Has anyone thought about doing a one-channel dimming controller? It would be in-line with the power-cord for each lamp. It would consist of a triac, MOC3023, PIC12F629 (or similar), five diodes and a few resistors and caps. I'm thinking that it would only need two input wires for both communications and wires, basically the outputs of a L293 bridge driver. You're probably not going to get DMX speeds out of this thing (19200 is probably the max baud rate), but it might be nice for a smaller setup...and that PIC could actually be good for up to 4 outputs.
--
Phil
its called X10 🙂
but yeh it would be a good idea so long as it ended up comparable to the multi output boards
Wombat
Man and I'm already using a Xmus Renard to dim the lights and play the music for those romantic evenings with the wife at a keystrokes notice. :p
What uses did you have in mind for it or what prompted it? Out of curiosity of course.
Perhaps going to one channel is taking things to an extreme, but I'm looking for alternatives to the high channel-count setups that people seem to be aiming at. Mostly I'm just trying to get some thoughtful discussion of alternatives at the current time (but not a discussion of DMX versus other schemes).
Here are the issues that I'm looking at with the current designs:
Renard64, Lynx FreeStyle, Grinch and Coop-595/64: huge numbers of Cat5 cables running from the controller all over the place. This assumes that the controller is mounted indoors and the SSRs outdoors. This means that there is a huge wad of cables that have to leave the house/garage somehow, and end of laying all over the yard. Ugly, and probably hard to get all of th lengths right. If the SSRs are indoors, then there are power cables running over the place, even messier. And power issues for everything except Lynx Freestyle seem to makes putting the controller outdoors unattractive (although I'm sure that people are doing this).
Renard16, Renard24 and Lynx - now you have the issue of running power cables all over the place, unless you mount the board outside near a concentration of lights. In the case of the Renard16 you need to get power to the board, which may be a problem if there is some distance involved and you don't want a separate power supply outdoors. The Renard24 and Lynx would probably be the best (i.e. simplest wiring) if they are installed outdoors (although the fan might be an issue with Lynx) and the lights are nearby.
The setup that appeals the most to me would have three or four channel controllers with integrated SSRs. The reason for selecting three or four channels is that there will usually be three or four lights in close proximity (multiple colors, so a one-channel controller is too small), and I'm not a big fan of mega-trees (so no need for 64 or 128-channel controllers). Each controller would have three or four 2-wire outlets, so the LED or mini-light strings would just plug into it. The controller itself would probably be potted (or at least conformal coated), so that I didn't have to worry about moisture (or lizards, snails or slugs). The serial i/o (and power, if not derived from the power line) would be two screw terminals on the outside of the box (or maybe go ghetto with binding posts). One objective here is make the setup economically modular, robust, and easy to setup, troubleshoot and fix in the field.
--
Phil
Do you mean something like a 4 channel Renard with onboard ssr's?
Or did I understand you to mean losing the separate i/o cable (cat5) and use an i/o signal over the power line, a la X10?
Daisy chainable?
Something like a 4-channel Renard with onboard SSRs with addressing. Cable could be something as cheap as doorbell wiring or 2-wire phone cable. PLC or wireless would be nice, of course, but probably out of the price or performance range.
--
Phil
That might be useful especially dmx so it is addressable.
Would this really make a noticeable difference in the amount of wires though?
Unless I am picturing this wrong, there would be a power wire going to each board, as well as a 2-wire control cable. The power wires would have to come from "inside" the house, just as with other solutions.
However, the 2-wire control cable could be daisy-channed, correct? If so, I see how this would be slightly less wire, but not any "cleaner" with a couple of cable routing tricks (i.e. cable tie several control cables together, run short distances of control wire with power wire, etc.).
Cat 5 is so cheap nowadays, and although I don't know what binding posts would cost, I don't think there would be much cost difference.
Just thinking out loud on the need compared to current solutions =)
What do you mean when you say 'power' cable? Are you talking about 110VAC, or the DC power for the controller? In the first case it would come from outdoor GFI outlets, and in the second case the power would come over the same two wires as the data signals.
At this moment I want to keep this discussion general, and not get too bogged down in details.
--
Phil
I like the idea, not because of cost, but because a chained set-up would reduce the number of runs and help with trouble shooting. I wont get into details becuase they are beyond me. From the displays I've seen (outside of candy canes) most people are using 3 to 4 channels (colors) for most display items.

