I'm not trying to start a debate but I thought responding to these points was important.
Entropy wrote:I don't like the Basic Stamp as they offer basically no growth/migration path to anything else.
Any compiler that supports BASIC is a growth path. I have been developing on the PIC for years using PICBasic, works great.
I'm also avoiding the Propeller for the same reason - they only offer different packages of the same chip currently, there is no way to "downscale" a project that doesn't need all of the resources offered, and there is no way to "upscale" to a larger controller.
You are correct in that you can't go down, but the Prop II is coming out this year so you will be able to go up. With that said if I need an inexpensive or smaller package processor I either use the SX or a small Pic.
Also, 4 clocks per instruction in this day and age, combined with the fact that the Prop uses a weird bytecode-interpreted language (There are ways to do native, but they cost money and are apparently quite difficult) really cripples the chip despite running at something like 80 MHz and having 8 cores.
The Prop development environment is object oriented and the weird byte-code language not only saves on space but is very similar to python. You have 4 choices of languages for the Prop
Spin (byte code) - takes up very little space, but is a touch slow
ASM - Very fast, but uses more space
BASIC - Compiles code from BASIC to ASM
C - There are both free and commercial compilers
"Not having to deal with interrupts" is a horrible reason to choose a microcontroller - polling I/O is awfully inefficient, and learning how to work with interrupts is not hard at all - it's included in the "blinky" tutorials for nearly any microcontroller.
Interrupts is one reason (of many) that hobbyists enjoy the prop. With that said, another way to put this is I have 8 processors in one while interrupts do work well I don't miss them, I launch my code into a new processor and I'm done.
Don't get me wrong I don't dislike other micros, and I have used Pics for years, I just find using the Prop enjoyable and flexible. When I started with the Prop initially I missed the onboard hardware (UART, EEProm, I2C) of the PIC line but I got used to it. Now, if I need a UART or A/D converter on a pin I just load some code and done. If you want to check out a project that uses the power of the Prop check out my PropController.
And above all else remember, opinions are like belly buttons everyone has one. 😉
I was with you. I'm now starting to understand it. After you do some basic reading and want to take it a step further, look at some of the source code for the Renard debug firmware. I had been working creating standalone wireframe controllers. I didn't implement anything yet, but I now have standalone 8 channel controllers customized for two of my future wireframes. These use basic, but custom code.
Also, there was some code provided for a different PIC to control 12 Output Falling Snow LED lights. I have that and while I was waiting for the PICs to come from Mouser, I modified the code to work with 8 outputs on the 16f688's I had on-hand.
In short, just get some code and play around with a Breadboard or a Renard controller. I have been having a lot of fun. Of course, you don't have to be in a hurry. For the first year, I was just a button pusher. As a result of the Falling Snow stuff, I decided I wanted to understand more.
My goal for this year is to understand how to manage incoming and outgoing data to the PIC.
Good Luck!
Edit: Sorry, I have no business replying to this thread. I read your first post and responded. Clearly the experts have chimed in. I assumed you were talking just learning PIC stuff. I'm hush up now!
Even if you choose to program in a HLL like C, learning the basics of assembler is a good thing in the micro-controller world.
David_AVD wrote:Even if you choose to program in a HLL like C, learning the basics of assembler is a good thing in the micro-controller world.
True, you are bound to use it at some point.
I'm a little late to this conversation, but THIS book is one that I picked up and have really liked.
I actually found it on overstock.com back in the day for a really good price.
