With the recent thread of seeing a long-time member sign off for good, and in that same thread several others talking about how they are going to be right behind him soon, this got me thinking about the future of this forum.
I've been in a number of other groups and forums where membership essentially was closed off due to circumstances. I watched them wither and die. It's sad to see, especially to once-vibrant spaces.
I know I've never been a regular here... I pop in at times... but now that there is a serious lack of places to discuss actual DIY decorating, I'd hate to see it go away. I don't know of another forum, or an active FB group, that covers the same space, with the exception of the "green forum" which seems to be going through similar issues.
So I throw this out there: Is there a way to turn it around? The general maker spaces out there still seem to be thriving. Facebook is dying. It might seem that a forum like this could bounce back. But we'd need to make an effort at broadening the scope from "support of mostly legacy DIY hardware from the past" to things that newer decorators could embrace.
The Pixel Radio project from a couple years ago (which I just discovered recently) is an example of the type of project that could really get some interest I think, if more people knew about it.
The hobby as a whole seems to be thriving... but it's morphed into buying coro props that you pop pixels in and play sequences downloaded from the internet. There are a handful of people still doing innovation but it gets drowned out by all the "where can I find a sequence of" and "where can I buy a prop that is a..." posts.
As for me, I don't know how many years before I hang it up either. In my mind I'd love to do it forever until I become dust, but I lose my second boy to college next year (construction/setup help) and the joints aren't creaking any less... I love projects though, so I'd love to have a place to hang even long after I hang it up.
Just like the return of vinyl records over digital media, I have to believe that "doing it yourself" can make a comeback as well.
Last night I re-arranged the playlists for our show into daily playlists and discovered something interesting. We have 40+ sequences that we pick and choose from for each night, of which 3 were done from "outside sources". The other 37+ were sequenced right here between my wife and myself. There is quite a bit of satisfaction in doing this and seeing the reactions of those who stop to watch the display makes it all worthwhile.
Yes - I buy coro props. (Don't have a CNC machine - yet.) Yes - I do plug in pixels bought from various vendors. I do, however, design/build/implement all the non-coro props. Satisfaction from this runs very high. The reactions I get from visitors is amazing. "Nothing like this any where else" is one of the greatest compliments I have received.
When the work involved with setting up a pre-built/pre-sequenced/someone-else-designed show begins to drag on those that don't do it themselves finally becomes a true "drag", I hope those doing it this way come to the realization that there is a whole new (to them) adventure in creation and implementation of their own work. Heck, have some T-Shirts made up promoting your show, then wear them out in public. When people ask you can honestly say, "I built this!"
Remember that sharing your ideas, getting new ones, and showing off the results is what DIYC is all about!
With the kids out of the house, the show has scaled back a bit, but I still enjoy helping people understand how the Computer Controlled Christmas “sausage” gets made. I don’t expect to design the next generation of controllers anymore—most of my creative energy now goes into making setup and teardown easier, designing modular components for compact storage, and building things that will last for decades instead of ending up in the landfill after just a couple of seasons.
My next project is a modular PVC pipe fence using 12 mm nodes spaced every few inches. The entire design will break down into individual lengths of PVC for easy storage. By swapping pine garland for black garland and spider webs, it can be used for Halloween; add colorful foliage for Thanksgiving; then rewrap it with pine garland for Christmas—one prop, three months of use.
I’m also proud to say that none of my sequences are store-bought. I generally don’t reuse sequences from year to year, because I’m always adding or removing props, which keeps things fresh and forces me to rethink the show.
As @tfischer rightly points out, “The hobby as a whole seems to be thriving… but it’s morphed into buying coro props that you pop pixels in and play sequences downloaded from the internet.” I’ve tried some of that myself, and while it absolutely has its place, the novelty wore off for me pretty quickly. These days, when I watch The Great Christmas Light Fight, I can often recognize specific props or controllers—and sometimes you can spot when a show leans heavily on off-the-shelf solutions.
To Al’s point, there’s so much more to this hobby than blinking lights. There will always be people who are perfectly happy buying a prop, popping in pixels, and running a purchased sequence—and that’s great. But there will also always be others who want to understand why things work, how deep the rabbit hole goes, and how the sausage is made. That curiosity and problem-solving mindset is what originally built this community, and it’s still very much alive.
-Tony
I try really hard to not knock anyone who takes time to put up any lights much less a larger synchronized display. Everyone has their way of doing things, and as such we think our way is the "perfect balance".
I do think there is a subset of people out there that want to build stuff. I think there's another subset out there that doesn't even realize you CAN build cool stuff, reasonably easily. I think a forum like this could easily pivot to accept these people. This forum has always been hardware-centric but there have been cool display prop (and even float) builds documented too, so it isn't a terrible stretch.
In order to get new people to come and stay, we need to make sure there's content to keep them here. The more things dwindle down, the harder that becomes.
I started this thread hoping we can save things before it passes the tipping point.
I've been adding seed pixels to Dollar Store wireframes, it's hard to beat $1.25. But the choices are limited and I want some different shapes. I'm looking at making my own wireframes, typically 1/8 inch wire or so. I may want to create three dimensional frames too, like the old deer frames that use to be everywhere.
