The way I read the standard, technically solid is for backbone installations and the stranded is for equipment connections to the backbone system. It is assumed the Backbone will be a permanent physical installation and the equipment connections will be movable.
However, it is good practice to never use solid for any type of movable cabling.
Most of my cables are solid CCA... I know shame on me... But its cheap... I've used about 3 1000ft rolls. The only broken wire I've had was this year... And only because the wife decided to drive on the edge of the drive... Instead of driving over the cable in the PVC pipe... My cable issues are the clip breaking off the end... But in 4 years I fixed one cable because of broken wires... my original display is using all of the same cables (gets packed away with element). So I have plenty of cables 4 years old...
DaveJZ wrote:Most of my cables are solid CCA... I know shame on me... But its cheap... I've used about 3 1000ft rolls. The only broken wire I've had was this year... And only because the wife decided to drive on the edge of the drive... Instead of driving over the cable in the PVC pipe... My cable issues are the clip breaking off the end... But in 4 years I fixed one cable because of broken wires... my original display is using all of the same cables (gets packed away with element). So I have plenty of cables 4 years old...
As with anything, there are those that use what is handy or cheap and get away with it.. It is not "best practices" by any means, but that is not to say it won't work.. I wouldn't recommend anyone do it with solid if they have a choice.. but it will technically work.. it just has limitations..
I got a 1000 foot solid core CAT5 roll from Menards my first year and the only failure I’ve had was one that a squirrel bit in half, three minutes after I made it and put it in my yard. One of the ends usually gets a 90° bend, each year, within the last couple of inches that gets plugged into a controller.
I’ve made quite a few cables with CAT6 too but it’s not exactly my favorite. Besides the string and separator in the middle needing to be cut off, the wires have more twist and take more time to straighten out. You can’t argue with free though. :biggrin2:
I was told that solid was bad then and I’m hearing that’s still bad now. :unsure: The original cables are now 10 years old. These cables may be retiring this year as I’m intending to go fully wireless next season. Now if I could just figure out how to get rid of the power cords. 😆
plasmadrive wrote:The way I read the standard, technically solid is for backbone installations and the stranded is for equipment connections to the backbone system. It is assumed the Backbone will be a permanent physical installation and the equipment connections will be movable.However, it is good practice to never use solid for any type of movable cabling.
I agree. If you're going to buy cable, stranded is probably a better choice with negligable cost impact. For those who have free cable available, that's awesome! In a pinch, I would grab my solid core spool to replace a cable without a second thought.
FWIW, the standards do suggest solid core in walls and stranded for patch cables. But they don't suggest using the cables for running DC RGB lights, PWM modulation for control of incandescent light dimming, transmission of RS485 serial data, or stringing all of this cable through your yard in the rain/snow! 🙂 So I think we're all operating outside the accepted best practices! 🙂
Not suggesting one way over another, however, I have been using the same solid core cat5 cables built by me for the past 3 years now with no failures. These are also laid out usually around -15C (November) and are pulled out usually around -23C (January) with temperatures easily dipping to -30 to -40C.
If you build and treat your cables well they will be good to you. I wrap mine over under once they are warm so that they don't have any stress once unraveled to install them. Usually at tear down I will get them out from under the snow and then move them into the house uncoiled to warm up before handling them too much.
kingofkya wrote:One more little gotcha if cable has been bent for any length of time, NEVER EVER reuse it. I started cutting the ends off the ends so no one could reuse em at work:) I have ripped out nearly 10k cat5 patch cables, to solve the random failures of thous reused cables, and my weekends or night emergency calls has gone from 5 a month to one every 4 months. Unfortunately its never a simple cable swap anymore always a more complex issue.Its always the little things.... on often cheap things.
Yes, micro fractures in any high speed cable cause reflections. We have the issues in data, but we also have it in RF. When we are working on wireless devices, microphones in ear monitor systems, we are always looking for points of reflection.
I don't have very many Cat5 cables anymore since I've gotten away from my distributed SSR model but I used lots of solid cable with no failures. To be fair though this was premium stuff - not only STP (not that we need STP but it has an extra jacket of foil and plastic) but it's double jacketed as well - it could withstand tanks driving over it I think. I still have tons of it (I think literally...) left...
budude wrote:I don't have very many Cat5 cables anymore since I've gotten away from my distributed SSR model but I used lots of solid cable with no failures. To be fair though this was premium stuff - not only STP (not that we need STP but it has an extra jacket of foil and plastic) but it's double jacketed as well - it could withstand tanks driving over it I think. I still have tons of it (I think literally...) left...
What's scrap price these days? [emoji2]
DaveJZ wrote:What's scrap price these days? [emoji2]
I hear ya - that along with about 60 40/50' extension cords there's probably a good bit of copper there...
