Well, what goes in should come out the other end, to be sure. That's the whole point of the Ren-W, that it's a direct, serial line replacement system that replaces the physical wire between two devices with a radio connection. There aren't many things to configure on it other than the XBee radio, and if their params aren't compatible or if it's the wrong kind of radio, things can get out of whack pretty fast. Other stuff that's generally bad news:
* using .1uf instead of 1uf caps around the MAX232 chip is a bad idea...
* plugging in/unplugging items while the Ren-W is powered up is generally not very successful...
* Ren-W does not have a native duplex mode (although you can tap various pins on the XBee to create it)
I used 1uf electrolytics and NEVER unplugged chips while it was powered up. Thats what I was thinking about communicating with the XBee. I should see the responses back from it using the AT commands. It does change baud rate, parity, etc... but the output doesnt look right. Printing up a shipping label tonight and putting it in the mail tomorrow. Thanks Dave
Dave
I'm surprised by the limited distance. I have a transmitter which is an explorer board with an xbee-pro (888-XBP24-ASI-001) and the external ant (712-ANT-2.4-PW-QW). My receiver is an SMA board with an xbee-pro(888-XBP24-ASI-001) and the external ant (712-ANT-2.4-PW-QW).
The explorer board is mounted in an all plastic box(the antenna is inside the box also), The receiver in question is in a cg-2000 box with a renard 24ss and ren-w(note the there are two renard 24ss very close to each other but not in the same box) and the ant is inside the box (antenna is on oppisite side of box from the tranformer in the ren24ss. The pair of renard 24ss control a 32 channel mega tree and the controllers are inside the tree near the top of the tree (about 25 ft high). The mega tree is about 15 feet from the receiver and it works fine. If I move the receiver out of the window(line of site) it can't connect to the tree.
I know that the antenna should not be in either box and that the mega tree wires cause issues to reduce the distance. My transmitter was place in the box because of small kids breaking the antenna. As for the mega tree I should have moved the antenna outside the box(maybe drop it out the bottom).
My surprise was not that I was hoping for 140 foot of distance but I thought that the 30 foot with the setup would be fine. Lesson learn is that there is too much interference from the mega tree since I have other receivers not near the mega tree setup the same way without any problems which are much farther away.
I plan on a two part solution to the problem for next year. My transmitter will have an external antenna(kids are getting older) with a higher gain of 7 dBi which I have purchased from e-bay. I will also drop the antenna from the top of the mega tree thru the bottom with an rp-sma extension cable to help with interference. I plan to add another wireless tree(spiral) next year which will be about twice as far away from my transmitter.
Like I said I was a little surprised by the distance but, I hope that I have a working solution for next year. My hope is that people going wireless with mega trees plan ahead a little better then I did with antenna setups. Other solutions exist such as repeaters but since my whole display is only 50ft by 25ft and the tranmitter is on the edge of the area(at most 40' from any point in the yard not including height)(inside the house) I hope that the repeater solution will not be needed.
You said if you move the transmitter out of sight it won't connect. I take it your transmitting Ren-W is inside the house and has to go through a wall/window. Depending on what is between the transmitter and receiver, distance can vary widely. If your window frame is metal, for example, it may reflect the transmission and create a dead zone in the receiption area. Putting the receiver in the top of a mega tree where the many strings of light converge creates a sort of Faraday cage and while the wavelength at 2.4ghz is pretty short, there could easily be so much electromagnetic interference up there that the receiver can't discern the signal out of the mess very easily and therefore, you have to be a lot closer to get a better signal.
We learn things every year about this wireless stuff, and one thing I learned a couple years ago is that it was possible to create an operating environment where it was impossible for the radios to work reliably, if at all. I expected it to work through 4 or 5 walls with metal siding, through window frames having a few thousand lights, through a set of net-lights and through a steel-reinforced concrete slab in addition to two walls of concrete block. Well, it hardly worked at all. Only occasionally would the controller respond. When I moved the transmitter outside so that it had a direct line-of-sight angle to the receiver it started working fine. Well, that taught me something... and after I analyzed the first situation I realized I was asking the radios to do the impossible.
So then.... In next years plan.. An XBee radio should transmit how far with direct sight??? I'm looking at a display at the in-laws place and could get the XBee in direct sight, however distance may be an issue... Now I'll add this, my display is in front of my house, and I would be transmitting to the rear of the house with radio on roof of both homes. Level ground. Just curious on the distance I should get if I went this route.
