Ok,I was about to pre-order some stuff and I was reading the power consumption. I was alarmed at what I was looking at and wanted to make sure the website has it correct.
For the 5v bullets...
White (all three colors) per string (50 nodes): 3 amps / 15 Watts
For the 12v bullets:
White (all three colors) per string (50 nodes): 2.268 amps / 27 Watts
Thats not what I expected. The 12v is almost double the power? Huh?
That takes my 24 strand tree from 360w at 5v to 648w at 12v.
That's correct. The 12V bullets simply burn off the extra voltage in heat through the resistors.
The reason it's not more than 2x is because 12V bullets also run the LEDs at a lower current, and thus they give out less light than 5V's.
See here for excellent discussion on the topic:
http://auschristmaslighting.com/forums/index.php?topic=2595.0
I was expecting a slight power increase. But nearly 2X was a shocker!
I wanted to rebuild the tree (24 strand) as 12v. But 600+ watts is not what I had in mind. Frankly I would rather run the power injections and their associated cost than to double the power (and the power bill along with it) with ongoing bills associated with it.
Sigh. I was really wanting to convert everything to 12v.
deonb wrote:That's correct. The 12V bullets simply burn off the extra voltage in heat through the resistors.The reason it's not more than 2x is because 12V bullets also run the LEDs at a lower current, and thus they give out less light than 5V's.
See here for excellent discussion on the topic:
http://auschristmaslighting.com/forums/index.php?topic=2595.0
+1 - - plus:
They both use the same 5V WS2811 and LEDs. You are just burning off voltage to get from 12V to 5V.
12V has it's advantages, but at the cost of efficiency.
deonb wrote: 12V bullets also run the LEDs at a lower current, and thus they give out less light than 5V's.
I have seen that written before, but it does not make much sense. The typical WS2811 control chip is a constant current output device, so the current thru the leds should be the same. In theory the leds should see 18.5ma for each color.
jklingert wrote:I have seen that written before, but it does not make much sense. The typical WS2811 control chip is a constant current output device, so the current thru the leds should be the same. In theory the leds should see 18.5ma for each color.
I assume that's being done with a current limiting resistor in front of the LED, but not really sure either.
I'm glad you found it. Most people don't get it. You will be glad to power inject.
Is there any reason to run the injection to the top of the tree? The guy that built this year's tree did so. And after I rebuilt it (with correct wiring) I followed suit. I am thinking all connections should be at the bottom, not top. It is and the new one will be zigzag 100px, 50 up and 50 down. Any reason I can't feed power to the bottom of the 50 px coming back down? Obviously I know the data line has to carry over at the top, but I want to eliminate the power cables running up. I mean do I have to inject where the data carries over? I, for the life of me, can't think of a reason I must feed power to top but I am still new at this.
No you can inject either side. Since this is a tree it may also be just easier to connect each strand to its own controller output rather than running the data wires across.
A controller isn't much more compared to a separate properly fused power distribution system.
The ECG-P12 only has 12 outputs and 12 universes max. Tree is 24 strands of 50, plus a 35 node star at top.
I pre-ordered two F16v2s and one TTL expander so one will have 32 outputs so I could do each strand individually. I don't know if I am going to replace the P12 or leave it to control just the tree and use the F16s for the rest of the display. Honestly, the P12 served quite well for the tree this year. I just think its kinda a waste of $250 to dedicate 25 channels (24 plus star at top), the majority of a F16 plus its expander just so I don't have to run 12 power cables.
