Spiral Tree Control...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Spiral Tree Controler

9 Posts
7 Users
0 Reactions
4,144 Views
SetMonkey13
Posts: 85
Topic starter
(@setmonkey13)
Estimable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
[#29588]

I have grand plans on expanding my current display and add a 8-10' tall spiral tree with 16 Red, 16 Green and 16 White LED strings. 16 stands of each colors seems to be a good choice from what I've read. So my question is whats the best way to I control the stands. A ren64xc or 3 renard ss16. Cost wise they seem about the same if a do a group buy for the ss16's. What are everyone's thoughts? Is there anything else I should consider? Thanks.


8 Replies
Posts: 352
(@pmscientist)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago

I've got similar plans, slightly different configuration, 9 RGBW strands for 36 channels. I've also got a handful of channels already in the same area that I'd like to control with the same controller. Personally, I prefer to have some capacity to sustain a failure. If somehow I manage to not biff something, weather and other factors can always come into play.

For me, the choice would depend on what I felt my future plans might be. If I thought I'd use enough capacity in the next couple years to justify 2 ren64s, I'd probably go that route. Otherwise, with just those two as options, I'd lean towards 3 ss16's and at least a spare ss16 PCB for a bit of redundancy.

What I'd really prefer is 2 Ren32s with a spare PCB. That would allow the use of 4 channel external SSRs. My reasoning there is the SSR seems the most likely single area for failure. As such, having a main control board with integrated SSRs presents, a more complex repair, should that become necessary. Worst case you've got an unusable channel (well, short of total board failure). Those conditions are easier to recover from with modular SSR control.


Reply
Macrosill
Posts: 9739
(@macrosill)
Member
Joined: 19 years ago

In the past I used 2 Ren24s to control my Mega Tree. Its is a perfect fit. 3 Ren16s would work out well also. I would advise against remote ssrs for a mega tree. Too much cabling between control wires and power in a small space. It gets to become a mess. I know, I did that my 1st year.


Reply
cnbales
Posts: 503
(@cnbales)
Honorable Member
Joined: 15 years ago

I agree with Macrosill. I have a 34 channel Mega Tree and use 2 Ren 24SS boards to control it. If I used a Ren 64 for it I would have 9 Cat 5 cables going into it. Also, looking at your signature line it looks like you used a Ren 24 this year, but you had two spare channels. If you can afford to use 2 Ren 24's it would provide you with extra channels in the event that a triac goes bad.


Reply
JasonPortwood
Posts: 753
(@jasonportwood)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago

I used a Ren64 for my tree the first year I went DIY with 32 channels (R/G 16 channels each). It was a bit crazy. I'm now in my second year using 2 Renard24's and loving the set up (R/W/G). A lot easier to manage.

I do run an SSR over to it for the 3 channel star and my strobes. I plan on using one of DirkNerkle's little addons to add more channels to the Ren24 so I can have one less long CAT5 cable running across the yard.

This year I have a Red / White / Green mega tree with the Red as the spiral color. Best decision I ever made to make it a spiral.

Jason


Reply
Page 1 / 2
Share: