to a resistor of the requisite value. It's just pretty hard to beat the cost and simplicity of swapping a resistor in this case. If you have to add a resistor when the main board doesn't have the provisions for doing so, a single ended board is cheaper and typically deals more channels in the same space than a differential board.
Sure, noise can still be an issue, and that's a place where differential signaling has some distinct advantages. However, even basic twisted pair deals with noise from typical AC lines and noisy low voltage DC well enough that, if you eliminate transmission line effects, you can carry the signal much further before taking the next step. Like I said, this is probably a solution for 10s of feet, not 100m+.
Good morning,
Actually the Sans Devices do output differential if you are using WS2811s or WS2812Bs. The unused "clock" signal is the D- in that case, and it works great!
I have not dealt with the series resistor issue but it would make more sense at the input of the receiving device and not the at the transmitter. We of course know that current in a series circuit is the same, but impinging noise along the data cable is or was relevant in my case. Therefore the series resistor being at the controller would not have been completely helpful. Twisted pair might have been helpful.. so I would have thought, but even using Cat 6 cable and null pixels at 8-10' intervals was not a fix. Differential was the only way I was able to fix my noise issues completely.
Again, YMMV.. but for my application.. the Pixel Extenders in conjunction with the differential output of the 6804s made my system work perfectly when everything else failed.
pythan wrote:Good morning,
Actually the Sans Devices do output differential if you are using WS2811s or WS2812Bs. The unused "clock" signal is the D- in that case, and it works great!I have not dealt with the series resistor issue but it would make more sense at the input of the receiving device and not the at the transmitter. We of course know that current in a series circuit is the same, but impinging noise along the data cable is or was relevant in my case. Therefore the series resistor being at the controller would not have been completely helpful. Twisted pair might have been helpful.. so I would have thought, but even using Cat 6 cable and null pixels at 8-10' intervals was not a fix. Differential was the only way I was able to fix my noise issues completely.
Again, YMMV.. but for my application.. the Pixel Extenders in conjunction with the differential output of the 6804s made my system work perfectly when everything else failed.
Unless I'm totally missing something, it's not true that a balanced signal is output for any pixels. It is ONLY true for Renard and DMX. See here: http://doityourselfchristmas.com/forums/showthread.php?26154-SanDevices-E68x-Version-3-Firmware-beta
Besides the missing documentation, the pixels need single ended input. Were a differential signal output for pixels, a converter would be necessary to get back to what the pixels expect. Is there such a converter for sale or recommended by sandevices for use with their controllers?
There are a few methods of terminating a single ended line. The method used by sandevices and many other pixel controllers is typically referred to as serial termination. Terminating at the receiving device may make more sense to you, but that's just not how it works with series termination. You can also terminate in parallel, which has DC and AC forms, and there are variants within there. Getting into the details is a bit off topic, but suffice to say there are benefits and drawbacks to each.
In the case of the 6804, a level shifter is probably needed in addition to impedance matching. The 3.3V signals output from the prop chip are towards the bottom of the range for the TTL logic level 'high' of the expected 5V input signal. Adding much cable between the two can tip that balance relatively easily. Add a 270 ohm resistor in there instead of the correct 100 ohm resistor, and you've got a good chance of problems. Add to that a 5V supply that actually operates at 5.1, and an issue becomes more likely.
There's a good chance you were dealing with a termination resistor issue. However, there's also a good chance it wasn't *just* that. You could easily have had a logic level issue too. The OP was about an E681, which has the level conversion, so I tried to keep my comments related to that.
I don't doubt that a differential pixel extender fixes the problem. OTOH, given that they run ~$15 per end, you're looking at $30 per string to go that way. YMMV, but I'm gunna try a different resistor first.
