Jumping on the pixel bandwagon for next year. Trying to decide what hardware is best. What are the main differences between Falcon pixel controller and E682? Who prefers what? Price looks to be about the same between them. Falcon can run more strings.
JLStout wrote:Jumping on the pixel bandwagon for next year. Trying to decide what hardware is best. What are the main differences between Falcon pixel controller and E682? Who prefers what? Price looks to be about the same between them. Falcon can run more strings.
WAY more strings, way more pixels. I have a 682, didn't get a chance to put it out, not entirely sure I will ever put it out. Just pre-ordered two F16v2 boards.
682 is a nice board but its limited in the number of universes. Not a bad board, or I wouldn't have bought one. I found the 1-4 connector arrangement thing quite confusing at first. F16 is pretty straight forward.
For the money the F16 is far more capable. But the 682 is available as a kit so you can save a lot of money if you assemble it yourself. There is no kit for F16.
I guess it depends on whether you will push the limit on the strings/pixels or not. The F16 can (with an expansion board) go up to 32 outputs. Do you need that? Will you need it next year? There is also a differential output expansion board for the F16 coming soon. Do you need to run more than 10-20' of cable between the controller and the pixels? If the answer to ANY of those questions is yes, then F16 is your board.
the 682 like all ready stated is a good tested board but the 4 ports together makes setting up a little harder where the falcon and some other new boards don't have that limitation the new boards can do more channels and the ease of setup makes me want one
I really don't think there is a vs required they both control pixels , have great support and lead to smiles on may faces .
Cheers
I have used E682s for three years now and am very happy with them. The F16V2 is probably more "capable" as far as number of pixels it can drive and my (really basic) understanding is that it doesn't require consistency between outputs. SanDevices recommends that you keep all four outputs of each cluster the same, which limits flexibility a bit. For an example, I drove a megatree and some pixel based arches--the megatree strips were longer than the arches---so I had to set the arches on specific outputs so I could have that one cluster consistent--going to the arches. So I had a couple of unused outputs. But the flexibility thing really hasn't been a big impact on me so far. While I wouldn't recommend pushing "distance" too much, I have been able to successfully drive my pixels as far as 30 feet, which is pretty good. The E682 is a solid performer. I am (at best) a beginner at putting together PCBs and I was able to put this one together--was pretty straightforward.
My two cents on Falcon equipment--if you decide to go with the F16V2, I think it is probably best to go with all Falcon equipment (FPD, F16V2, etc)--then you can do most of your learning on ONE forum--FalconChristmas. Just my opinion there....
I agree with Angus40--whatever you use, the folks who see what you have done will LOVE it!!
Falcon has a solid presence on this board so no need to go anywhere but here for support.
e682 is proven, solid board, $180 assembled, $110 as a kit. 12 universes
falcon16v2, new within last year. hundreds of people are using them, i have three. $200 assembled, 64 universes. It can receive 5 times more data than an e682, but will you use all of that? What if you just want 12 strings of 100? both would fulfill that
besides the larger amount of data (2040 nodes for e682, 10880 nodes for falcon), i like the oled display on the falcon and the flexibility of having any kind of string.
pick the one you are comfortable with, they both drive lights
You can't go wrong with either. But the logistics of power distribution and pixel density will generally be a larger factor than the board functionality.
If you need a whole bunch of pixels in the same place (megatree or matrix), larger boards with more channels are typically better.
If however, you need pixels in a bunch of different places, then smaller boards may be simpler. Also consider the E6804, as well as the E1.31 bridge and pixel extender. There's even smaller boards, but probably not the best to be TOO distributed your first year.
What you typically don't want to do is one centrally located board with a whole bunch of 50' runs to each of your prop locations.
Of course, with Dave's new differential line board, you should consider the F16V2 & new daughterboard as 2 locations.
I've used the E682 for the last few years and I agree,it's a good board.
I'm going to try the F16V2 this year and it it works out,I'll sell the E682.
F16V2 appears to be a little simpler with the setup.
DanJ wrote:I have used E682s for three years now and am very happy with them. The F16V2 is probably more "capable" as far as number of pixels it can drive and my (really basic) understanding is that it doesn't require consistency between outputs. SanDevices recommends that you keep all four outputs of each cluster the same, which limits flexibility a bit. For an example, I drove a megatree and some pixel based arches--the megatree strips were longer than the arches---so I had to set the arches on specific outputs so I could have that one cluster consistent--going to the arches. So I had a couple of unused outputs. But the flexibility thing really hasn't been a big impact on me so far. While I wouldn't recommend pushing "distance" too much, I have been able to successfully drive my pixels as far as 30 feet, which is pretty good. The E682 is a solid performer. I am (at best) a beginner at putting together PCBs and I was able to put this one together--was pretty straightforward.My two cents on Falcon equipment--if you decide to go with the F16V2, I think it is probably best to go with all Falcon equipment (FPD, F16V2, etc)--then you can do most of your learning on ONE forum--FalconChristmas. Just my opinion there....
I agree with Angus40--whatever you use, the folks who see what you have done will LOVE it!!
You do not need to use all falcon equipment. The F16v2 can be used with many different controllers and equipment. It is an e131 controller. The Fpd and f16 v1 for example are pixelnet equipment and are totally a different animals compared to the F16v2.. Falcoln christmas is the site that developed the Falcon Pi show player ( fpp) as well so that would be another good reason to hang around on their site.

