OK....I'm up to my elbows in 4.18...... Maybe I've overloaded the processor in my mind.....but I'm struggling with how to combine layers...
On the left, under Layer/Timing you have what appears to be the old "Layering" button where you can do the combinations of the 2 layers. Then on the right under Timing you can add "Display Elements" ....Then under that you can add Layers.
I assume that's to accommodate the old 2 layers we used to have in 3.x?
I further assume that to combine effects I need to add each effect to it's own layer.
So if that's the case how do you apply the Layering choices (the reveals and masks and such)?
Knowing my logic when it comes to software I'm sure I'm going about this in reverse or from the side.....and that I am missing the patiently obvious yet again.
Can someone post a short how to so that I can understand how to begin approaching this? Right now I don't know what I don't know and suspect I'm making some false assumptions.....
Thanks.
SC
The blend mode in the layering button always defines how the current layer will blend with all layers below it. We combine from the bottom up. You would probably be safe just setting everything to "1 Reveals 2". That way all effects will show whats below them.
CopperCreekLights wrote:The blend mode in the layering button always defines how the current layer will blend with all layers below it. We combine from the bottom up. You would probably be safe just setting everything to "1 Reveals 2". That way all effects will show whats below them.
I guess I'm even more confused..... Doesn't that chop out a huge group of combinations? I mean the 1 I was working on I pulled in all the settings from 3.6.15 and it was a "2 Reveals 1"....nice effect that is totally different looking (and ugly as sin) if set to "1 Reveals 2"....
Was I at least correct in setting layer 1.....dropping it onto a layer....then creating layer 2 and dropping it onto a second layer?
OR do i create each in "1 Reveals 2" instead of the separate layer 1 and layer 2 approach...?
Just drop the effect in the layer and then adjust it. And a pro tip. 2 Reveals 1 = 1 Reveals 2 if you reverse the layer order so it all depends on which one you put on top. If you have lots of 2 Reveals 1 that's fine but I don't like to think in that way. I like things to combine from the bottom up like in Photoshop. You aren't limited to 2 layers anymore either.
Not sure I know what you mean by the last question. 1 Reveals 2 just means the effect on top will let the effect on bottom show through. 2 Reveals 1 makes it look like you dropped the effects down in the reverse order.
CopperCreekLights wrote:Just drop the effect in the layer and then adjust it. And a pro tip. 2 Reveals 1 = 1 Reveals 2 if you reverse the layer order so it all depends on which one you put on top. If you have lots of 2 Reveals 1 that's fine but I don't like to think in that way. I like things to combine from the bottom up like in Photoshop. You aren't limited to 2 layers anymore either.Not sure I know what you mean by the last question. 1 Reveals 2 just means the effect on top will let the effect on bottom show through. 2 Reveals 1 makes it look like you dropped the effects down in the reverse order.
Well....I created 2 layers on the right under timing. Then I created 1 effect and set the "Layer/Timing" on the left to "2 reveals 1"...hit update and dragged it onto the top layer on the right. I then created a second effect and AGAIN set the "Layer/Timing" on the left to "2 reveals 1"...hit update and dragged it onto the bottom layer on the right...... So basically I created 2 layers but I THINK I set them both to "2 reveals 1."
My problem is.....I don't know if that's what I'm supposed to do....I don't understand how the control/manipulation of the layers work now. In 3.6.15 you had 2 very separate effects.....in different locations with no chance of confusing which was which....Under that compartmentalization approach I can understand when you say "2 reveals 1"...as each layer has it's own identity and is controlled by a button dedicated solely to mixing the 2 layers. I could see the 2 layers on the right.....any combinations were done on the left.
Now in 4.18 I'm confused about what controls what. It is unclear what controls the individual layers and what controls the mixing.....It appears that the 1 button in the "Layer/Timing" box controls all layers AND the mixing.....and I can't figure out how that works....How do I know when the button is active for a layer versus when it's active for a mixing?
I'm not doing a very good job of explaining this because, unfortunately, I don't know enough about how it should function to explain where I'm going wrong... I have probably taken a wrong path somewhere along the way and completely strayed away from the logic in place.
