software based osci...
 
Notifications
Clear all

software based oscilloscope

12 Posts
5 Users
0 Reactions
5,390 Views
Posts: 93
Topic starter
(@petefats)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
[#3086]

i'd like to have a scope for my lab. i've never used one before in my life, but i can already see how useful one could be.

any suggestions on required reading or things i should be looking for? what type of resolution can i expect/require/pay for. how spec'd out does the computer have to be (it'd be going on an older p4 3g).


11 Replies
Posts: 39
(@joyangel)
Eminent Member
Joined: 19 years ago

Why bother with a software/pc based oscilloscope when you can get a real analog one off ebay for less then a $100. I would recommend a 20Mhz dual trace oscilloscope sence this will be your first one.


Reply
Macrosill
Posts: 9739
(@macrosill)
Member
Joined: 20 years ago

petefats,
I was in the same boat as you are now about 2 months ago. I never used an o'scope for anything other than to look at a low voltage sinewave and measure the dc voltage of a battery. I wanted to get a software based o'scope for 2 reasons. 1. It looked cooler than an old analog unit. 2. It seemed cheaper than a new analog unit. In doing some research and talking to some here and in the chat I started looking more at the spec of an o'scope than its appearance. I did not know previously they came with different specs, I thought a scope was a scope. I could not have been more wrong. To make a long story shorter, I just received a 60mhz 2 channel scope from a member here for 90.00 shipped. I think I got a great deal. Its used and old but still functions and should be more than sufficient for my inexperienced use.


Reply
mrpackethead
Posts: 2289
(@mrpackethead)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
joyangel wrote:Why bother with a software/pc based oscilloscope when you can get a real analog one off ebay for less then a $100

As someone who now has both an old scope, and a usb scope.. heres why i'd bother.

1. Easy to move about. - Typically a usb connected scope is pretty small. you can stick it in your laptop bag.

2. Far better display possible on a large lcd monitor, in colour..

3. Massive signal storage possible ( restricted by how big your storage pool is ).. This can be very very useful.. You can use it as a data-logger..

4. Waveforms 'captured' can easily be shared and exported to others and different applications. for example; " i saw this trace at test point 3, when i started it up, is that normal? "

5. Functionality can be upgraded through software..

6. You get a bunch of different instruments in a single box. A oscilliscope, a spectrum analyzer, meter and data logger.. Some even include a signal generator..

7. Instant ( nearly ) recall of settings for a various job..

8. On screen measurement with mouse..

9. Ability to set up complex triggering as needed, and view pre-trigger..

10. self calibration..

Theres some gotchas with Digital Scopes however..

1. they are typically ( mhz for mhz ) more expensive.
2. they are probably more complex to operate ( arguable though )

My 10c worth.


Reply
Posts: 93
Topic starter
(@petefats)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago

thanks for the feedback. i'm torn right now. 3/4 of me wants to buy something old, so i continue to learn, and half of me wonders if there is a shortcut.


Reply
mrpackethead
Posts: 2289
(@mrpackethead)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago

petefats,

what are you looking to do with it? What sort of things do you work on or intend to work on? For ~ US$150 you can get a pretty good entry level USB Scope.

Ebay item number 280220822203

Mines been working well for everything i do. ( i bought a 2250 model which is a bit faster ).


Reply
Posts: 93
Topic starter
(@petefats)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
what are you looking to do with it? What sort of things do you work on or intend to work on?

i'm interested in the data leaving the computer to my various devices, as well as the data that goes out of them. at this point, i have a few different devices to source dmx, as well as an ledtriks and a 595. a software based scope looks to me to be the wireshark/tcpdump of the electronics world.

For ~ US$150 you can get a pretty good entry level USB Scope.

Ebay item number 280220822203

Mines been working well for everything i do. ( i bought a 2250 model which is a bit faster ).

how fast is considered fast? that item says it can do realtime sampling at '100MS/s'. is that 1 million samples per second? also, i see this one has two inputs. is there any benefit in going to 4 or 8 input ones?


Reply
WWNF911
Posts: 1722
(@wwnf911)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
petefats wrote:how fast is considered fast?

For what were doing here, I can't imagine you'd need anything faster than 100 MHZ.

Additionally, I've used Wireshark before. Not as a scope but as a network sniffer when trouble shooting problems on a network. How would this be used as a scope of any kind?


Reply
mrpackethead
Posts: 2289
(@mrpackethead)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago

Fast these days is in the order if GS/s. Just like very fast cars, be prepared to pay very large sums of money. 🙂 However, i have only ever once needed a scope that does that kind of speed, and that was'tn for a diyc project!

Something to be aware of is the difference between Sampling rate and useful bandwidth.
A digital scope that is sampling at say 100M/s will have a useful theoritical bandwidth no more than half the sample rate, ( ie 50Mhz ). ( Nyquist Theorm - If a function f(t) contains no frequencies higher than W cps, it is completely determined by giving its ordinates at a series of points spaced 1/(2W) seconds apart. ). Google that if you want to learn some more!!

The theory is that you have a bandwidth thats half the sample rate, practically, however depending on your signal etc, you more realistically have a useful bandwidth of 1/3 to 1/4. Ie a 100MS/s scope is good for about 25Mhz. I can see a 100Mhz "square wave" on my 250MS/s scope, but its starting to look much more like a sine wave function.. ( a square wave is a series of sine waves summed together.. i can only see the fundemental frequency in this example, hence why it looks like a sine wave )..

In terms of watching data thats coming and going from your pc to the various devices, you'll be more than looked after with a 100MS/s scope. The data rate on DMX is 250kb/s, you'll easily see it, and your signal will look very square.. You'll even be able to look at signal on 10Mb/s-1 ethernet if you want, or full speed USB. If you can afford it, buy the faster ones, they will give you a better result.

As far as getting more channels, you can simply stack more devices up on your usb ports.. the software will just add more channels in.


Reply
Posts: 93
Topic starter
(@petefats)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago

thanks again for the continued replies. few more questions....

how's the software side of these things? am i at the mercy of whoever designed the hardware? or is there a standard of sorts...


Reply
Page 1 / 2
Share: