Having made the decision to order 5V Pixels earlier this year (either wisely, or unwisely) I am in the process of figuring out the best way to control and power these new toys. My initial thought was a Sandevice E682 as I have read a lot of positive comments about them on the various forums. However, as I get more into the power requirements of 5V pixels, and pixels in general, I have to wonder why power is run through the pixel controllers out to the strings? With the frequent requirement of power injection why does someone not just build a controller that only outputs data, or data/clock and let the users wire the power directly to the power supplies. It would seem to me to simplify the design of the controller, plus make them smaller and less expensive. It would be similar to using a renard board with SSR's.
Are there any pixel controllers using this concept that I am overlooking? Is my thought process flawed?
Right now my brain is about to explode from trying to figure out the options and the best path to take to implement my pixel megatree.
There are such boards. I believe I've seen them down under and a few other places. Your logic is totally fine. A megatree with a E682 saves on wiring. The string to the controller rather than to the controller "and" power. The E682 is a much more mature and developed board and the ones without power are new. 1st generation vs 3rd generation. Options are open. And I like options.
I think the primary reason is that the controller board will always need power. If you have to have power there, why not allow it to also power some lights? You are correct that it would simplify the design a bit to not route that power to a light output, but not by a lot. Nothing stops you from using the E682 exactly as you have prescribed - data only with power injected entirely externally.
You could check out the nDP2, from J1Sys. It runs around $65, controls 4 universes per output. It has 2 outputs. It's about the size of a tic tax container. Definitely worth a look.
A big part of the cost of power on controller is the fuse holders and fuses which you would have to buy separately.

