Beyond Forward-Phas...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Beyond Forward-Phase Dimmers

21 Posts
10 Users
0 Reactions
8,040 Views
Posts: 6728
Topic starter
(@p-short)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 19 years ago
[#18005]

I wonder it's time to start looking for a replacement approach to dimming strings. The current triac-based approach generates a lot of garbage on the AC power lines, which I think is the cause of some of the current 'flicker' problems, and is likely to get worse as the number of channels increases. Some of the flickering problems may be helped by using snubbers, snubberless triacs, and MT1-Gate resistors on the SSRs, but these solutions don't reduce the amount of noise going back into the AC lines.

Possible approaches are reverse-phase dimming (not clear if this would be cleaner than forward-phase dimming), or an attempt at sine-wave dimming. I think that any alternative approach is going to be more expensive than the current triac-based forward-phase dimming.

Does this seem like something worth pursuing, or will the issue become moot with the increasing popularity of individually-controlled RGB pixels? At the moment I think that it's already too late to do much for the 2012 season, other than limited testing in anticipation of the 2013 deployment.


20 Replies
dirknerkle
Posts: 10310
(@dirknerkle)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

I'm personally in favor of exploring new dimming ideas but if an approach is found to be at not only greater complexity but expense as well, it puts it out of the reach of the average DIY'er. I think the hobby is already expensive enough and that other potential solutions might be explored. For example, what can be done to create "cleaner" power?

The current method of dimming is certainly cost-effective for the DIY individual, and as an alternative, perhaps the creation of some anti-garbage filtering device might be explored. If inexpensive enough, it could possibly be something like a dongle and placed between the controller and the a/c line to prevent the injection of additional noise from the controller into the power system.

Another approach might be to create power supplies that provided clean 120vdc and power lights with that using existing PWM concepts with MOSFETS (or other power components?) instead of triacs.


Reply
Posts: 789
(@chilloutdocdoc)
Prominent Member
Joined: 18 years ago

I think it's worth pursuing.. However as a lot of people are pursing DC based dimming. I think there's less issue as long as you use a GOOD power supply for that. I do like the idea of forward phase dimming, but how much complexity and cost does it add to the controller? I don't know a whole lot about the whole concepts of electricity. But for a cost reducing effort, do you think we could shrink down the "power available" per channel? Frankly, most of my channels are only loaded with .2 to .33 amps, and the peak is 1A. Why do we need to have something capable of 2A or 3A or 5A. What about LED channels that only have on the order of 100mA per channel. Why have a 4 or 8 amp triac.

I heard at one point somebody had mentioned that you could PWM AC using two mosfets (in opposite polarity in order to catch both sides of the Sine Wave) not sure how "right" they were. What about one mosfet and rectified AC? They had mentioned that it would be less noise, but I'm not sure about the electronics behind of it. Only in my early years of college learning about all of this stuff.

A lot of ideas to toss around, but it's all about weighing the options, and the cost v improvement.

my $.002 (my advice isn't worth all that much)


Reply
steve_hirst
Posts: 296
(@steve-hirst)
Reputable Member
Joined: 17 years ago

I think that even if it is more expensive that there are some of us that would prefur to spend more and have a better show. It will depend on the price but if its within reason i'm sure it will be used.


Reply
budude
Posts: 10400
(@budude)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 18 years ago

It would be neat to integrate the BAM/MIBAM dimming into a DC version of the code for the Renards. It produces much smoother dimming and requires less updates/power from the PIC.


Reply
Page 1 / 5
Share: