dirknerkle wrote:Okay, so I bought the "upgrade" for $49. I purchased LSP last year, so I thought the upgrade was a good choice. Here's my experience with it so far...The web site said I would receive my License Key immediately. Well, close, but certainly not immediately. It took about a half hour via email.
I installed the upgrade. When I started it, it told me the existing license was not valid for LSP 2.0. I expected that, since it was a license for 1.8. But I had my new license key, so I entered it into the space provided, and clicked INSTALL.
Errors abound. It was unable to validate my license key which I had just received via email. It suggested that I try it again. So I did. I tried it about a dozen times. Nada.
I had hoped that the new and improved version was, well, new and improved. But what I'm seeing is just more of the same. 🙁
Hi Dave,
I am not sure why you have had the issue, I have not heard of it before from other users. Perhaps somehow you did mot receive the correct downloaded version.
Really sounds like you had one error rather than "Errors abound" but I can fully understand your frustration.
You might try this...
Go to the home page of LSP
Download the free trial
use the new key you were provided via the e-mail
If that does not work can you let me know,I would like to get to the bottom of the issue so if other users have it I can help them out.
The issue with the registration is caused by a proxy so it wasnt the actual LSP software that has caused the issue. There have been server issue over at LSP due to the high demand
fasteddy wrote:So beside the authenticating issue your seeing have you at least given the demo a run as you seem to be basing the whole function and stability of LSP on an authentication issue. For someone of your calibre i would think you would at least look a bit deeper than just at the authentication issue before righting it off.
Have you tried what I suggested?
I still think Dave is missing his mark on the new version. I agree with Dirk about first time impressions. They are very important. In an email I received from him he states that the normal prices are 99, 249, an 399 yet when you look at his website the prices are 129, 299, and 449 This is also conflicting. My confusion here is do I plunk down the $49 now in hopes that he will fix the problems, or wait for a while longer and pay a lot more for the upgrade.
I think this other thing that annoys me is that I offered to help test and he declined. In fact several of my email were just ignored. I am concerned that this pattern will not change.
I also suspect that many of the problems I was having with LSP ver 1.8 are still there.
N7XG wrote:I also suspect that many of the problems I was having with LSP ver 1.8 are still there.
Are you basing your comments that there are some inconsistencies in the web site? If that is true you probably would not buy any software. One can pick apart little things like this that don't have anything to do with the operation of the software. Just try the new version and post accurate comments. You will obviously find things you dont like but at least try it before making comments like "I also suspect that many of the problems I was having with LSP ver 1.8 are still there."
Rather than just guess, why not try it and report accurate facts rather than suspicions. Why plunk anything down, try the trial version for free.........
I have made a suggestion to Dirk about how to possibly correct his issue but have not heard if that resolved it or not. He probably has not had time to try it yet.
I will attempt to answer any questions related to the product but am tired of and wont respond any further , as another user stated, to the "the holy sequencing wars".
Update...
After multiple tries, reboots, reinstalls, and even trying different computers, the software FINALLY authenticated. It could have been a server issue, but the only time it worked was when I typed the serial number in all lower case. In upper case (which is what is delivered to the user) it never worked. It may have been situational, but even so, the registration mechanism is an integral part of the software and whatever is used, be it the Internet or otherwise, there's little excuse for not preparing for it. LSP uses the Qsetup system for its installation method and Qsetup has internal as well as web-based authentication capability. Qsetup's web-side mechanism is not bulletproof and has some real weaknesses. Having used Qsetup myself, I'm quite aware of what it does well and what it does poorly.
Just as a test last night, I imported a working Vixen sequence, configured the controller, verified with the controller test that it was correct, turned on the outputs and ran the sequence. Nothing worked except the audio. This was exactly the same experience I had with version 1.8, so as far as the end result is concerned, it doesn't appear that much has changed.
I hope others have more success with LSP than I have had and for them, I wish them all the best and will applaud their accomplishments. For me, it appears that it's just another piece of software I can't use, and I have many, many more important things to do than to mess with it any more.