But if I go back to the Photoshop comparison.....their approach almost always makes me feel like I'm trying to tie my shoe while looking in a mirror....everything seems reversed....and I struggle. In this case maybe I'm stuck in the way 3.6.15 worked and can't see the logic of the new approach.
Thanks for letting me vent....
SC
The button never applies to a layer. It only applies to the currently selected effect. It doesn't matter what you set the effect to that is on the bottom-most layer because there are no effects below it to blend with. Just put a pinwheel effect on top of a bars effect and change the pinwheel effects blend mode around and watch what happens.
1 Reveals 2 means any black pixels in the effect on top will let the effect on bottom show through. 2 Reveals 1 does the opposite....you will primarily see the effect on the bottom with the effect on top showing through. If I had my vote I'd delete 2 Reveals 1 because if you want the effect on the bottom to be primary then put it on top.
You know 90% of the sequences we get from users don't even have any effects blended. You're struggling with a lot of other basics so why get wrapped up in something more complex that you really don't even need to do a nice show.
CopperCreekLights wrote:You know 90% of the sequences we get from users don't even have any effects blended. You're struggling with a lot of other basics so why get wrapped up in something more complex that you really don't even need to do a nice show.
Well, I was just trying to duplicate some of the effects that the random effects feature in 3.x came up with. I got hooked on the random effects that NC came up with....truly amazing stuff (most of which is blended) that go far beyond what my imagination could ever come up with and so a lot of what was in my show last year is blended because I like neopolitan better than vanilla! 😉
With the random effects option/generator I didn't have to worry about about all the technical theory....I could just look at the effect and within about 5 seconds decide if I liked the look or not. Now, it appears, I actually need to understand how some of those effects are made in order to continue making my preferred 'neopolitan' effects....
I really wasn't trying to sound critical....I was just trying to understand and be able to remain functionally literate with the software. I am one of the 10 percenters who gravitate toward the exotic blended effects. Back before the random feature came into being I did generic effects....vanilla color washes etc. Once I saw what the effects generation feature could accomplish I literally went back and allowed NC to generate almost all of my effects.... I just kept hitting 'Create random effects' until it came up with something that looked cool.....almost always blended BTW. So when you ask "why get wrapped up in something more complex"...that's the reason.
As you point out I've been "struggling with a lot of other basics" and thought I had fought through most of those with your assistance (greatly appreciated BTW)...then I ran into something that seemed I should already know and I couldn't figure it out.....I felt dumb as a bag of rocks....embarrassed to even ask and that turned into frustration which probably came out in my flailing attempt to understand in the post above. I apologize if it came across badly....it was just frustration with myself.
It took me the better part of a year to master HLS (at least the parts I use).....I got frustrated learning that too but I have a flaw in my character....I NEVER give up....and I will just keep trying until it finally sinks in.....so persistence makes up for my dumb as a bag of rocks appearance....and when I jump into a project I tend to jump with both feet and ask questions later....That might be a flawed approach on a beta project.....but I got so excited with 4.x that I couldn't restrain my enthusiasm.
Thanks for all your help....I wouldn't be this far along without a lot of helpful pointers from you guys....
SC
CopperCreekLights wrote:The button never applies to a layer. It only applies to the currently selected effect. It doesn't matter what you set the effect to that is on the bottom-most layer because there are no effects below it to blend with. Just put a pinwheel effect on top of a bars effect and change the pinwheel effects blend mode around and watch what happens.1 Reveals 2 means any black pixels in the effect on top will let the effect on bottom show through. 2 Reveals 1 does the opposite....you will primarily see the effect on the bottom with the effect on top showing through. If I had my vote I'd delete 2 Reveals 1 because if you want the effect on the bottom to be primary then put it on top.
Thanks for the clarification.....Now I know what I'm trying to get it to do...It's hard to get some place if you don't know where you're going before the first step is taken.... :rolleyes:
BTW....I have gone back and read your explanation of this several times and I think I FINALLY understand it for the first time....after all these months of using this kind of effect.....Suddenly the light went on.....as it were. 💡
Thanks for the patience.....I'm slow but I really like learning about how this works....it takes me a while but when I get my hands around it I know that my understanding of how it works will assist immeasurably in the future....
Santacarl. Thank you for all the questions. The developers may get frustrated on some but it helps others too, not just you. And beta is a good time for it rather than scrambling after the release.