Oh, but I love the holy wars. As long as people are reporting (with or without slant) it's good. If it degrades to pure name calling, that's worthless. The way I see this is, someone had a great idea and some (or most) of the knowledge to develop it into a product. Tried and hasn't got there yet. Decided to charge for continuing efforts. So at this point you buy it as is and don't expect anything more or Buy it even though it won't do what you want, to support it with hopes it will get there someday maybe. I have done this many times with software I really wanted to see become a real product. However I will be watching on the sidelines for this software.
One thing that I noticed when trying to output to controllers is that every time I open LSP, the check marks next to your controllers in the "configure output" screen become unchecked. I have to go in and re-check them every time I open LSP. Check this to see if this is why you did not get any output.
I too also had a REG Problem... I think I was one of the first. It was fixed the next day.
If you read the email sent after purchase, is says: "We are very sensitive to your time and our support staff will process your order as soon as possible." I'm not sure anywhere it said instantly, Esp with an upgrade, they have to verify you are allowed an upgrade price
Playback doesn't lag as much, file sizes are MUCH smaller. I haven't started to sequence yet, because I went major RGB this year, and 1.8 just couldn't do that. Now I can start!
Okay, I stuck a toe in the water, downloaded the trial version and have a report as to what I observed.
Disclosure: I have written an unauthorized enhancement to the Adjustable Preview plug-in for Vixen. However, I am not involved in any way with any current Vixen development. I am a C# .NET software developer in my job that pays for this habit (Among other things, I do human/computer interface modeling. In laymans terms this means I make the user interface look and work easily for the human.) I have used Vixen for 1 year. I have never used LSP before.
Now on with my review:
I downloaded LSP 2.0 demo and installed it. Opened it up and imported one of my Vixen sequences. 216 channels imported in about 95 seconds. I then opened the same sequence in Vixen to compare side-by-side to ensure the import went okay. This is where I have to give LSP strike one. The tail end of my sequence was at the front, many channels did not import properly, channel colors did not import, channel names did not import and LSP could not find the audio to my sequence even though I have the standard Vixen 2.1 install. See attached Screen shots for examples of channel error. Importing is a basic function and the Vixen file is a simple xml file. I reverse engineered the format in about 35 minutes, so I don't know how LSP has got it so wrong.
Okay, so I try a simpler, shorter sequence. Imported in about 15 seconds. However, still could not find the audio, channels were still fubar, end of sequence was at the beginning, etc.
Next, I create a sequence. Strike two. I have a modern system (Dual core T3400 @ 2.17GHz, 3 GB ram, Windows 7, current patches and all drivers up-to-date - this is how I earn my bread and butter after all) and LSP lagged horribly. I would go to select an area for a fade and it would hiccup on the audio the whole time I was doing so. I saw you could turn off this Audio scrubbing feature and it got a little better, still lagged at an uncomfortable level. I struggled through and got a few seconds of a sequence done. I have a test rig setup right now with 24 channels available. I tried to see what the sequence looked like and could not get ANY output to go to the controller (A Renard SS24.) I checked that I had the outputs configured properly and that they were enabled, both were correct. I then realized that it was only allowing me to configure one of my output (I have two XBee explorers on two com ports and only one could be configured through LSP.)
I did find some of the features in LSP exciting. For example, layers. You can put a set of channels in a layer and work on them independently of all your other channels. I like this. Second feature which I like was the preview. Much, Much better than AP in Vixen. Want a multi- channel arch? A couple of clicks and you're done. Mini trees? Click, drag. Click, drag. Click, drag. - you got 3! Some of the items I could not get oriented the way I wanted, but overall, much more powerful than anything in Vixen 2.1. Okay, I have a preview done now, let's see what it looks like.
Strike three. LSP played back about 3/4 of a second and then locked up! I had saved my sequence, so I forced a shutdown of LSP and reopened and reloaded. This time it played. It is nice to see your preview with more realistic images.
After the third strike, I decided to give up. It looks like LSP will eventually become a fine product, but it suffers from what I call .0 syndrome. I try to avoid 1.0, 2.0, 3.0, etc. releases and wait until the .1 version of each. LSP is too buggy for my liking for the time being. When 2.1 comes out, I'll try it out then and let you know what I found.
Regards -- John







